289 replies to this topic

[Goldsmithfan]

Then it should have just had him and the words John Williams on the front.

Sort of like this, then?

If I could count the number of times I've spilled my seed to that image... Ah, memories.

[MissPadmé]

Well of course either the Album re-issue or the Ultimate Edition Re-issue.

[king mark]

Wow, you realized Sony Classical has not improved in a decade as far as releasing soundtracks properly

[Alexander]

[ZackR]

Not interested. At all.

Dear Sony,

Please bring on someone like Mike Matessino or Lukas Kendall or someone from LLL who knows how to do these things. Just contract the work out to them and you release it. Please? You'd have my money immediately.

[Richard Penna]

They just can't be bothered with pleasing a few thousand music fans. More money is made elsewhere.

[E.T. & Elliott]

Hey, Darth Maul is blue, right? Why is he red on the new cover...

Good catch with the Clone Wars thing. That is precisely why they're hyping Darth Maul. Holy ****, look at this cross-promotion:
http://www.starwars....turns_2012.html

[Stefancos]

What?

Maul is red in the film and everywhere BUT the TPM EU cover

[Jediking12]

Sony Classical is really misleading a ripping people off. Just for once can we get a pretty decent Prequel Trilogy soundtrack?

Like the Corelllian Edition / Star Wars Trilogy box set that came out in 2008. They just can't stop re-issuing the same Album that was released back in 2004/1997 or whatever.

Lets see what LA LA Land has in store for Star Wars

[E.T. & Elliott]

To be fair, it's partly (mostly?) John Williams' fault. If he really wanted the music out there, it would be.

[Jediking12]

you think that the Prequel Trilogy would had the same respect like the Prequels but No! its been a decade since Episode I was released and still no complete score

I'm still good with the Ultimate Edition. Although I'm mainly looking for an expanded release for Episode II and III

and maybe music for the first 2 Harry Potter films

[Faleel]

Hey Welcome bud!

[king mark]

Jediking12 is the voice of the normal fan that would buy this .Sony listen to him

[gkgyver]

and maybe music for the first 2 Harry Potter films

You didn't by some chance miss the leak of the SS recording sessions?

[king mark]

He only has 2 posts here so probably not

Well they had 10 years to properly release Harry Potter 1 before the sessions leak and an official release is now useless except for owning a physical c.d.. I hope the same happens with the Prequels

[gkgyver]

Well, he just posted here, but that doesn't mean he didn't live until then.
The thing leaked at other places too.

[E.T. & Elliott]

Supposedly, Lucasfilm was "seriously considering" releasing the [complete] prequel scores. I guess they didn't consider it seriously enough.

[Faleel]

Jediking12 knows about the leak.

[king mark]

The unreleased music in The Old Republic (added to previous game material) was the tipping point where official releases for expanded SW Prequels are not so important to me anymore. Seriously, that thing is sort of like a sessions leak

[Trent Bennett]

you think that the Prequel Trilogy would had the same respect like the Prequels but No! its been a decade since Episode I was released and still no complete score

I'm still good with the Ultimate Edition. Although I'm mainly looking for an expanded release for Episode II and III

and maybe music for the first 2 Harry Potter films

You haven't heard the Phantom Menace score until you've heard the intended edition.. It is by far WAY better than the so called "Ultimate Edition". Grant the "Ultimate Edition" was nice to have for the new and remastered music, at the same time it fell short because it essentially was an isolated score.

[E.T. & Elliott]

I'll take your word for it, KM.

[Jediking12]

and maybe music for the first 2 Harry Potter films

You didn't by some chance miss the leak of the SS recording sessions?

Yeah I do have that. But I meant an Official Product. I'm not too much of a fan of Fan made Albums unless it has no SFX like the SS Recording Sessions

Supposedly, Lucasfilm was "seriously considering" releasing the [complete] prequel scores. I guess they didn't consider it seriously enough.

I heard of back in 2002 A Ultimate Edition to Episode II was suppose to be released but the people at Lucasfilm LTD got pissed off at Sony Classical so they never actually released one -___-

[king mark]

why did the people at Lucasfilm get pissed off at Sony classical?

[gkgyver]

I didn't read about any video game release containing tons of unreleased Episode 3 music. Is that buried in the Prequel resource thread?

