Jump to content

Barnald

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2,596

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Barnald

  1. Barnald
    Part of me thinks Doug knows it would be cruel (and perhaps not entirely beneficial to our full comprehension/appreciation of his undoubtedly wonderful book) if we hadn't heard all of what he will be discussing, so surely something is planned. Certainly this book will be very interesting in terms of laying bare the full extent of the revisions. Perhaps they're even worse/more substantial than we thought...
  2. Barnald
    There are few worse fates
  3. Barnald
    Well he does say 'great detail', so we can have him for false advertising if not.
  4. Barnald
    I refuse to let this forum die. A couple of posts on Doug's blog (remember that?) are worth quoting: Thank Christ that Tauriel bit was cut, but it raises an interesting question. If that is non-canonical, does that mean it wasn't Shore's intention for the theme to be heard in 'Kingsfoil' either? Or does 'recap' simply refer to tracked material? Doug is dropping a lot of strong hints now that we should hear something soon. I guess the book isn't far away. But in all honesty, with all these references to Shore's original intentions and talking about them in detail, I truly hope we get to hear whatever we don't have at some point. Even then, I would also want certain 'non-canonical' film alternates.
  5. Barnald
    No chance is this not opening without a crawl.
  6. Barnald
    I think it's more that people can't be arsed to post long-winded comments about a film if they're not saying something enthusiastic about it. At least, that's my excuse. Like me, I guess he must have missed those real-world lightsaber and force duels.
  7. Barnald
    Maz, in terms of design, performance and realization, was pure arse. I believe that's the first thought on this film I've posted on here. I trust it was worth the wait.
  8. Barnald
    In that case you're coming with us then. I'll pack an extra sandwich.
  9. Barnald
    We'll have the last laugh when Disney acquire the rights to everything Tolkien and proceed to milk his proverbial tit. The Irresistible Rise of Alfred Lickspittle will break all kinds of records.
  10. Barnald
    Fine. But we're taking BB's shit rescore thread with us.
  11. Barnald
    I like to think that when they all come for this sub-forum us loyal few will die defending it.
  12. Barnald

    .

    Barnald replied to BloodBoal's topic in Tolkien Central

    I don't know, I still think the eagles theme was meant to score their initial arrival, as in the film. That just doesn't sound right over Beorn's bits.
  13. Barnald
    I'm sure back in 2013 I read something about Jed Brophy confirming they'd just recorded a commentary. Perhaps he was mistaken and was talking about interviews?
  14. Barnald
    There's a challenge. I blame Warner, either for skimping, or possibly even wanting to hold them back for this ultimate box set.
  15. Barnald
    He just stole it from TORN!
  16. Barnald
    Page did Death Wish 3 as well. You're right about it being nasty and exploitative, but crap is just harsh! That bit in 3 is hilarious. They get a call saying the guy's wife is going to be okay, but then when they get there they're told his wife "has expired".
  17. Barnald
    Death Wish 2. A Bronson classic of course (if not quite as good as 1 and 3, my personal favourite), and great to finally have the uncut version on Blu-ray. Has Jimmy Page's tremendous score ever been discussed in these parts?
  18. Barnald
    Or indeed what type of jelly he likes on his pizza
  19. Barnald
    Flavour is always pivotal
  20. Barnald
    I'm disappointed no one asked if the rumours of a naked wrestling match between Williams and Giacchino to decide who scored TFA (while Abrams watched on) were true or not.
  21. Barnald

    .

    Barnald replied to BloodBoal's topic in Tolkien Central

    The theme works great in that scene. It's probably one of my favourite additions.
  22. Barnald
    I like maps, so that's not a problem.
  23. Barnald
    You're just jealous of my pop-up Hobbit book aren't you? Admit it.
  24. Barnald
    I too ordered the two art books the other day (they're going to be a Christmas present to myself). The only Tolkien-related books I want now are indeed The Annotated Hobbit, which I can't believe I don't have yet, and that Adventures of Tom Bombadil edition that was released recently.
  25. Barnald

    .

    Barnald replied to BloodBoal's topic in Tolkien Central

    No one cared in the first place BB. Therefore you must carry on.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.

  I accept