Giftheck

I'm just fiddling with the tracks a bit more. It seems the clean transition from the first chord to the snare roll for Anakin Defeats Sebulba can be found in a DVD rip of AotC. I'm also working off the theory that Battle of Naboo I (aka Courtyard Crossfire) is a separate cue from Laser Fight March (after hearing that the Laser Fight march is always separate whenever I hear it save when it is in Jedi Power Battles and Obi-Wan VG seems to have a clean ending for BoN1)

I listened to Arrival at Tatooine on the UE. I could swear the opening statements of Jar-Jar's theme there are tracked. It fits exactly with the OST from what I found.

I would assume that like in the cartoon version, some of the music will be tracked in but then there will be a lot of new material. I would prefer it if "The Arena" and "Boun ty Hunter's Pursuit" weren't the only ones this time around though. Include some TPM or Revenge of the Sith!

GoodMusician's edit should have already incorperated all of the BF2 PS2 rip that I gave to him. Yeah. I got mine off FFShrine so it's incomplete. I'd like to know how to do it though so I can complete it. Though better not discuss that in the thread since that's DVD ripping discussion.

Exactly. Which was part of the reason I thought a AotC UE should have been released - for the previously unreleased TPM stuff.

What would you prefer? Sony is far too "They hated the TPM UE so we won't release any more so-called completed scores". I see it like this. Edits such as these are statements to Sony to get off their backsides and release the material.

Ah, well. For more completeness I've edited it into my set, as well as the film version of the Battle of Coruscant Suite (The solo War Drums were reassembled from both front channel and rear channel DVD rip, though I won't tell you how I got it - what with it being against board rules) If you do rip the DVD for the film suite (if you want your edit to be as complete as possible) I would recommend overlapping the rear channel's taiko drums over the Battlefront II rip of Boys into Battle so they sound as even as possible. I may post a low-quality sample of it. Though people here seem to be pretty 'anti-film version', so I doubt many of you would have the film suite in your edit. I'm going to work on stuff with the aid of a Battlefront II PS2 rip and GoodMusician's earlier Episode III edit I found where someone else had posted it and claimed it's theirs. However if I did release a complete Episode III score, it would be GoodMusician's name under the credits, not mine (for those who think I'd rip him off, no chance. I don't believe in doing that sort of thing, or my TPM edit would have been all his and none of my work. That is something that I have seen on Tomb Raider Level Editor forums)I'm also going to see what I can do with the tracked stuff from TPM/AotC. EDIT: I see lordskylark is back, but I wonder if he was ordered to remove the FTP... if it has, we should be told sooner rather than later.

I had a look into the film version of "Boys into Battle". Material here: BF2 boys_into_battle_2 1:15.5-1:19 BF2 boys_into_battle_2_PC 1:18.5-1:19.5 in the film is war-drum-less. And the version of "Battle of the Heroes" that appears in-film has a loop of a certain part but this loop is choirless.

heh... the internet is real picky like that. Out of curiosity, when are you putting Episode III back up? I had to get rid due to limited Hard Drive space (and it was the one I told you about so it's likely out of date anyway)

GoodMusician, the MP3 link for the new "Droids Confer" track does not work.

Without word from John Williams himself where that cue goes, I'm afraid we can only go on what we know. I personally believe that goes to the bit between the Droid Invasion and Intro Jar-Jar where Obi-Wan is being chased by the STAPs, and Qui-Gon deflects their fire. It seems to fit perfectly for that scene.

I thought it might go somewhere after the Droid Invasion is finished but before the cue Introducing Jar-Jar begins.

I've listened to it. I couldn't believe he got the tracked music 100% absolutely correct! There's one tracked piece missing but that's actually irrelevant (about 10 seconds long from "Search for Shmi" but to be honest the track sounds a lot better without the tracked bit in it) I'd strongly recommend this edit to anyone and everyone who's a fan of Williams. It's the best AotC score I've heard in a long time. Once again, a brilliant effort, GoodMusician.

