Jump to content

Tom

Members
  • Posts

    2,754
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Posts posted by Tom

  1. I hope the new themes don't suck (by Williams standards) like in his most recent work. Sorry, guys. I love him too and I'm sure you'll all disagree with me, but his themes for Crystal Skull, Tintin and War Horse were pretty bland, forgettable and just kinda awful by Williams standards. For me, the majority of the standout music in those scores were little one-off moments. I can barely listen to Crystal Skull and that's a ******* Indiana Jones score for Christ's sake. I know the movie was about as terrible as they come, but Jesus. I guess Williams is no Goldsmith.

    What an original post. Please tell us more.

  2. I understand the criticism of the appropriateness of mutt's theme from the point of the view of film criticism--I do not understand how that is relevant as it pertains to the music itself. At the end of the day, the only thing I judge a piece of music on is its acoustic aesthetic value. The adventures of mutt is a fun and exciting piece that is cleverly orchestrated. Whether it was meant for Hitler, Mutt, or William's goldfish makes no difference in terms of appraising the piece of music itself.

  3. I guess that we will have a better picture of things once the recording dates are announced. I suppose he could do what he did with Tintin and begin star wars now, score another picture, and then finish star wars. My hunch, however, is that the main, if not only, recording dates will be late winter/early spring. We will find out soon enough.

    also, I am assuming that he is scoring the Spielberg picture, which has not been confirmed.

  4. Just listened to this again after a couple of weeks--I find it better and better with each listen. I mention somewhere above that I hope this turns out to be a movement in a full concerto. Further speculation on my part: unless the Chinese orchestra specifically asked for a piano and orchestra piece (which seems unlikely to me), it seems that there is a good chance it is part of a larger concerto. Again, speculative, but if they asked him for a piece, but he was already committed to pieces like the brass composition, Star Spangled banner, etc, he could have then offered the Scherzo as a standalone piece (assuming that he had already been working on the overall concerto).

    It also seems odd that there are no notes about the piece, which he usually gives for premieres. I realize I sound like a crazy person, so I will stop now.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.