Jump to content

Richard Penna

Members
  • Posts

    16,597
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Richard Penna last won the day on October 23 2022

Richard Penna had the most liked content!

About Richard Penna

  • Birthday 07/06/1985

Profile

  • Title (custom text underneath your username)
    Dance the night
  • Location
    Surrey, UK

Recent Profile Visitors

21,216 profile views
  1. I love the little concert-like pieces in GoT - Light of the Seven, Jenny of Oldstones. They're very simple but oh so evocative. Some of his HotD material is little more than voices, drones and strings, but what he does with them to creative his sound is so interesting to me. What's not strong about them? I'm looking for some element with more substance than just not being at Williams' level of orchestrational complexity, because we both know there's so much more than that to an effective piece of scoring.
  2. I always try to keep my comments in the positive spirit of the discussion (hence bringing up the superb Rosewood as a replacement score example that Williams nailed) but I'm not going to restrict my words just to avoid offending a few people who are convinced that no one can ever write better than JW. The forum ceases to be a place of discussion and debate if every conversation gets derailed because someone is devasted at a suggestion tarnishing Williams' abilities. This score is largely not my thing except for a few cues and The Days Between with the beautiful guitar melody. My overall prior point was that, apart from there being nothing I hear in this score that makes it overly special within Williams' ouvre, I honestly hope that the labels' attention and resources are being spent on scores that need expanding and properly presenting more than I think this score does.
  3. A long-term rental is definitely a more appropriate way to see it - all you're "purchasing" is a license to watch the film on their platform for as long as they carry it. In fact, the whole thing is basically just a way for them to get an extra $10 from you to watch a trendy new film, and their carefully-written T&Cs cover their ass if and when they lose the agreement with the studio. Even iPlayer desktop which allows downloads, doesn't actually just give you a file to do what you want with. I believe they're stored in some sort of format that makes them expire after a period. It's all completely around controlling how and when you watch a show - for some reason all these studios are absolutely terrified of allowing you a private digital copy of a show. I'm almost surprised there has never been a legal challenge to Amazon's "purchase" terminology actually, because you're definitely not purchasing anything.
  4. I understand the password sharing crackdown - that's much more blatant receipt of something you haven't paid for. But things disappearing off services after a period is the killer for me. I'll always remember watching Kingdom of Heaven on some platform a few years ago and due to its length, I went to bed with about 5 minutes to go...... not realising that it was the last day they had it! I went back the next morning to watch the last 5 minutes and it either wasn't there or they wanted money. My response? I liked it so I bought the director's cut Blu-ray. The fact that that's a solution to that problem in 2024 is not good, and if the streamers and studios don't find a way of keeping movies on their services far more long term, then as you say, it goes back to piracy - the very thing streaming was addressing at one point. I like the idea of buying digital movies in place of discs, but again, the killer is you need to let me own a file of that download. I've given you money to buy it - you don't get to just remove it from me when you're bickering with the studio again. That's not my problem.
  5. One thing I note is that if you're prepared to pay you can watch nearly anything, and I did actually buy a movie called Secret Life of Bees from Prime when it was my book club's selection and it was only a few £s to buy (unfortunately I disliked the movie as much as the book). The problem though is that even when fully paid for, you're still at the mercy of licensing agreements so if I understand correctly, if Amazon loses their agreement for the movie you've lost access even though you paid for it. Hence I'd never buy a streaming movie for something I cared about. Hence I'd be a lot more open to a service where you paid the fee and then got to download a full HD file (20GB or so doesn't take too long on a good connection) but I suspect no studio will ever allow that because it leaves the door wide open for you to just give that file to someone else. Closest I've seen is a performer over here who films most of his shows and puts full HD copies on his website for sale. Hence for films that are important to me for one reason or another, I have to own the disc.
  6. I never saw a rental disc that had the special features stripped - certainly I never saw any messages that a feature was unavailable. Add that to the list of dumb ideas studios have made in the name of wanting more money from you. This weekend I received two things - the complete Alan Partridge box, as I'm constantly watching compilations on YT and finally decided it would be easier to just own the damn thing. Also the blu-ray of Shrek as it has a certain nostalgic importance to me and it was getting oddly difficult to find even a used copy in the usual places (I've never owned it in any format), whereas other animated movies of the period don't seem to suffer similarly. Now due to streaming I've found a lot of movies from the 90s and 00s are very difficult to find on Blu-ray whereas DVD copies are littering the planet. Hence Shrek is the first case where I decided to get a copy while available, and it won't be the last. I also have an external USB DVD drive set to region 1 so that it doesn't matter if I have an American-sourced DVD (and I have several).
