I thought all three Home Alone pieces were great. The orchestra really seemed to enjoy playing this one and the choir singing it; I noticed that right at the very end of Merry Christmas, Merry Christmas the choir shouted an extra "Yes!", Macaulay Culkin-stylee, as the last chord was played. Ken Bruce announced beforehand that the programme would be broadcast close to Christmas, so it did not sound at all incongruous. Believe it or not this was the fourth all John Williams concert I had attended this year, but all four had something different to enjoy and included Williams pieces that I had never heard played live in concert before. I was very pleasantly surprised at the inclusion of Call of the Champions, for example, which I really wasn't expecting - I had to stop myself from singing "citius! altius! fortius!" along with the London Voices. Can you guys outside the UK listen to BBC Radio broadcasts on the internet, either live or on the BBC iPlayer? I think that Lockhart sometimes conducts sans baton. No idea why. As for the "extra" yes on "Merry Christmas, Merry Christmas", that's how the concert version ends.