Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Arnaud

  • Rank
    Occasional Poster

Recent Profile Visitors

2084 profile views
  1. Oops, sorry. I checked before posting but missed it. This was news to me. Please feel free to delete.
  2. Hello all, I don't think this has been noticed here. Here's a link to a very interesting interview of Steven Spielberg by fellow director Marty Scorsese for Filmmaker Magazine on the occasion of the release of Bridge of Spies. If you get to 47:20, Spielberg talks about the call he got from Williams telling him he was going to be fit with a pacemaker and was prevented from working for seven weeks by his doctor. This is probably also why Williams didn't conduct most of The Force Awakens. http://filmmakermagazine.com/
  3. I'm not sure anybody believes that. This Indy fan doesn't. Willy Scott was a bit of a problem. Sallah's character didn't suffer too much in Last Crusade but Marcus was a huge disappointment. So was the fat kid in the opening sequence. Such an appalling cliché. I won't go into the last film, I've forgotten it already.
  4. Menace is a flawed film. Clone is a terrible film. Sith is not a film. This order can't be wrong, it's mine. Though I'm sad and disappointed by this prequel trilogy, I have to say that I still admire George for completing the six episodes. It's an incredible goal for an artist to achieve. Sorry about changing the subject. This was supposed to be about Indy.
  5. As is often the case with film franchises, the first one is the best. So good it spawned sequels. And then the quality holds or decreases steadily. So: Raiders Temple of Doom / Last Crusade Skull It works with Star Wars too: Star Wars / ESB Jedi Menace Clone Sith
  6. Not a single vote for Always, The Witches Of Eastwick or The River? Come on People!
  7. I kinda like Eno's work. It's perfectly fine that he hates Williams' work although I find that a bit extreme, as though he had something to prove. It is a matter of taste. When he adds that 'it's ruined many a good film, in my opinion' he becomes ridiculous.
  8. Too many great works to choose from. My favorite score is different every day so today I vote for Jaws 2 because it's a brilliant and often overlooked score that had no vote yet.
  9. John Adams's piece is from 1982 and Steve Reich's is from 1986. Did Reich plagiarize Adams?
  10. Arnaud


    Well, that's a perfect illustration of a quote. Given that Rites of Spring is one of the greatest piece of music written in the 20th century and one of the most original for its time I'm tempted to say that Williams did a pretty good job. He toyed with it in the first few bars and then freed himself from the temp track. I won't dare to say that he improved on it but he certainly found his own voice pretty quickly and the rest of the piece is remarkable in its own right. That reminds me that Lucas rejected the original Jawa theme so he was really hands on.
  11. Arnaud


    Thank you, I will order this book right away. Plagiarism exists but some people see it at every turn which is really boring. Some because they don't know enough about music and others because they know more than they should and it turned them into snobs.
  12. Yes, since the market for John Williams books is overflowing. People making this purchase are probably seeking it out, or something like it. The cover photo does not appear to be a serious deterrent in that regard. Ok, first of all, to seek something out, one has to be aware it's out there. Reaching people with no money spent on marketing is incredibly difficult. This means that one who publishes a book really can't afford to miss a sale after having caught a potential buyer's attention for even a mere fraction of a second. Anyone who has ever tried to sell something, anything, knows how hard
  13. Arnaud


    I went to the opera in Paris last sunday. I saw Wagner's Tristan and Isolde. Today I read an interview with the excellent conductor where he announced he was working on his next assignment which is Ravel's Daphnis and Chloé. He then added that he had never noticed before how often Ravel quotes this opera of Wagner's including in the very first notes of Daphnis. I guess that according to some another plagiarist has been outed... But maybe they already knew it!
  14. It's unfortunate because many people still buy books based on the cover and this particular picture will not make anyone buy this book. It won't help them notice it and it won't help undecided buyers to make their choice. I assume the content of the book is of great interest. If so the cover does not give it justice. This is a good picture to use inside. Not on a cover. Sorry about that. I'll still buy it. Hell, I'll buy two to be forgiven. Though I don't like the cover. But I said that already.
  15. I'm sorry to say I don't understand the choice of the photograph used on the cover. Very unfortunate to say the least.
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.