-
Posts
17,580 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
42
Reputation Activity
-
publicist got a reaction from karelm in Is Hans Zimmer the most revolutionary film composer of all time?
Thor, i know more than a few outside-Hollywood movies and i know that even if from this day on no movie ever would have a score at all, you still would compulsively insist that there never was a better period for film music, it's just your nature.
What i think should be made clearer,especially in light of whom this messageboard is dedicated to, is that a lot of people think of film music as a way of vivid storytelling. And you can twist and turn, this isn't how music by and large functions today in film, and not only Hollywood, since a lot of non-HW-filmmakers of course are influenced by that, too. Of course there are bright spots and brilliant applications of music to picture, but that is really not the norm and also shouldn't include great song scores (we just as well might include cricket chirping then).
So in essence, i don't dislike a score like GIRL WITH A DRAGON TATTOO per se, i like quite a few Martinez or Mansell scores (recently: STOKER!) but i also see that they often don't function as great storytelling but more as loose moodsetters that often are rather vague in what they are conveying. This isn't to say they are bad or good, only that they are not able to direct my interest as the best Herrmann/Williams/Goldsmith-etc. scores could do. And that, for me is a fact that can be objectively proven. And those examples are still miles better than a lot - read. not all - factory-assembled RCP clone scores that range from GAME OF THRONES to the recent ENDER'S GAME.
-
publicist got a reaction from Sharkissimo in Is Hans Zimmer the most revolutionary film composer of all time?
A slight unease for me is to call all this MUSIC in capitals, now we talk about music production and act as if one of those typical 130-minute RCP scores is essentially the same as a huge Rózsa score just assembled a wee bit differently. May we at least say that whatever Zimmer and cohorts produce, it is not always and doesn't act always MUSIC per se, but in a lot of cases, sound design - as per the wish of the actual producers.
That's where my tummyache regarding 'revolutionary' comes in: if i take the genre of film music really as a MUSICAL genre, i don't know if that indeed was in any way revolutionized by modern aesthetics. A lot of it barely can be called music and isn't called up to be such (Horner complained in Vienna how composers now aren't even considered artists but technical personnel like ADR recordists and such).
-
publicist got a reaction from Sharkissimo in Is Hans Zimmer the most revolutionary film composer of all time?
Thor, i know more than a few outside-Hollywood movies and i know that even if from this day on no movie ever would have a score at all, you still would compulsively insist that there never was a better period for film music, it's just your nature.
What i think should be made clearer,especially in light of whom this messageboard is dedicated to, is that a lot of people think of film music as a way of vivid storytelling. And you can twist and turn, this isn't how music by and large functions today in film, and not only Hollywood, since a lot of non-HW-filmmakers of course are influenced by that, too. Of course there are bright spots and brilliant applications of music to picture, but that is really not the norm and also shouldn't include great song scores (we just as well might include cricket chirping then).
So in essence, i don't dislike a score like GIRL WITH A DRAGON TATTOO per se, i like quite a few Martinez or Mansell scores (recently: STOKER!) but i also see that they often don't function as great storytelling but more as loose moodsetters that often are rather vague in what they are conveying. This isn't to say they are bad or good, only that they are not able to direct my interest as the best Herrmann/Williams/Goldsmith-etc. scores could do. And that, for me is a fact that can be objectively proven. And those examples are still miles better than a lot - read. not all - factory-assembled RCP clone scores that range from GAME OF THRONES to the recent ENDER'S GAME.
-
publicist got a reaction from KK in Is Hans Zimmer the most revolutionary film composer of all time?
A slight unease for me is to call all this MUSIC in capitals, now we talk about music production and act as if one of those typical 130-minute RCP scores is essentially the same as a huge Rózsa score just assembled a wee bit differently. May we at least say that whatever Zimmer and cohorts produce, it is not always and doesn't act always MUSIC per se, but in a lot of cases, sound design - as per the wish of the actual producers.
That's where my tummyache regarding 'revolutionary' comes in: if i take the genre of film music really as a MUSICAL genre, i don't know if that indeed was in any way revolutionized by modern aesthetics. A lot of it barely can be called music and isn't called up to be such (Horner complained in Vienna how composers now aren't even considered artists but technical personnel like ADR recordists and such).