Not true. There's about a minute of music missing from the scene which Smith realises his prediction is coming true. On the album that segues straight from where Smith smashes Neo to the ground to "You were right Smith". There's also alternative orchestrations of Neodammerung and Navras. But that discussion isn't really for this thread.

Well at least they didn't just DL it and claim it's all theirs. They gave a link to it in my FFShrine thread and even mentioned me. How very considerate. Although I did recommend that they listen to other sets too. Not just mine. Mine's not the full picture, and probably won't be for a while - I'm relying only on what I can download since I cannot rip form games I don't have (save Jedi Power Battles - I can't rip from that period) I'll probably stop doing these after I finish completely with TPM anyway (Although I quite fancy doing a complete Matrix Revolutions score at some point, but that's not for here). AotC sounded like a nightmare for GoodMusician to do. EDIT: Listening to the AotC Edit now. Sounds amazing. Sony should definately have done something like this. In fact, I doubt Sony could top this.

I listened to the Battle of Naboo III in the Phantom Menace UE (The Battle Rages On, disc 2) and it appears that the version of this track has a slightly different instrumentation, and a different ending that was missed from "The Republic Pilots Take Off". The ending of this cue misses the final timpani hit, but there is only a clean ending in-film at the end of the scene where the Federation Pilots begin the fight (It ducks out after "Fighters, straight ahead!")

This is... wow. I think nobody can top this at all. This looks really good.

I did manage to hear (after a few listens) what seems to be an artificial segue between the opening measures of the cue and the rest of the cue. I do wonder why it was omitted though. I suppose Lucas felt one or the other would do. Hence why you can't hear this part in the video games since VGs rarely use the actual movie music (save for LEGO Star Wars).

I wonder if now this thing will ever get back on topic... <_< Updated my track list. BTW, GM, do you have a blog? On FFShrine in my SW Soundtracks thread I got posted a link to an edit that is definitely your TPM edit.

Exactly.

You can happily steal my edit It took no more that 20 minutes after finding the right percussion (Some I substituted - like timpani hits were subsituted sometimes by material from TPM Bubble World)

