Indianagirl

Kitten, You are doing a good job of this yourself.

Everyone needs to call out Kitten so he will ignore us all and we will be free of his gibberish

LOL I'm normally not a fan of today's comic book movies at all.....But I did like Wonder Woman

Where I come from they call that slavery.

That's not Rey's mother. That thing gave birth to Kitten.

Rey has flaws. Chief among them is she is Far TOO TRUSTING! A flaw possibly passed along thru her mother. In TLJ this flaw very nearly cost her not only her life but It very nearly cost the entire galaxy a doomed fate.

Wait....who thinks Rey doesn't have flaws??????

Oh Kitten, You didn't. Take one look thru the happy birthday Kathy Kennedy tweet or facebook and you quickly find out how much in the minority you people are. Solo's box office is due to multiple reasons some of which we probably don't even know. Your self-entitled little movement is quite insignificant. We are the silent majority.

I'd pay good money to see that

It's like the whole world has gone mad

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKzu0yeoQaU Has anyone seen this nonsense?

Would Piglet be acceptable?

Yeah you further clarified after you were called out and after you tried to defend your original statement several times after that. You couldn't let it go and you kept digging deeper in the process. Congratulations, Kitten. Perhaps you are finally learning to put a sock in it. Hogwash! Kennedy wears many hats and overseeing and helping writers develop story is one of them. Want to know where the decision that Kylo Ren was trying to immitate Darth Vader by wearing the mask rather than needing it to survive came from? Kathy Kennedy. Such as?

Stern, if this factory ever produces a shell that can actually be fired, I'll be very unhappy.

There is truth in that but there are over riding story and character elements that are set in stone for all three trilogies.

There you go Mansplaining to me again. You made a perfectly clear statement in another thread that completely contradicts your above comment and because I dared to hold You to Your own words You had to Mansplain me by telling me I've misunderstood. Clearly You think I'm not intelligent enough to remember your original statement. Here is your original statement... "But if the scene was meant to show "forced child labor", which I'm assuming it was, that is SJW in Star Wars. And most fans would agree that it does not belong." You clearly reduced forced child labor to a common little SJW and informed us all that it does not belong in Star Wars. I don't believe for one second you actually think forced child labor is okay but it shows you are willing to say anything to press your agenda. This is why most people don't take you seriously. Because that is not a tactic pulled by a serious person. You don't want to be like that, Kitten.

Luke did die by self sacrafice. He sent the Legend that was Luke Skywalker to do it. There's a lot I could say here but I have a few things around my house that need doing. I may come back and address this later.

There has been some of that and I think it's unfortunate and just has added fuel to the fire. However, in their defense the "complaint's" lodged were often so ridiculous in nature that many of these employees were dumbfounded. I seem to remember that being the case on more than one occasion with Pablo Hidalgo. I'm not convinced the boycott has anything to do with Solo under performing. I'm willing to be wrong on this but I really don't think the boycott has made even a small dent in the numbers. Really? I haven't read anything there. I just know that the polls they do are far from scientific and can't be taken seriously.

I don't care about what the "fans" want!!! George didn't care about what the fans want!!! Many of the fans are idiots. The last thing on earth we need is Lucasfilm pandering to what they think the fans might want. If you're so self-entitled that you need to be pandered to then go join the Marvel Universe. Leave Lucasfilm alone. No time to discuss this to a committee!!!

So?

Kitten, This is why I don't respect you. You make a false statement and someone comes along who unequivocally demonstrates it to be so and you respond as if it had never happened. You will literally say anything to keep your false narrative alive. Including when you attempted to suggest that passing judgement on child slavery was a kind of social justice moment that something like Star Wars shouldn't pass judgement on because it might be too preachy and make certain people uncomftorable. That was the moment I lost all respect for you. As for George not approving of Disney's material. First of all it's no longer his to approve or disprove of. He willingly sold the franchise with the intention they continue to build off of his canon. Secondly there is little evidence he doesn't largely approve of what Disney is doing. George did have an issue with the sequel trilogy not being about the twins but it remains to be seen if they will end up brother and sister. I personally think they will but who outside of Lucasfilm knows? He would have asthetically made Force Awakens look differently than it does but then again it's no longer his to make. We know that he liked Rogue One and Solo a lot. Solo was the one stand alone film that we know he wanted them to do. He was complimentary toward TLJ and I know of no actual quote to dispute that. So when you say George didn't approve of this Disney material not only is that not entirely accurate it also misses the point. You continually grasp at straws to keep your hateful agenda alive. That's not going to bring me to your side.

“I don’t read that stuff. I haven’t read any of the novels. I don’t know anything about that world. That’s a different world than my world. But I do try to keep it consistent. The way I do it now is they have a Star Wars Encyclopedia. So if I come up with a name or something else, I look it up and see if it has already been used. When I said [other people] could make their own Star Wars stories, we decided that, like Star Trek, we would have two universes: My universe and then this other one. They try to make their universe as consistent with mine as possible, but obviously they get enthusiastic and want to go off in other directions.” – George Lucas, from an interview in Starlog #337 Kitten the EU was never canon. It's more that I just don't respect you.

So you acknowledge there could be a master plan.

Yawn

I'm really hoping JJ has it in him. I too am glad Colin Trevorrow got the boot and I'm basing it soley on Jurassic World. I liked Jurassic World but I didn't think it captured the magic it so blatantly tried for. Episode 9 needs to be amazing. It needs to be a fitting end to the entire Skywalker Saga. That is a daunting task that leaves me as nervous as anyone for it. Nevertheless, I don't for one second think that Lucasfilm is just winging this from one director to the next with out an overall storyline. That storyline may of seen some adjustments as time went by but I don't buy into the whole bit that Rian Johnson came in and completely undid JJ's story. I've followed not just the films but also the books and I can tell you that this is going somewhere. And for anyone who is not following the cannon as closely but is interested in how we got from Return of the Jedi to The Force Awakens....read BLOODLINE!