[Jediking12]

why did the people at Lucasfilm get pissed off at Sony classical?

Because the Episode I Ultimate Edition was "Supposently a Complete Score" which was misleading so Sony was going to make one for Episode II

I didn't read about any video game release containing tons of unreleased Episode 3 music. Is that buried in the Prequel resource thread?

I think that new Star Wars game has more Episode III music

[indy4]

I heard that TPM UE didn't sell as well as expected, and that's what caused them to ditch the AotC UE idea. But that was from somebody on this MB a long time ago (I dont' remember who).

[Faleel]

I didn't read about any video game release containing tons of unreleased Episode 3 music. Is that buried in the Prequel resource thread?

The Old Republic, its a Pre-prequel MMPORG

[gkgyver]

I see

[Jediking12]

I heard that TPM UE didn't sell as well as expected, and that's what caused them to ditch the AotC UE idea. But that was from somebody on this MB a long time ago (I dont' remember who).

I think ggtuk2005 said something about that

[Krang]

Well this is the most depressing news I've read in a while. Damn them.

[king mark]

I see

There's also a thread devoted to The Old Republic

Were missing about 6 minutes from the RotS complete score now, mainly the dark middle part of Padme's Visit, Padme's Funeral/Finale , and the tail end of a few other cues. The music we have in the games ( 2 hours, 1 minute of it) is good quality, SFX free and can be edited (almost) perfectly

[gkgyver]

Is that the same edit that's on ffshrine with this tracklist:

Spoiler

Disc 1

01 Fox Fanfare :22
02 Star Wars Main Title and the Battle over Coruscant 8:00
03 The Elevator Scene 3:00
04 Count Dooku’s Entrance :49
05 The Death of Dooku 2:02
06 Grievous and the Droids 3:27
07 Another Happy Landing :41
08 Revisiting Padmé 1:33
09 Grievous Travels to Palpatine 1:51
10 Scenes and Dreams 5:14
11 Be Careful of Your Friend 1:32
12 Council Meeting 3:29
13 Hold Me :43
14 Palpatine’s TV Set 1:38
15 Palpatine’s Big Pitch 3:17
16 Good Bye Old Friend 2:38
17 Going to Utapau 2:18
18 Riding the Lizard 1:26
19 Obi-Wan Faces Death :19
20 Drawing Swords :08
21 Good Guys Arrive :26
22 Palpatine’s Seduction 2:30
23 Rolling with Grievous :56
24 Fighting with Grievous 1:37
25 Dialogue with Mace 1:38
26 Padmé’s Ruminations 1:36
27 I am the Senate 6:08
28 Palpatine Instructs Anakin 2:02
29 Lament 4:24
30 Bail’s Escape :37
31 Swimming, Droids and Yoda Farewell 2:14

Disc 2

01 News of the Attack 1:59
02 Moving Things Along 4:17
03 Anakin’s Dark Deeds 2:14
04 It Can’t Be 5:12
05 A Moody Trip :58
06 Padmé’s Visit 3:20
07 Heroes Collide 4:38
08 Yoda vs. Sidious 1:33
09 Yoda Falls :18
10 The Boys Continue 2:09
11 Yoda to Exile :07
12 Revenge of Sith 2:43
13 The Immolation Scene 2:41
14 Anakin Crawling 1:07
15 The Birth of the Twins 2:38
16 Padmé’s Death 2:12
17 Plans for the Twins 1:40
18 Padmé’s Funeral :29
19 A Home for the Twins and End Credits 13:05
20 Lament (Album Version) 4:27
21 Moving Things Along (Album Mix) 4:14
22 Revenge of Sith DVD Version 3:42

[Faleel]

Yes, that is alexander's edit.

[king mark]

Yes, the one just posted by Star Wars Fan786

that's a good one if you don't fell like making it yourself. It doesn't use DVD rips to fill the gaps

[gkgyver]

Well, then .... that's nice to have.

Hm, is it heresy to just keep the files you want on your PC?