-
publicist got a reaction from KK in Is Hans Zimmer the most revolutionary film composer of all time?
Thor, i know more than a few outside-Hollywood movies and i know that even if from this day on no movie ever would have a score at all, you still would compulsively insist that there never was a better period for film music, it's just your nature.
What i think should be made clearer,especially in light of whom this messageboard is dedicated to, is that a lot of people think of film music as a way of vivid storytelling. And you can twist and turn, this isn't how music by and large functions today in film, and not only Hollywood, since a lot of non-HW-filmmakers of course are influenced by that, too. Of course there are bright spots and brilliant applications of music to picture, but that is really not the norm and also shouldn't include great song scores (we just as well might include cricket chirping then).
So in essence, i don't dislike a score like GIRL WITH A DRAGON TATTOO per se, i like quite a few Martinez or Mansell scores (recently: STOKER!) but i also see that they often don't function as great storytelling but more as loose moodsetters that often are rather vague in what they are conveying. This isn't to say they are bad or good, only that they are not able to direct my interest as the best Herrmann/Williams/Goldsmith-etc. scores could do. And that, for me is a fact that can be objectively proven. And those examples are still miles better than a lot - read. not all - factory-assembled RCP clone scores that range from GAME OF THRONES to the recent ENDER'S GAME.
-
publicist got a reaction from Uni in Is Hans Zimmer the most revolutionary film composer of all time?
A slight unease for me is to call all this MUSIC in capitals, now we talk about music production and act as if one of those typical 130-minute RCP scores is essentially the same as a huge Rózsa score just assembled a wee bit differently. May we at least say that whatever Zimmer and cohorts produce, it is not always and doesn't act always MUSIC per se, but in a lot of cases, sound design - as per the wish of the actual producers.
That's where my tummyache regarding 'revolutionary' comes in: if i take the genre of film music really as a MUSICAL genre, i don't know if that indeed was in any way revolutionized by modern aesthetics. A lot of it barely can be called music and isn't called up to be such (Horner complained in Vienna how composers now aren't even considered artists but technical personnel like ADR recordists and such).
-
publicist got a reaction from Brónach in Is Hans Zimmer the most revolutionary film composer of all time?
A slight unease for me is to call all this MUSIC in capitals, now we talk about music production and act as if one of those typical 130-minute RCP scores is essentially the same as a huge Rózsa score just assembled a wee bit differently. May we at least say that whatever Zimmer and cohorts produce, it is not always and doesn't act always MUSIC per se, but in a lot of cases, sound design - as per the wish of the actual producers.
That's where my tummyache regarding 'revolutionary' comes in: if i take the genre of film music really as a MUSICAL genre, i don't know if that indeed was in any way revolutionized by modern aesthetics. A lot of it barely can be called music and isn't called up to be such (Horner complained in Vienna how composers now aren't even considered artists but technical personnel like ADR recordists and such).
-
publicist got a reaction from Incanus in La La Land Records - New John Williams release coming Black Friday 2013 [UPDATE: June 2014] [Empire of the Sun]
Don't we all?
-
publicist got a reaction from crocodile in La La Land Records - New John Williams release coming Black Friday 2013 [UPDATE: June 2014] [Empire of the Sun]
Don't we all?
-
publicist got a reaction from Incanus in La La Land Records - New John Williams release coming Black Friday 2013 [UPDATE: June 2014] [Empire of the Sun]
It sounds like it's recorded in a very bassy closed cucumber jar. I'm certain it's a mastering problem, around that time alot of Williams recordings, i. e. 7 YEARS IN TIBET or THE PATRIOT were plagued by this overbassed but strangely distant sound, none more so than A. I.
-
publicist reacted to Brónach in What Is The Last Score You Listened To? (older scores)
(not a score)
Breton dance performed by Galician musician Carlos Núñez.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=76WwmDoQBnY
Basque song by Benito Lertxundi
-
publicist reacted to Koray Savas in What Is The Last Score You Listened To? (older scores)
Parkland by James Newton Howard
-
publicist reacted to ChrisAfonso in I dare everyone here: make a concert arrangement of the Tintin Theme!
