Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
4 minutes ago, BloodBoal said:

Meanwhile, in an alternate universe:

 

The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring

Music composed by Wojciech Kilar

 

The Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers

Music composed by James Horner

 

The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King

Music composed by Basil Poledouris

In another alternate universe...

 

Wilst thou soar? Or wilst thou suck? The Legend of Zelda: by Basil Poledouris

Posted

Of those three I'd pick Poledouris to do the trilogy. I'm barely aware of Kilar's music, but what little I've heard wasn't quite my thing. I think nine hours of Horner fantasy would wear me out - there are only a small handful of his bigger scores that I can handle in full.

 

But I like that Shore's music feels authentic to Middle Earth without becoming pretentious - it's fun and spectacular and scary. No doubt PJ made the right choice.

Posted
21 hours ago, The Score Cleaner said:

In another alternate universe...

 

Wilst thou soar? Or wilst thou suck? The Legend of Zelda: by Basil Poledouris

 

It already exists and it's glorious:

 

 

Posted
2 hours ago, BloodBoal said:

 

It already exists and it's glorious:

 

 

As if that wasn't what I was referencing ;) (and the OOT trailer before it)

Posted
6 hours ago, Richard P said:

Of those three I'd pick Poledouris to do the trilogy. I'm barely aware of Kilar's music, but what little I've heard wasn't quite my thing. I think nine hours of Horner fantasy would wear me out - there are only a small handful of his bigger scores that I can handle in full.

 

But I like that Shore's music feels authentic to Middle Earth without becoming pretentious - it's fun and spectacular and scary. No doubt PJ made the right choice.

A Horner LOTR would've sounded exactly like most Horner scores from the time. I can already see people bitching both then and now: "Aragorn's theme is just Tristan's theme from Legends of the Fall!", "The Shire music is just Braveheart leftovers!", "Why is Celine Dion singing the Aragorn and Arwen love theme!?".

 

Now, I'm a massive Horner fan and apologist, and his post-Titanic up to The New World (which was exactly when he got the invitation) is my favorite period of his career, so I probably would've enjoyed it, whether it'd be just one score or the whole trilogy. Still, I wouldn't change what we got for it.

 

I'm not sure about Poledouris (would he had made it his third Conan score, or his style changed too much in the years since?), but Kilar's music would probably be a bit too European and classical-sounding. Shore rooted his music in the European orchestral and operatic tradition, but he still made it just"Hollywood-y" enough so as to not alienate the audience - precisely the mistake Gabriel Yared committed with Troy.

Posted
On 08/03/2026 at 7:44 PM, #SnowyVernalSpringsEternal said:

Nobody does is better

I like Poledouris' score for Conan the Barbarian, more than anything in the Lord of the Rings.

So, if it was possibly on that level, I think it would be great!

Posted
16 minutes ago, filmmusic said:

I like Poledouris' score for Conan the Barbarian, more than anything in the Lord of the Rings.

So, if it was possibly on that level, I think it would be great!

It's the cover isn't it, with almost shirtless Arnold

Posted
1 hour ago, BloodBoal said:

Poledouris' The Lord Of The Rings could have been really something.

 

While both his Conan The Barbarian score and Shore's work are of course vastly different, there is one thing they have in common that really elevates those them: how the composers brilliantly capture musically the "distant, really ancient world" aspect of their respective films. Both scores absolutely nail that sound to perfection.

 

Just tell me this would not feel right at home in Middle-Earth:

 

 

That first one almost feels Rozsa-ish, like Quo Vadis.

 

 

Posted
7 hours ago, The Score Cleaner said:

That first one almost feels Rozsa-ish, like Quo Vadis

 

Ah, nice catch!

 

It almost sounds like you can hear the 'Quo Vadis Domine' phrase at 01:09.

Posted
9 minutes ago, BloodBoal said:

 

Ah, nice catch!

 

It almost sounds like you can hear the 'Quo Vadis Domine' phrase at 01:09.

The opening, also reminds me of a cross of On the Doorstep and the end of Return to Vulcan (album version I think)

Posted
11 hours ago, BloodBoal said:
19 hours ago, The Score Cleaner said:

That first one almost feels Rozsa-ish, like Quo Vadis

 

Ah, nice catch!

 

It almost sounds like you can hear the 'Quo Vadis Domine' phrase at 01:09.

 

Some of the stuff that was left off the Conan album versions has always reminded me of Rózsa.

Posted
On 7/3/2026 at 7:36 PM, Mr. Hooper said:

'Looking for Richard'

 

An intimate portrait of one man's (Jurassic Shark) quest to find his friend (Naïve Old Fart), on the unforgiving dune pastureland of the Outer Hebrides, off the west coast of mainland Scotland.

 

Mark Kermode hails it as "A triumph of the indomitable human spirit... But he really could've just mailed that CD."


@Naïve Old Fart


I don't think I'll ever get around to seeing this, but I need to know which CD Jurassic Shark felt it necessary to travel all that way to hand-deliver to you...

 

Please put the answer in a spoiler box so not to ruin it for others. :D

Posted
9 minutes ago, Mr. Hooper said:

I don't think I'll ever get around to seeing this, but I need to know which CD Jurassic Shark felt it necessary to travel all that way to hand-deliver to you...

 

Probably Lady Jane… :rolleyes:

Posted
30 minutes ago, Marian Schedenig said:

 

Probably Lady Jane… :rolleyes:

 

Sadly it's OOP, so it would have to be Roy Budd's Phantom of the Opera.

Posted

@Jurassic SharkI never heard of Lady Jane until you mentioned it a couple weeks ago.  What am I missing out on?

Posted

"Did someone call for me?"

 

image.jpeg


 

Me: "No, he said "Lady Jane," not "Lady Jaye." :)

 

 

image.png
 

"Fine, but you don't know what you're missing..."

 

 

 

Posted

I’m glad I’m not the only one whose mind went to Lady Jaye. :lol:

  • 1 month later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.