[Score_Fan]

you think that the Prequel Trilogy would had the same respect like the Prequels but No! its been a decade since Episode I was released and still no complete score

I'm still good with the Ultimate Edition. Although I'm mainly looking for an expanded release for Episode II and III

and maybe music for the first 2 Harry Potter films

I want all the potters
and star wars
and jurassic park(s)
and Indy 4
and spider-man 3


although not all owned by sony....my money shall go elsewhere, and not to them, which is a shame as I would gladly lay down any (reasonable) price for them.

[GoodMusician]

I love that the website that's crosspromoting says his face is tatooed. If I'm not mistaken, that's how his people look and the more evil you get, the darker it becomes... and the bigger the horns... but thats ok

I hate sony for releasing it again. and again. and again. It's utter lunacy.

It reeks of Lucas though. Reissuing the same thing in a different packaging? Isn't that Lucas' call mark? I mean hello lol...

But money is to be had... and advertising... it's inessence a reprint with a different cover booklet. Rather than continuing to reprint the old set to keep it on shelves, they're just changing the booklets. It's a small change and enough to get a few people to shell out $20 for what they already had.


I love the Complete Score to Episode I btw. Do what you can to hear it. Do anything! It is by far the best modern score by Williams since the 90's.

[Mr. Breathmask]

I heard that TPM UE didn't sell as well as expected, and that's what caused them to ditch the AotC UE idea. But that was from somebody on this MB a long time ago (I dont' remember who).

I think there was something about Sony and Lucasfilm being completely surprised by all the fan backlash they received for the TPM UE. When it turned out people were ripping DVD and game audio and making their own soundtracks, they genuinely thought an isolated score on CD was what people wanted. After everyone got pissed off for getting an entire CD's worth of new music, Sony and Lucasfilm basically went, "well, screw these guys. We give them what they want and they still bitch and moan. Not worth the effort."

A sad tale indeed.

[Richard Penna]

It only ended badly because they were unwilling to listen to where they had gone wrong, and had a complete lack of understanding about why people were using DVD/game rips.

These companies need to learn that there is a reason the speciality labels hire the producers that they do.

[Alexander]

Is that the same edit that's on ffshrine with this tracklist:

Spoiler

Disc 1

01 Fox Fanfare :22
02 Star Wars Main Title and the Battle over Coruscant 8:00
03 The Elevator Scene 3:00
04 Count Dooku’s Entrance :49
05 The Death of Dooku 2:02
06 Grievous and the Droids 3:27
07 Another Happy Landing :41
08 Revisiting Padmé 1:33
09 Grievous Travels to Palpatine 1:51
10 Scenes and Dreams 5:14
11 Be Careful of Your Friend 1:32
12 Council Meeting 3:29
13 Hold Me :43
14 Palpatine’s TV Set 1:38
15 Palpatine’s Big Pitch 3:17
16 Good Bye Old Friend 2:38
17 Going to Utapau 2:18
18 Riding the Lizard 1:26
19 Obi-Wan Faces Death :19
20 Drawing Swords :08
21 Good Guys Arrive :26
22 Palpatine’s Seduction 2:30
23 Rolling with Grievous :56
24 Fighting with Grievous 1:37
25 Dialogue with Mace 1:38
26 Padmé’s Ruminations 1:36
27 I am the Senate 6:08
28 Palpatine Instructs Anakin 2:02
29 Lament 4:24
30 Bail’s Escape :37
31 Swimming, Droids and Yoda Farewell 2:14

Disc 2

01 News of the Attack 1:59
02 Moving Things Along 4:17
03 Anakin’s Dark Deeds 2:14
04 It Can’t Be 5:12
05 A Moody Trip :58
06 Padmé’s Visit 3:20
07 Heroes Collide 4:38
08 Yoda vs. Sidious 1:33
09 Yoda Falls :18
10 The Boys Continue 2:09
11 Yoda to Exile :07
12 Revenge of Sith 2:43
13 The Immolation Scene 2:41
14 Anakin Crawling 1:07
15 The Birth of the Twins 2:38
16 Padmé’s Death 2:12
17 Plans for the Twins 1:40
18 Padmé’s Funeral :29
19 A Home for the Twins and End Credits 13:05
20 Lament (Album Version) 4:27
21 Moving Things Along (Album Mix) 4:14
22 Revenge of Sith DVD Version 3:42

That's my edit, i'm StarWarsFan786 on ffshrine.

...Do you like it?