I worked on an enhanced TPM track list a while back, but when I found tons of new material for my 'complete' score, I abandoned this list. Now I've returned to finish this list. It is NOT the way my score is set out, but is the way an 'Expanded' score would be set out. I've replaced stuff that was from lower-quality files (namely Jedi Power Battles and TPM Video Game), though there may still be a couple of mistakes I didn't find. Key: DVD = DVD rip FOX = 1993 Arista/20th Century Fox Anthology GAL = LucasArts' Star Wars Galaxies GB = LucasArts' Star Wars Galactic Battlegrounds: Clone Campaigns (Saga) IG = LucasArts' Star Wars Insider's Guide JPB = LucasArts' Star Wars: Jedi Power Battles OBI = LucasArts' Star Wars: Obi-Wan OST = original soundtrack album to The Phantom Menace ROTSG = Star Wars Episode III Revenge of the Sith Video Game SF = LucasArts' Star Wars: Starfighter Special Edition TPMG = LucasArts' Star Wars: Episode I The Phantom Menace UE = The Phantom Menace: Ultimate Edition soundtrack Stuff noted with a * before the location/track/times is stuff I have exclusively, either from the Battlefront II PS2 rip on FFShrine or from a rip of TPM DVD. I'll send copies of this stuff to anyone who needs it (not a link to the material on FFShrine since A - you need to be a member to see links, and B - the rip lists each track like 000-star_wars_battlefront_ii_oga.mp3 - of course, if you like figuring out what is what, then I'll gladly send you the link, but why waste the hours I spent trying to understand what each track has in it? 1. 20th CENTURY FOX FANFARE UE d1 t1 all or * DVD fanfare all NOTE - this is the fanfare that was intended for the film. 2. MAIN TITLE/THE ARRIVAL/GAS LEAK/DROID FIGHT/QUEEN AMIDALA/THE DROID INVASION UE d1 t2 all UE d1 t3 all UE d1 t4 0:00-1:13 JPB 3e 0:45.5-0:46.5 UE d1 t4 1:14.5-end UE d1 t5 0:00-0:08.5 BF2 droid_fight 0:34.5-0:36 UE d1 t5 0:08.5-0:13.5 BF2 droid_fight 0:40.5-end GAL mus_player_v_creat_b_lp 0:00-0:01 UE d1 t5 0:29-1:25.5 (loop: 0:47-0:48) GAL mus_combat_q_vict 0:07.5-0:09.5 UE d1 t5 1:26-end UE d1 t6 0:00-0:22 OST t13 3:13-3:23 UE d1 t6 0:27-end UE d1 t7 0:00-0:21 OST t14 1:26-1:27 UE d1 t7 0:24.5-0:44 OST t14 1:36.5-1:44 GB Music03 1:14-1:15 (Include the first timpani hit, but the second belongs to 'Tentacles') JPB Music2e 0:00-0:00.5 (You only need the second timpani hit) BF2 laser_fight_march-armies_face_off-the_arena-droid_invasion 1:15.5-1:37 OST t14 1:59-2:07 JPB 2e 1:00-1:00.5 TPMG sqfight5end 0:03-end 3. INTRODUCING JAR JAR/BUBBLE WORLD OST t4 0:00-1:09 UE d1 t8 0:00-0:54.5 GAL mus_underwater_amb_b 0:44.5-end mix OST t10 0:00-0:14 UE d1 t9 0:05-3:00 OST t10 2:58.5-3:09.5 UE d1 t10 0:01.5-1:04 OST t10 4:11-4:13.5 UE d1 t10 1:06-end (loop: 1:11.5-1:14.5) 4. GONE FISHIN' UE d1 t11 0:00-0:32.5 OST t4 4:17-4:18.5 UE d1 t11 0:34-0:50 OST t14 4:34.5-4:52 UE d1 t11 0:50-end 5. TENTACLES UE d1 t12 0:00-1:08 (loop: 0:46-0:48) OST t14 3:10.5-3:15.5 UE d1 t12 1:11-end TPMG sqfedannounce 0:36-end 6. THEED PALACE ARRIVAL/YOU'RE UNDER ARREST/ESCAPE FROM NABOO/INTRO DARTH MAUL GAL mus_theed_palace_lp 