Leaderboard

I didn't even think about it.. Schindler's List!

So I posted this video in the YouTube clips thread late last July and it was well received, but then my channel got shut down. I also lost the project file. Since then I've been itching to remake it. So I finally had some time today and remade the video as closely as I could to the original. I also remade the Hans Zimmer version as well. The Zimmer one didn't turn out as well as I wanted, but whatever. Enjoy the side by side comparison of these composers while my channel still lives.

Batman Mask of the Phantasm by Shirley Walker War Horse by John Williams Saving Private Ryan by John Williams First Blood by Jerry Goldsmith

5 seconds into John Carter I thought I was listening to Super 8. Ottman's score was more enjoyable for me on the first listen.Jack the Giant Slayer lacks cohesion, strong themes, and also falters a bit in the mid-portions of the score. But most of it, through its various musical colours and styles (especially in its highlights) are executed so well that it makes a more entertaining and diverse listening experience than John Carter. The album could use a trimming though.

What do you do when your iPod skips the song you selected?Scream bloody murder and drive through whatever unlucky pedestrians happen to be in my way. Why, what do you do? Sorry the mental image made me actually start laughing out loud.

I love love love this score. The OST remaster is PHEMONENAL. The range and openness of the sound is amazing. Played it the whole way through. When I left after listening, there was a note on the door "please turn down your music, even if it is wonderful". LOL

You've never heard of Hercule Poirot, the famous Belgium Detective from Agathie Christie's many novels and short stories?

So you are a Poirot fanatic as well as a LotR fanatic, Mikko? You're becoming more sympathetic to me with each day! I've read practically every Poirot novel in existence and have the old album as well. Now, if they could release another edition of Patrick Gowers' Sherlock Holmes, that was even better.

It is, actually. Karol

Just a quickie: