publicist
-
Posts
17,580 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
42
Posts posted by publicist
-
-
19 minutes ago, Richard Penna said:
If this release had been 50 mins and everyone loved it, there would be complaints about why they couldn't do a longer release.
You have to be a purist on some matters. Let them complain!
PS: compiled this playlist on the go. It runs a bit over 60 and tries to weed out the most insubstantial stuff. There's still more you'd need to do, but for the moment that will do for me.
-
Like i wrote in that other thread, it's another one of these baffling 'more is less' releases. 110 minutes of material that needs editorializing like a plant needs light. It's not enough to just whittle out tracks, you would need to edit tracks themselves. This is a good 45-50 minutes score.
- mstrox and Not Mr. Big
-
2
-
3 hours ago, Brundlefly said:
The "boh-ats" are much better in the film recording.
Which sounds like its same-year counterpart 'The Fury' thin-ish and not at all apocalyptic. I don't know if both were recorded at Fox, but this problem lasted until the early 1980s (think of 'Masada'). Strangely enough, pristine recordings like TMP or Jaws 2 were possible, but they certainly were no industry standard.
-
I will repeat myself here like James Horner on a particular manic day of self-referencing, but it must be said: the release of 110-minute (or even more) albums kills what would have been fair to good 50 minute releases. James Newton Howard struggles on with the Beasts franchise and the third one isn't any better or worse than part II. Don't expect anything on the scale of King Kong, but it's also no Pawn Sacrifice or Michael Clayton. Perfectly middling stuff.
It's even eerily similar: full of fleeting moments that never coalesce into musically satisfying cues - the start/stop problem i talked about earlier in Williams' RoS score, which means basically many empty gestures of the big orchestra that fizzle out into nothing, because they are just there to accentuate the usual blockbuster methodology of bluntly demanding attention whenever a character suddenly turns around etc. - it isn't a crushing disappointment but still a chore to sit through.
With all the required editing work laid at my feet, i should get at least a voucher for a free flac download for things like this. Because, you know, that's what you need when you start extensive audio editing.
-
James Horner's nod to Bernstein's childhood classic 'To Kill a Mockingbird' (it riffs on a similar tune, with extensive piano, violin and woodwind solos). For budget reasons much of the orchestra was synthesized, which could theoretically give it an interesting edge, sadly most of it sounds like strings and plucked harps played on crummy synths. Still, as a direct relative to the many children scores Horner did so effortlessly it's a nice addition to the canon.
-
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
On 18/02/2022 at 5:16 PM, Luke Skywalker said:You're all entitled to your opinion and you don't have to like MG, but this claim is such nonsense. Regardless of the orchestrations he's using, he's written so much orchestral music of high quality for Rogue One and other movies.
It certainly is enough for franchise fans with few musical credentials. But it should raise eyebrows that a sizeable number of guys here who profess to know and admire Williams' composing abilities consider *this* stuff high quality.
- Remco, Timo Martikainen and Fabulin
-
3
-
Colourful orchestral adventure score (the kind which is scientifically impossible these days, as we are told in another thread). Gordon shoots his load in the Riddles overture, which is a compact suite of all the good stuff distributed more fleetingly throughout the 45 remaining minutes. In a recent podcast, Gordon offers fascinating insights how he taught himself composing, which makes his imposing brass writing all the more remarkable.
-
23 minutes ago, Not Mr. Big said:
Both themes in that concert arrangement have a lot of emotional weight. The "We Go Together" portion is one of JW's most heartstring-tugging cues of the last few years for me.
Yeah well, cues that he conceived obviously without having seen the film.
As i was pointing out, my beef is not that the themes are weak or the scores, but that the nature of the writing tends to be fragmented and heavily wedded to picture. I can't remember a Spielberg picture with so many dead spots that could be easily edited out without complaint. So it's probably a matter of modern editing and filmmaking in general.
-
The Rise of Skywalker concert cue certainly doesn't sound weighty, either (also like something out of the Potter trilogy).
-
1 hour ago, Docteur Qui said:
Can you clarify what you mean by significance? If it’s referring to the quality, craft or aesthetic impact of the music, that is purely subjective opinion. Cultural significance? Hans Zimmer, as we speak, is touring the world with his music in concert, and has reached a level of popularity only rivalled by Williams. The status of film composers has never been higher in the public consciousness, they’re literal rockstars now. If you mean significance in terms the presence or role of music within the construction of a film, I addressed that in the evolution of sound design (and would go further to include CGI). John Williams once made us believe a man could fly, but these days anyone with a laptop and After Effects can rustle together something convincing.
What i mean is exactly that: MUSIC with a capital M, that's written and conceived as real music, not just a wallpapery thing that wafts away in the background at the mercy of a hundred sound effects. I'm aware of all what you're talking about, but it sounds too apologetic to me, like an industry professional trying to sell me something that is of no particular use for a music fan.
QuoteAesthetic trends come and go in media and always have, but the homogeny of contemporary entertainment is as much as product of studio profiteering than anything. Familiar sells, and in times of economic uncertainty no studio wants to risk innovation eating into profits.
Sounds like back in the 90's and early 2000's, when Ford Thaxton found an excuse for nearly everything with a non-sequitur like 'this will bring in the big monies, just accept it'. But why should i?
