• Announcements

    • Jay

      PLEASE DONATE to JWFAN if you can!   08/16/16

      Hello JWFan members,   The team behind JWFan needs your help!   We need annual donations to keep our community running   This is for the domain name, IPBoard license, and server space.   We hope you can help use with a donation of any size.   Use this link or the link on the mainpage. Thank you!   The Administration team
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Josh500

What are the differences between Raiders March and Tintin's Heroic Theme in terms of what they express?

Which do you prefer? (I am sure RM will win, but who knows? Maybe some of you prefer this "new and fresh" heroic theme by JW!)   27 members have voted

  1. 1. Which do you prefer?

    • Raiders March
      22
    • Tintin's Heroic Theme
      5

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

70 posts in this topic

If you take the most heroic renditions of Raiders March ("Flight from Peru," "Desert Chase," "The German Sub") and the most heroic renditions of Tintin's Heroic Theme ("Escape from Karaboudjan" and "Pursuit of the Falcon"), that is. Do you think these 2 themes are interchangeable? Why? Why not?

In my opinion, the Raiders March is overly optimistic and cheerful, very heroic but slightly clumsy and funny too; it perfectly expresses the sense of Indy "being in over his head (yet again!)."

Tintin's Theme on the other hand strikes me as less optimistic, less cheerful, not clumsy or funny whatsoever; it's still very heroic but somewhat in a bookish, studious, and more detached way (I am not sure whether you'd agree here, but tell me what you think!). In a way, it's more "balanced" than Raiders March, i.e. there isn't as much going on here, emotionally (although the fact that Tintin's theme is considerably shorter may have something to do with it, of course).

Well? What's your opinion?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IMO Tintin's theme is one of the most interesting and catchy themes JW wrote in a long time!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tintin actually doesn't have just one but 3 different thematic identities in the film. There is the main heroic theme, the secondary sleuthing/action theme and finally the small quirky motif for solving riddles. Williams treats each of these areas with its own thematic idea and I would love to hear him combine all three into a concert suite. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been underestimating this theme for some time... Sure, there's Haddock's Theme, the Dueling theme, Snowy's theme, etc. which are all more complex than Tintin's theme, but Tintin's theme is quite wonderful to listen to!

The closest thing to Raiders March and Luke Skywalker's theme JW wrote, maybe. Well, in terms of a heroic theme played principally by a trumpet (or a French horn), that is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When I hear Tintin's theme I think of Allo Allo.

When I hear the Raiders March I think of Harrison Ford being punched.

Indy wins!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tintin actually doesn't have just one but 3 different thematic identities in the film. There is the main heroic theme, the secondary sleuthing/action theme and finally the small quirky motif for solving riddles. Williams treats each of these areas with its own thematic idea and I would love to hear him combine all three into a concert suite. :)

Yes. Definitely!

And if JW does Tintin 2 as well, maybe we'll get more themes associated with Tintin and his escapades! :)

Tintin's theme, of course ;)

Just so we all know what we're talking about... ;)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31sdNPbBL3o

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tintin's theme is an enormous missed opportunity. Quite possibly Williams' least memorable theme for a titular character. It's grown on me a bit, but mostly only in the statements where the orchestration is interesting enough to overcome the melodic mediocrity. The Raiders March, on the other hand, is brilliant and memorable, and it wins easily.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tintin's theme is an enormous missed opportunity. Quite possibly Williams' least memorable theme for a titular character. It's grown on me a bit, but mostly only in the statements where the orchestration is interesting enough to overcome the melodic mediocrity. The Raiders March, on the other hand, is brilliant and memorable, and it wins easily.

Let me guess. Tintin's theme rubs you the wrong way! :P

But I gotta say, I disagree with you. Tintin's theme is perfect for the character. And as to orchestration... an interesting orchestration is needed for Raiders March too, duh. Still, yeah, a concert version on the OS album would have been nice... although, of course, we might still be getting that!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll have to agree with datameister. sadly, tintin's theme didn't do much for me at all. same thing with the whole score.

ok... sir francis and the unicorn is pretty fantastic, I must admit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll have to agree with datameister. sadly, tintin's theme didn't do much for me at all. same thing with the whole score.

ok... sir francis and the unicorn is pretty fantastic, I must admit.

Well to each their own. ;)

But for me, it's fast becoming one of my all-time favorite scores, on the same level as HP 1-3.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I went with the Raiders March. It is more thoroughly developed I feel even though I like the Tintin theme very much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Tintin's themes are fantastic but they're really not in the spotlight of this score like Indy's theme was in Raiders. I think in Tintin the main thing would be the Unicorn's theme.

(What I like about Tintin's theme in its most complete version is how it goes down and jumps, jumps again further, and then falls and manages to jump and finally "fly". In my humble opinion it's a quite expressive moment)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Tintin's themes are fantastic but they're really not in the spotlight of this score like Indy's theme was in Raiders. I think in Tintin the main thing would be the Unicorn's theme.