0:49.5-end UE d1 t13 0:04-1:16 BF2 theed 1:07.5-1:14 BF2 theed 0:02-0:08.5 TPMG theedstalk 1:10-1:12 fade out TPMG theedstalk 1:12-1:13 mix UE d1 t13 1:26-1:47.5 JPB 6a 0:22-0:41.5 TPMG sqtheedattack 0:41.5-end mix GB Music04 0:00-0:07 UE d1 t14 0:07.5-1:23.5 OST t12 2:50.5-2:55.5 UE d1 t14 1:25-1:38.5 OST t12 3:09-3:11.5 UE d1 t14 1:40-end UE d1 t15 0:00-1:41.5 GB Music02 0:57.5-1:09.5 UE d1 t15 1:51.5-end UE d1 t16 all (loop: 0:42-0:47.5) 7. ARRIVAL AT TATOOINE/STREET BAND OF MOS ESPA/PADMÉ MEETS ANAKIN/DESERT WINDS/JAR JAR'S RUN-IN WITH SEBULBA/ANAKIN'S HOME AND THE INTRODUCTION TO THREEPIO UE d1 t17 all UE d1 t18 all UE d1 t19 0:00-1:10 IG bts_pyro 1:23.5-1:28 UE d1 t19 1:11.5-end UE d1 t20 all UE d1 t21 all UE d1 t22 all 8. RUNNING OUT OF TIME UE d1 t23 9. TALK OF PODRACING UE d1 t24 10. WATTO'S DEAL/KIDS AT PLAY UE d1 t25 UE d1 t26 11. THE RACER ROARS TO LIFE/THE SITH SPACECRAFT/MOS ESPA ARENA BAND/CHANCE CUBE/THE FLAG PARADE/JABBA INTRODUCTION/THE RACE BEGINS/ANAKIN DEFEATS SEBULBA UE d1 t27 UE d1 t28 UE d1 t29 UE d1 t30 0:00-1:44 OST t11 1:22-1:37.5 fade out OST t11 1:37.5-1:38 mix UE d1 t31 0:00.5-1:08.5 (loop: 0:56-0:57) OST t7 3:44.5-3:49.5 UE d1 t31 1:10-end UE d1 t32 0:00-1:11 OST t9 1:08.5-end 12. ANAKIN'S GREAT VICTORY UE d1 t34 all 13. THE STREET SINGER UE d1 t35 all DISC 2 1. ANAKIN IS FREE/DARTH AND QUI-GON/CORUSCANT ARRIVAL UE d2 t1 all UE d2 t2 all (loop: 0:06-0:08) UE d2 t3 all (loop: 3:15-3:18) (loop: 3:24-3:30.5) 2. THE QUEEN AND PALPATINE UE d2 t4 all 3. HIGH COUNCIL MEETING UE d2 t5 all 4. THE SENATE/ANAKIN'S TEST/HE IS THE CHOSEN ONE/NUTE AND RUNE CONFER WITH DARTH SIDIOUS/MOVING FORWARD/THE GUNGANS/WAR PLANS UE d2 t6 0:00-0:54.5 BF2 senate 0:18-0:31.5 UE d2 t6 1:03-end UE d2 t7 all UE d2 t8 all UE d2 t9 all UE d2 t10 all (loop: 0:47.5-0:49) UE d2 t11 all UE d2 t12 all 5. THE BATTLE OF NABOO I (THE GUNGANS MARCH/THE ARMIES FACE OFF/THE BATTLE BEGINS/LASER FIGHT MARCH) UE d2 t13 all UE d2 t14 0:00-0:01.5 GB CIV2 0:01.5-0:03.5 JPB Music6d 0:27-0:33.5 GAL grasslands_mus_lp 0:02-0:24 JPB Music6d 0:55.5-1:00.5 BF2 armies_face_off 0:00-0:01.5 OST t14 0:31.5-0:34 (Original material here segues directly from last track into this one with a bit of fiddling) UE d2 t18 0:03-0:44 (loop: 0:29-0:39) BF2 armies_face_off 0:34.5-end UE d2 t16 0:00-0:02.5 BF2 escape_from_naboo-battle_begins-battleship_destroyed 1:45.5-1:46.5 UE d2 t16 0:02.5-0:12.5 BF2 escape_from_naboo-battle_begins-battleship_destroyed 1:56.5-1:59.5 UE d2 t16 0:15-0:23 JPB Music4a 2:37.5-2:38.5 fade out JPB Music4a 2:38.5-2:39 mix JPB Music5c 0:00-0:17 SF n21 0:31-0:52.5 RC musGEO_jwbattle05B_lp 0:02-0:07 or ROTSG elevbattle01 0:17-0:22.5 TPMG sqplayerdeath all -If you chose ROTSG elevbattle01, then don't copy the first note from TPMG sqplayerdeath 6. THE BATTLE OF NABOO II (TAKE TO YOUR SHIPS/THE DUEL BEGINS/ANAKIN TAKES OFF) OST t12 0:00-0:35.5 UE d2 t17 0:54.5-0:58.0 SF n09 0:36.0-0:39.5 JPB Music4a 1:24-1:37.5 OST t12 0:36-1:57.5 TPMG sqassaultintro all OST t12 1:57.5-2:39 GB won2 0:39-end 7. DUEL OF THE FATES OBI m_credits 0:52-1:34.5 OBI m_maul 0:18-1:49 OBI m_credits 