  7. Thomas Newman talked in an interview once about the soloists and specialists he works with, and he had a really relaxed attitude when it comes to the musical acumen of the people he works with. Paraphrasing, he said that if someone is really good at playing <instrument> but can't read music or has difficulty in that area, he's (exact words) 'grateful to have you'. I'd imagine finding composers or players who have that magic combination of a great talent at music theory and a knack for memorable music (such as, but absolutely not exclusively, Williams) is like gold dust. The majority of creatives are likely to be one or the other - studying music theory and taking great pains to write music that's structurally inspired by the greats or writing from the heart and creating music that works for the picture, regardless of how simple it may be.
  8. Yep, I rented a heck of a lot of DVDs and Blu-rays from LoveFilm, and was very disappointed when they stopped as they had pretty much everything. Particularly as you could see all the extras and special features and generally see how good the release was, and I'm fairly sure I bought a few Blu-rays after having rented them. What's just occurred to me is why Netflix (and others) clearly have a long-term issue with licensing agreements with the studios for streaming when they could rent out films/series/etc to their heart's content as long as they had the disc. Evidently the licensing model must be very different for streaming.
  9. Nah, I don't think pearl clutching is warranted - this can hardly be compared to other cases of composers coming on late in a project and composing a massive symphonic score in a few weeks. It's a sugary family drama that quickly needed some fairly understated music which any good Hollywood composer could have done. Compare it to Rosewood where Williams provided an actual score (after that bizarre jazzy stuff which was never going to work) and delivered an excellent, thematic, celebrated score.
  10. I guess the cue list posted above might give an indication, but it doesn't tell us whether all the missing bits are 1 minute long, or whether the OST only has half the score. The reason for the replacement wasn't musical, I don't think - at least there seem to be (in the words of Torn Music) 'conflicting stories' regarding why Doyle was dropped, except for Doyle being unwell and Williams taking over. I didn't sense any suggestions that Columbus was unhappy with Doyle's music so it's unlikely to be a case where Williams saved the day. I never found the full album overly engaging outside of a few highlights - maybe it's just not my style; maybe it's an indication of time constraints to rewrite an entire score.
  11. Between this and Nosferatu, based on samples the latter probably struck me a bit more, but it's nice that this will be on streaming so we can evaluate it properly.
  12. It's fine, but at least the cues presented here don't really do anything for me... somewhat unfocused orchestral meanderings. I rather liked the film when I saw it a few decades ago, but I always thought it wasn't necessarily the sort of drama that needed that much music. Williams' score more focused with that nice guitar theme and a couple of nice tracks, but in my view if we consider the overall pantheon of scores that are awaiting proper official presentation and are worth Mike and others spending their time on, this isn't near the top.
  13. TWINE is my favourite, but partly for nostalgic reasons. It's also more balanced between the string/piano material and action which makes it an easier listen. I know TND is probably the most popular around here but for my tastes it's too loud and overbearing for the most part - I've never gotten into it. The problem for me with QoS is that I think the film is absolutely goddam awful - I sat through it once with my brother, then twice more I tried again and neither of us had a clue what was going on, what the story was, and were both thoroughly bored. Arnold absolutely did the best job anyone could have done (and I'm sure he found the film more intesting than we did) but it remains a concept album for me - 20 minutes or so of decent action music. I also unpopularly side with JNHFan2000 in that I like Newman's scores in general. The action music is a bit mixed given that (a) action is not his forte imo, and (b) some of the material at the end of Spectre is just generic fluff (considering Mendes knows how to use music well, I really question what he was thinking here) but the overall sound he gave to the scores is refreshing - his more ambient/rhythmic approach working particularly well with the early action sequences in Skyfall and the Scotland scenes later on.
  14. A luxury no doubt earned from decades at the top of the industry, but I suspect that a lot of directors/producers would be hesitant to hire him nowadays due to the lack of instant, realistic demos. Didn't Williams remark that Cuaron asked him for demos for PoA, and Willams told him it would take weeks of work? I think JW was lucky in this respect that SS/Lucas/etc were understanding of his process, and that he was active before demos were the norm. Happy to be corrected, but I wonder if this has more to do with composers wanting to be in the booth and discuss the music with the filmmakers, instead of worrying about the conducting side. However, this does go along with my general stance in this area that the effectiveness and suitability of a score for its film significantly outweighs any need for said score to be technically complex.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.