135 replies to this topic

[Ricard]

Looks like Poltergeist is as much a Spielberg film as The Empire Strikes back is Lucas'.

TESB is an Irvin Kershner film and you don't have the right to deny that.

[Ricard]

Anyway, I really don't see what this has got to do with wether the prequels should be considered starwars movies or not.

banghead

[Morn]

LOL

[Romão]

Enfin, a kind act is never lost.

[Romão]

We're not discussing where the merit or craft of any film lies, where discussing wether we have the right to dismiss integrant parts of someone else's story as not being really part of the story. None of us has the right do it because none of us is the crafter of the story. You don't want to considerer the prequels starwars, fine, but that doesn't change the fact that they are, no matter what, true starwars films.

Romão, who thinks Ricard takes some things way too seriously

[Rogue_Leader]

Star Wars Saga ....

3 movies ....

A New Hope, The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi ....

There ARE NO OTHERS ......

I leav you with this thought.

[Luke Skywalker]

Looks like Poltergeist is as much a Spielberg film as The Empire Strikes back is Lucas'.

TESB is an Irvin Kershner film and you don't have the right to deny that.

And you have to Say the Prequel trilogy is not SW?

Couldn't it be our subjective opinion?

[Rogue_Leader]

Couldn't it be our subjective opinion?

Of course it is Luke. Thats how it always works with one's own personal thoughts.

[Ricard]

Looks like Poltergeist is as much a Spielberg film as The Empire Strikes back is Lucas'.

TESB is an Irvin Kershner film and you don't have the right to deny that.

And you have to Say the Prequel trilogy is not SW?

Couldn't it be our subjective opinion?

Hmm... You mean you didn't see the sarcasm in my reply??? :?

[Ricard]

We're not discussing where the merit or craft of any film lies, where discussing wether we have the right to dismiss integrant parts of someone else's story as not being really part of the story. None of us has the right do it because none of us is the crafter of the story.  
You don't want to considerer the prequels starwars, fine, but that doesn't change the fact that they are, no matter what, true starwars films.

Of course we DO 'have the right' to dismiss them, as we 'have the right' not to consider them Star Wars films. Who are we to tell anyone whether he 'has the right' to anything. That's my point :roll:

And of course the Prequels are officially Star Wars films. But 'true' Star Wars? No way! (IMHO, of course)

Romão, who thinks Ricard takes some things way too seriously

Seriously? LOL Not at all. It's just an internet discussion

[Luke Skywalker]

Looks like Poltergeist is as much a Spielberg film as The Empire Strikes back is Lucas'.

TESB is an Irvin Kershner film and you don't have the right to deny that.

And you have to Say the Prequel trilogy is not SW?

Couldn't it be our subjective opinion?

Hmm... You mean you didn't see the sarcasm in my reply??? :?

:oops: no i didn't.

I just thought you were upset for what Merkel said.

Anyways, yes officially it is a Irving Keshner film . I agree with that. I dont agree with the Lucas didnt have to do anything with that movie.

Luke, who does not want to star an argument

[Rogue_Leader]

Too late Luke!!!

[Romão]

Anyway, it's always a pleasure to have some discussions with you guys.
We don't agree many times, but it's always great fun.

Rom~~ao, who really likes the MB

[Ricard]

beerchug

[Romão]

[Rogue_Leader]

I think Luke is trying to be too much of a peacemaker on this board. Between this and his "truce" thread I feel it is time Luke got in touch with his dark side.