saulocf

Gosh. How hard is to quote a theme from another composer? Giacchino's theme isn't great, but it is very memorable. Already disappointed.

Awful movie. One of the worst movies ever created, no kidding.

Fixed.. had Portuguese keyboard by accident

You know what? I wouldn’t be surprised if this went back to Giacchino. It would make a lot of sense: JJ involvement, Bad Robots picture, and I suspect he didn’t score MI 5 because he was busy in 2015. It wouldn’t be my first choice, but better than Balfe

Does anyone else think that Williams lost the opportunity to compose a theme for the Kylo/Rey dynamic? I think it was the heart of the movie and should have its own theme, and play in full force when they are fighting together. Also, would have been awesome to hear the “Wills” theme from Giacchino’s Rogue one when the Jedi books are shown, but I know that it is asking to much

I am the only one that hear a very strong similarity of Rose's theme with Giacchino's Yorktown theme from Star Trek: Beyond?

It ain’t bad. It’s a fun score, underrated like the movie.

I would actually prefer it, now that you mentioned it

Oh no, I don't blame Williams at all, she is a fabulous actress, just like Sophie Turner. They really had luck with the casting. I just thought that the writing made her "stubborn" way to quick.

Agree on the gorgeous, disagree on the crap actor. I think she is improving, but she was never as bad as people claim that she is. I think she is superior to Kit Harington in every sense. It was so forced. When did she became this cold? Wasn't last season that she almost got killed because she couldn't kill an innocent woman?

It sounds an awful lot like his Cars 2 score.

He does, but it is pretty bad. I wonder why Giacchino didn't choose to quote Tyler's instead, he seems to be the master of quoting past franchise themes and did a nice job adapting Silverstri's theme

Wait.. WHAT?!?!?!?

Except for the GREAT MoH-like action setpiece "Monumental Meltdown". I liked a lot. Here is the thing about Giacchino, his themes may not be the best nor the most complex ones (except for the Yorktown theme from ST:Beyond, that one is awesome), but he is always able to make them interesting. He is the exact opposite of Hans Zimmer (good themes, bad arrangements, orchestrations and development).

Ok, I get that.. it does not sound great by any means, I was just surprised by the "Just orchestral noise" comment, as it sounded incredibly harsh. If anything, there is some nice arrangements of the Spider-Man theme a the 0:36