1:37.5-end 8. THE BATTLE OF NABOO III (THE DROID BATTLE/UP THE WIRE/THE GREAT DUEL/CRASH LANDING/QUI-GON'S NOBLE END) TPMG sqgripping2 0:00-0:10 BF2 bounty_hunter's_pursuit-up_the_wire 0:23-0:33 TPMG sqgripping2 0:20.5-end mix OST t5 0:19-end TPMG sqmaulduelstart mix (at 0:10) DVD great_dual 1:59.5-2:54 (EQ: reduce bass) TPMG sqfightmaul2end 0:00.5-end mix OBI m_suspense_14 0:00-0:02 UE d2 t25 0:01.5-0:13 OBI m_suspense_14 0:13.5-end BF2 anakin_defeats_sebulba-gungans_retreat 0:20-0:46 UE d1 t33 1:57.5-end mix/fade in UE d2 t26 1:35-end UE d2 t27 0:00-0:26 OST t15 1:52-2:18 UE d2 t27 0:48.5-end (loop 1:59.5-2:05.5) 9. BATTLESHIP DESTROYED/DEATH OF DARTH MAUL UE d2 t28 0:00-1:28 GB Music03 4:22-end mix UE d2 t28 1:47-end 10. CONFERRING WITH YODA/QUI-GON'S FUNERAL UE d2 t29 all UE d2 t30 all 11. AUGIE'S GREAT MUNICIPAL BAND/END CREDITS (FILM VERSION) * DVD parade 0:00.5-0:32 UE d2 t31 0:32-0:47 * DVD parade 0:47-1:00.5 UE d2 t31 1:00.5-end UE d2 t32 0:00-0:52.5 * DVD parade 2:16.5-end 12. RUN-IN WITH JAR-JAR TPMG sqdanger1 0:00-0:06 UE d1 t7 0:51-end 13. HIGH COUNCIL MEETING (ALTERNATIVE) GAL mus_jungle_amb_b all NOTE: Anakin's Test (Alternate) was, upon investigation, incorrect. The melody in the first few seconds sounds like an alternate to the end of UE D2 t3 (As heard in both GM's edit and mine), while the rest is a clean ending for 'Anakin's Test' 14. THE GUNGANS MARCH (ALTERNATIVE) OST t14 0:00-0:29.5 or TPMG sqstalk1 0:00-0:29.5 (alternative recording) TPMG sqstalk1end all 15. CRASH LANDING (ALTERNATIVE) TPMG sqgripping1 0:00-0:11.5 * BF2 crash_landing-the_duel_begins-qui-gon's_noble_end 0:00-0:27.5 TPMG sqgripping1 0:39-end 16. AUGIE'S GREAT MUNICIPAL BAND/END CREDITS/DUEL OF THE FATES/ANAKIN'S THEME (ALBUM VERSION) UE d2 t31 all UE d2 t32 all 17. DUEL OF THE FATES (ORCHESTRAL VERSION) NOTE: No complete version is available, but you can at least make the first two or so minutes of it. OST t15 0:00-0:10.5 UE d2 t20 0:13-0:17 GB Music01 0:01.5-1:49.5 OST t2 2:04.5-2:44 ?? (unreleased but matches OST t2 2:44-2:55) UE d2 t20 0:29-0:41 ?? (unreleased) OST t2 3:22.5-3:43.5 ?? (unreleased but matches OST t2 3:43.5-3:55) UE d2 t20 0:29-0:41 ?? (unreleased but matches OST t2 4:01-4:04) OST t2 4:40-end ========= As said, if you would like the new material, PM me for it. I'm not going to post any links to it on this forum.

I made the tracked music for my AotC Edit. The edits are very jarring, and it was a difficult task to find the percussion for the track transitions.

Having heard both your previous prequel edits, I think this will be quite good. Would you be doing the tracked TPM stuff in there (Jedi vs Droid/The Battle of Geonosis)

:cool: Spielberg is "planned" to direct DH? Please evaluate. It was in the Daily Express (British newspaper if you don't know) a week ago, under "Harry Potter and the Film of Two Halves". Apparently, the producers are trying to get Spielberg into the final film. The Express is a very reliable source (if it appeared in a newspaper like the Sun I wouldn't have taken it seriously, but I happen to trust the Express)