QuoteAgain this is a question of subjective taste. The musical artform encompasses far more than the European art music traditions that were popularised in films scores last century, and includes systems of tonality, instrumentation and compositional techniques from cultures all over the globe, including modern digital techniques and popular songwriting conventions. Just because you can’t recognise the skill and craft on display in modern scores doesn’t mean it isn’t there. There are some seriously talented people making music for film these days. It just doesn’t sound like what many people here recognise as “good” music.
Again, i don't really see what you are advocating here: that you are a big fan of sound gadgets and expensive gear? My argument is and always have been that i listen to something released separately from the movie, so i'm rating its musical qualities. That's all there is to it.
I can talk about all this stuff, and it is known and debated for years, but do i gain better music from it?
-
1 minute ago, Not Mr. Big said:
A more apt title for the concert arrangement would have been "The Spirit of Fun" or something.
That concert piece is eternally underrated by most fans. It's the most musically complicated - how JW weds and builds the disparate ideas into one piece moving towards a big resolution: that's great 'musical' writing, not the tons of murky underscore.
-
2 hours ago, crocodile said:
I'm not sure how to judge this one based on the album and film. The latter especially is handled appallingly. There is still something like 2 hours we have not heard yet?
I'm not suggesting that Williams' abilities have declined, certainly not. But it's a pipe dream to think there's a cohesive masterpiece buried in the Disney vaults.
There's an incredible amount of film-dependent writing here, i guess when you load the cues in Audition you will see many start/stop sections, slow build up's without resolution, sudden jolts to accentuate a character turning around etc. that don't necessarily have a musical reason and certainly do not sound very musical.
And the whole thing moves like that, apart from a few through-composed pieces.
-
Even The Rise of Skywalker itself wasn't that great, so lowered expectations all around.
-
14 minutes ago, Docteur Qui said:
Coming to this thread a bit late, but I will say that as much as I love a good old fashioned traditional score with colourful orchestration etc... they're hardly appropriate for most films these days.
You cite several things that are neither (that) new, nor really an explanation for the loss of significance of music composed for films.
Yes, digital has completely changed the technical/production side of things, but that's not really what drives these developments. The term 'content' is now routinely used for all kinds of media, and it describes a downgrade of sorts in the sense that we have become used to everything kinda looking and sounding the same.
Of course there still would be countless films that would profit from 'traditional' scores (doesn't mean they must all sound like 'War Horse'). That they aren't written or even requested is mostly due to a generational change (the 'Stranger Things' phenomenon, whole lines of product are just based on slavishly recreated deja vú's - or the director's Spotify playlist) and the simple fact that the industry doesn't push for excellence beyond purely technical categories - certainly not for the musical artform.
That there are occasional beacons of light (last years sadly not much beyond Greenwood, Gordon and yeah, Dune) gives me hope that the state of things will eventually change. Until this happens i refuse to call bland pap and ACME-style uniformity an acceptable state of things.
-
It's noncommittal, bland pop - no match for Matchstick Man - but it had a marimba cue i liked (had the boot once).
-
With one of Powell's most charming main titles.
-
6 hours ago, Thor said:
Since this topic was ressurected, I'll have to echo my own sentiments from a year ago. Not getting hired by mainstream Hollywood isn't necessarily all bad. There are a lot of exciting things happening outside Hollywood, either on the US indie scene or in other countries.
Or in video games, where Austin Wintory has pretty consistently done much more sophisticated work than film composers usually do (read: are allowed to do). I. e. Pathless, Journey, Abzu.
12 minutes ago, Edmilson said:I agree. Despite the interesting insight he offered on the state of film music these days, I don't think they'll help him getting new gigs. Hollywood doesn't like artists who complain on social media about not getting jobs.
Hollywood also doesn't consider composers artists these days (lip service excluded). They are, as James Horner ruefully observed when he was still alive, just another technical category.
-
Star Treks! Give me those Star Treks! Nothing but Star Treks - Don't let them end.
-
It's an accumulation of Dont's.
-
1 hour ago, Naïve Old Fart said:
I've not heard the most recent release, but I'm assured that it sounds very good, Indeed.
It doesn't, but leagues better than the pinched Varése, which has an impossible stereo field with hardly a separation between the instrumental groups.
-
21 hours ago, Thor said:
I have all three albums, but at some point -- when I have the time and energy -- I will boil all of them down to one 50-minute album that represents everything I ever wanted to own from the HTTYD scores.
I tend to prefer the more playful things, like the aforementioned and 'Furies in Love' from the third one. Tends to bring out a more behaved compositional side of Powell.
-
-
- Popular Post
Had this saved this for a re-listen to decide if it was worth to investigate the Varése deluxe. Meh. Don't know if it's a generational gap thing but i remain dubious about its appeal. Except for a handful of quieter cues and the occasional highlight ('Flying with Mother') it ends up sounding like a big frenetic blob of sound to me. Maybe it has to do with the striping technique used for recording it. After experiencing the same problems with part III, i will return mainly to part I whenever i feel the dragon itch.
- Jurassic Shark, GerateWohl and Thor
-
3
Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore (2022) by James Newton Howard
in General Discussion
Posted
Both inessential cues that meander too much before making a real musical point and are too short to afford so much meandering. I will also say, categorically, that there's a real arbitrariness to it (long sections of vaguely pleasant children's chorus, long stretches of uniform awe and/or menace stuff that could belong to any Marvel film) a diffuse non-commitment to clear narrative statements that is very typical of current blockbuster scoring. Howard is an old pro who knows his way around some restrictions, but there's very little to recommend it, really.