Hmmm yes. But surely that's because Tintin's Heroic Theme (and his other 2 themes) aren't played over the end credits, and they didn't get a concert arrangement on the OS album.

And I am thinking that this might have been done by JW on purpose... because Tintin is not supposed to be the center of attention, like Indy. He is just a blank figure without much character who gets drawn into one adventure after another.

I think Tintin's theme gets used quite a LOT throughout the movie, though . . . whenever Tintin does even something slightly heroic, or just when he is the focus of attention.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Tintin's themes are fantastic but they're really not in the spotlight of this score like Indy's theme was in Raiders. I think in Tintin the main thing would be the Unicorn's theme.

No, it's Snowy's theme, you idiot! Disappointing, Shaky Chaac, quite disappointing...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

But anyway, I think we all agree, the themes in Tintin are quite solid.

Compare, for example, the themes in Tintin with the (new) themes from KotCS! Mutt's Theme, the Crystal theme, Irina's theme, hell even the theme of the Russians...

No comparison, if you ask me!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Irina's theme and the theme for the Russians are fantastic in my opinion.

Well, they are not bad by any means, but I think any theme from Tintin is better (more memorable, effective, well-constructed) than these 2.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The themes in KOTCS are wonderful,,,

As opposed to the themes in Tintin?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes. I mean, the Tintin themes are good, but I don't think they're half as good as KOTCS. Then again, I know I'm in a minority with Call of the Crystal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes. I mean, the Tintin themes are good, but I don't think they're half as good as KOTCS. Then again, I know I'm in a minority with Call of the Crystal.

:blink:

Well, if you really think so, I won't argue with you. To be honest, personally I still can't get into the Crystal theme...

But for me (and for most of us, I am sure) the score to Tintin is far superior to the score to KotCS... and I am not talking about just the main themes, of course.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like them all, except Mutt's music, which never clicked with me. The underscore of KOTCS is a bit boring at times with moments on coolnes here and there (mushroom cloud!!). Tintin is a score with a quite exciting and colourful underscore all throurough, which is I think thereason why some prefer it to KOTCS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jeez, you sound like I've personally insulted you.

Is Tintin as a score better than KOTCS? As a whole it probably is. But theme by theme, I'd personally pick KOTCS any time. Both have the fact that I get bored listening to them relatively easily in common.

And WAR HORSE tramples over both with a big neigh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like them all, except Mutt's music, which never clicked with me. The underscore of KOTCS is a bit boring at times with moments on coolnes here and there (mushroom cloud!!). Tintin is a score with a quite exciting and colourful underscore all throurough, which is I think thereason why some prefer it to KOTCS.

Well, even if you put Tintin's theme aside for a moment, consider the Scroll theme, Sir Red Rackham's theme, Snowy's Theme, Haddock's theme, the villain's theme, the Unicorn theme...

Man! These are maybe some of the best (and most original) themes JW wrote, IMO!

Jeez, you sound like I've personally insulted you.

Why in the world would you get that impression? I was just a little surprised, that's all...

Is Tintin as a score better than KOTCS? As a whole it probably is. But theme by theme, I'd personally pick KOTCS any time. Both have the fact that I get bored listening to them relatively easily in common.

Like I said, I won't argue with you if you really think so. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I prefer Sir Red Redham's theme to the Unicron theme.

ROTFLMAO

Yeah, that's what I thought all along!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Tintin's themes are fantastic but they're really not in the spotlight of this score like Indy's theme was in Raiders. I think in Tintin the main thing would be the Unicorn's theme.

I dunno, pretty much every main theme from Tintin is based on Tintin's theme, so even if the theme itself doesn't get a lot of playing time in the film, its variations do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dunno, pretty much every main theme from Tintin is based on Tintin's theme,

Haddock's Theme, the Scroll Theme, the villain's theme, Sir Red Rackham's Theme, the Dueling Theme, Snowy's theme are based on Tintin's Theme?

so even if the theme itself doesn't get a lot of playing time in the film

But it does!

Any more, and people would be comparing it to Hedwig's theme in PS!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I went with the Raiders March. It is more thoroughly developed I feel even though I like the Tintin theme very much.

Development is overrated. When you strip both themes to their essence, it becomes clear that Tintin is the product of a subtler and more mature compositional voice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Indeed, in comparison the Raiders March comes of as gaudy, obvious and unsophisticated. Of course JW can hardly be blamed for this, since this was much earlier in his career, when he had not yet established his true style. It wasn't until scores like Nixon, Rosewood and in particular Sleepers that the modern, immaculate style of John Williams would seen the light of day.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tintin

Wait until it will have many different takes in the fortcoming Tintin sequels, after

raising to it to the full glory via many modulation. JW at his best.

Now you are used to all JW's three Indy scores. You will wait and see.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0