It took me almost two years to get this out of my head an into my computer, but I've finally managed to assemble a little concert arrangement based on Tintin's theme:
http://soundcloud.com/chrisafonso/tintins-theme-arrangement
It mostly consists of Williams' original theme and secondary "sneaking" theme, which I extended a bit. And to make King Mark happy, I applied a bit of a Raiders March feel to the beginning.
It's relatively short, unlike the more fleshed out suites Homeboy and especially Skystalker already created, but I hope it's enjoyable nonetheless
-
publicist reacted to BurgaFlippinMan in Alfonso Cuarón's Gravity
I drove 60 miles to see this in IMAX 3D. And it was worth every single cent. The technical execution was absolutely brilliant, the effects were seamless and having the image fill up almost your entire field of vision in 3D (especially in the first person views) made for some buttclenchingly tense moments during the action sequences. Space seemed very scary in IMAX 3D
-
publicist got a reaction from Brónach in What Is The Last Score You Listened To? (older scores)
ENDURING LOVE: Jeremy Sams
Be surprised that a new filmscore obviously got away with a dedicated Vaughan-Williams homage that even soars into concertant heights in PASSACAGLIA that have been long absent form filmscoredom. Fans of the sweet and delicate IRIS (Horner) or even ANGELA'S ASHES and such might find something to like in this album, though i never even have heard of Jeremy Sams (an oversight that will no be corrected). It's on Spotify.
-
-
publicist got a reaction from crocodile in Abel Korzeniowski's Romeo and Juliet (Replaced James Horner) - Sony Classic OST
Danger motif for the Capulets!
-
publicist reacted to Brónach in What Is The Last Score You Listened To? (older scores)
I love the fun Galician overtones of this. I wonder if it's based on some folk melody from there.
-
-
publicist reacted to Hurmm in Alfonso Cuarón's Gravity
Anyway at its core Gravity is an exceedingly simple and lean thriller set in space, with a dose of human spirit. The entire film is made up of setpieces, and there's nothing that suggests the ambition of, say, 2001: ASO. It's a superbly tense and technically marvelous thriller. That's it.
I do think the praise being heaped on it at the moment is a bit much though, as good as it is. I'm also doubtful that movies in the near future will try to mimic the camerawork here.
-
publicist reacted to Sharkissimo in Alfonso Cuarón's Gravity
I miss a bit of intrusion. Everything today is so boringly understated.
-
publicist reacted to Quintus in Alfonso Cuarón's Gravity
Is there literally nothing you'll give quarter to if it isn't sumptuously or bombastically orchestrated and played by a fucking symphony orchestra?
-
publicist reacted to AC1 in What is the last Television series you watched?
Now quickly watch season 4!
From wikipedia:
And you know what? It's true.
Alex
-
publicist reacted to Incanus in What is the last Television series you watched?
The Wire: Season 3 finale. Sheer awesomeness. There is a great feeling of closure in the season finales of this show because they are actually closing cases whether succesful or not, but here perhaps more than in the previous seasons there is a sense of coming full circle as they tie quite a few story threads together.
-
publicist got a reaction from Hlao-roo in BBC Radio documentary on film music.
But that's the point: in the 50's, a Waxman score like NUN'S STORY or TARAS BULBA may have been drawn from the classical idioms, but both were fresh and new scores and not just an inferior copy. Same goes for our beloved Silver Age: scores like E. T. or FIRST BLOOD, to quote a watershed year, took inspiration from Hanson, Bartok, Stravinsky, Herrmann et al., but they still added something to the mix that wasn't there before and enriched film art by showing us how homogenous film and music can interact.
I really don't feel the urge to compare that to the way movies are scored today: again, it works on a low musical level and it's hardly worth to listen to all those 74-minute releases of scores that just don't do much that makes musical sense, or worse, subject me to uninspired TRANSFORMERS-like simple chord motions for the 1000st time.
