Jump to content

publicist

Members
  • Posts

    17,580
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    42

Posts posted by publicist

  1. 1 hour ago, Marian Schedenig said:

    As usual with more recent JNH, Beasts "suffers" from from some clear highlights connected with much meandering and "unmusical" transitions. I suppose it's Howard's response to the current day scoring conditions: Pick a few moments and really do invest some "serious" artistry, and just competently phone in the rest because you don't get enough time to do more and you can't trust it surviving to the final edit anyway. All too often that affects even the highlight cues themselves, because the switch from "art" to "generic autopilot" happens in the middle of a track. But Beasts, in the 2 CD version, has quite a bit of material to build an excellent short suite.

     

    This affects part 2 in a much more harmful way. Who's to blame him, saw parts of the movie and it was horrible. And to be honest, the same problems befell Williams on his recent SW scores. 

  2. 32 minutes ago, Richard Penna said:

    I still haven't either FB films so I can't comment - AFAIK they've never been on any streaming services without having to pay - I cynically assume that certain franchises are so precious (Potter, Bond) that they can't fathom making them streamable. What happened to making the first two free (i.e. in subscription) to entice people into the cinema to see the third?

     

    Really? Here in Germany, Amazon Prime has both, Potter and FB on steady (free) rotation since years.

  3. 12 minutes ago, JTW said:

    A gentleman would never talk like that in public, even if he thinks that.

     

    Again you seem to delude yourself into thinking the entertainment industry, home to millions of flim flam men, professional liars, narcissists, thieves and god knows what else, should adhere to the standards of UNO or something.
     

    7 hours ago, JNHFan2000 said:

    Violence is in no way the proper solution for anything and clearly there is more going on with Smith then we all know. I think it would be good for him to do an interview with maybe Oprah, Robin Roberts or someone in that caliber to have a long conversation of where this was coming from. 

     

    Let's just be thankful it happened at the Oscars, not in the war room...;)

     

    image.png

  4. Just buy 'The Last Valley'. Barry, like Morricone, isn't a composer where you need every last minute of music, there's a lot of low-key stuff on Bond that ain't that great. And the expanded editions that are out since the early 2000's include his most important contributions on very long albums.

  5. 6 hours ago, JTWfan77 said:

    He ain't Jerry and it shows unfortunately.

     

    There are long, dramatic cues like 'Sheva's Decision', 'Eleazar Speaks' (Masada's infamous mass suicide decision) and 'Silva's Soliloquy' that are very good. It's all i kept but when they play i feel in good musical hands.

  6. 9 hours ago, Luke Skywalker said:

    It was the juxtaposition with the terrorist attack that i didnt understand, plus the detachment eric banas character seems to have, while he should showing more complicity and tenderness to his pregnant wife. 

     

    Gee, really? The point of the whole thing was to show how insensitized and numbed Bana had become through his experiences. The sex probably was meant to emphasize it, as a purely physical exercise, with a haunted look on his face suggesting he's not in the moment but relives his past experiences.

  7. 48 minutes ago, Brundlefly said:

    The only thing I don't like about First Knight is the generic Love Theme which does get repeatet a lot, but without any noticeable variation.

     

    It's his customary Barry tune.

     

    The theme is fine, but the bridge is perfunctory and if i ever had a beef with Goldsmith's style, it's that his thematic bridges often come off as 'let's get done with this with as few notes and surprises as possible', which often make a great theme appear less so, because the bridge doesn't carry it.

     

    It works in cases like 'Rambo' or 'First Contact', but for every Long Road there are 9 others that sound shallow. 

  8. 24 minutes ago, Thor said:

    MzQtOTUxNC5qcGVn.jpeg

     

    I suppose this is a "kick" to the John Powell fan kids who grew up with his HTTYD scores as the best thing since sliced bread. This has always been my second favourite Powell score (after FACE/OFF), and it's from 1998. Great West Africa-West blends. I tend to prefer Powell pre-HTTYD, so sue me, you tiny wincy kids! ;) 

     

    The 11-minute final race cue is a real winner, and the faux-ethnic style mixed with western composition techniques is really charming. One of my favourites from 1999, and yes, it doesn't suffer from Powell's more hyperactive later style.

  9. 10 hours ago, JTW said:

    I think you’re mistaking being polite with being PC, but that’s OK, I don’t mind. 

     

    It's not being polite, it's dodging discussion, but hey, no one forces anything on you.

    1 hour ago, Naïve Old Fart said:

    SCHINDLER'S LIST is a clinging, cloying film, that preys on your emotions, and demands respect, while, at the same time, doing nothing to deserve it. It's Oscar bait at its most shameful.

    The interesting thing about "I could have done more", is that it never happened. According to Mrs. Schindler, he thanked people, politely, then got into the car and drove away. End of. No tears. No falling over. No regrets.

    It's a well made film, and, technically, very proficient, but somehow it just doesn't ring true... even for a piece of fiction.

    As @publicist has drawn our attention to it, the "Cincinnati Kid" sequence, probably would have spoiled the perceived altruism of Schindler, and shown him for what he was: a businessman.

    I appreciate SCHINDLER'S LIST, but, in no way do I like it.

     

     

    I think it's a great achievement, all things considered. Back when i was in school, SL was mandatory viewing, and while this concept fell flat on its face especially with a certain young male demographic, a much bigger percentage felt shaken and moved by it, something schoolbooks and documentaries never remotely achieved.

     

    We might bemoan certain things that can be considered manipulative or naive, but on the whole, a bleak, sometimes borderline unwatchable Holocaust movie like this just wouldn't have been possible in Hollywood at that time (without Spielberg). 

  10. 3 minutes ago, JTW said:

    I may be wrong but nonetheless that’s my personal opinion and I still disagree with you, while respecting YOUR opinion. 

     

    Don't try to appear so overly PC, rather discuss your opinion in terms beyond simplistic statements á la 'in my opinion it's an infallible masterpiece, period'. It may be my problem, as i come from a journalist background, but i find the discussion culture here has been really come to a crawl after several older posters left the board.

  11. Just now, JTW said:

    Could be, I accept your opinion, although I disagree. 

     

    You are wrong then. :) It's just bad style to falsify your lead character to make sweeping do-good statements that belong to another generation, especially, and that is my main beef with it and the Oscar bait reproach, if you can reasonably expect that the majority will or has to clappingly agree with you. Besides, the writing and length are too cumbersome to count as universal truth, especially with the heavy-vibrato violin playing in the back.

     

    Of course i'm talking about my reaction, i wouldn't deny anyone to be moved by such sentimentalities, but if a movie is elevated to such lofty heights, this criticism bears mention.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.