Jump to content

Jurassic Shark

Members
  • Posts

    31,997
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    67

Posts posted by Jurassic Shark

  1. 1 minute ago, Richard Penna said:

     

    Hymn is nice but it gets OTT towards the end with the choir. I used to like bits of the rest of the score such as Omaha Beach but I never connect with JW's long drawn out dramatic pieces (usually his finale tracks). That's not just a JW thing - I have the same issue with Horner's 10 minute tracks.

     

    What about the final tracks of the Braveheart OST?

  2. 41 minutes ago, Steve McQueen said:

    The spirit of the baroque was more performer centered than composer centered, to be fair.

    So wildly differing interpretations are quite acceptable, I think.  I don't like the idea that "historically accurate" interpretations are superior.  All interpretations are in their own way valid.

     

     

    I don't really care what's considered right and wrong, as long as they make the music sound great!

  3. I like and listen to both.

     

    3 minutes ago, Disco Stu said:

    I watched one Apollo's Fire video like 2 years ago and Youtube refuses to stop recommending me all of their videos ever since.

    Too Ren Faire-ish for me

     

    Period performance groups really are hit and miss with me. Some really make it, some don't. What do you think about the tracks I suggested above?

  4. 18 minutes ago, bollemanneke said:

    So are you both saying that, when it comes to baroque, there is no one single right interpretation of a certain piece? Jurassic Shark uses the expression 'informed guesswork, but isn't that the same as saying 'we really have no clue at all?' I'm getting the impression that all Harnoncourt wanted to do is being different than everyone else.

     

    From what I've read on the subject, historical instruments and written historical accounts are used as the basis to get the music as close as possible to how it was played back then. Of course, such old accounts are neither complete nor 100% reliable, and we can never be sure how the performances actually sounded back then. But I have the impression that most of the well-known groups really strive to be as authentic as possible (such as Pinnock, Hogwood, Carmignola, Akademie für Alte Musik Berlin), while a few clearly exaggerate (such as Il Giardino Armonico). A common criticism of the early historical performance groups (such as Harnoncourt) is that they took things too far, sounding too eccentric.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.