Am I Alone? Infinity War Is The Worst MCU OST.

[Jedi767 5]

I noticed the 1st viewing of Infinity War (a movie which I think is awesome) that the soundtrack was abysmal. Had it been scored by someone who actually cared, I feel the movie would've been elevated to something far more incredible. Hard to have an incredible movie with a soundtrack this bad. 

 

I always thought the online groups / forums would agree, but there seems to be some crazy fanboy blind eye witchcraft going on when it comes to this soundtrack. Not only is it the worst of all 3 Avengers films soundtracks (totally throwing away the excellent themes created in Age Of Ultron), I believe it is the worst MCU soundtrack of all time. 

 

Its just background music.

 

Can you name 3 excellent songs on this OST you can listen to over and over that come close to some of the great themes found elsewhere in the MCU... 

 

Sorry, I've bottled this up for almost a year now and I cant stand seeing the nonstop praise for one of the worst soundtracks to a comic film - ever. 

[John 2016]

I liked the score, though you are definitely not alone with your opinion that you feel it is an underwhelming effort. I see more criticism than praise for it on this site.

[Jedi767 5]

2 minutes ago, John said:

I liked the score, though you are definitely not alone with your opinion that you feel it is an underwhelming effort. I see more criticism than praise for it on this site.

 

That's good to hear. An incredible score could have truly elevated that film. Bryan Tyler / Danny Elfman should've been brought back. Or Literally anyone else.

 

It's weird because Winter Soldier is one of the best MCU OST's, then Civil War & Infinity War are the 2 worst. Strange to see the Russo Bro's royally screw up their soundtracks after such a hit.

[The Illustrious Jerry 2464]

Personally, I think Infinity War was a good score. My disappointment comes from what it could've been and simply wasn't. 

 

Silvestri had had the chance to, with this grand culmination of sixty plus superheroes coming together in one film, create a grand Wagnerian opera. Many of these characters had pre-existing themes which were very much at his disposal, yet the lack of grand thematic material takes away much of the interest of the score. It really could've been an epic motif festival, and the exploration of this possibility may have been to much to collect for Silvestri. I'm not sure if another composer could've done it to perfection, but they certainly could've given it a shot.

[Jedi767 5]

2 minutes ago, The Illustrious Jerry said:

Personally, I think Infinity War was a good score. My disappointment comes from what it could've been and simply wasn't. 

 

Silvestri had had the chance to, with this grand culmination of sixty plus superheroes coming together in one film, create a grand Wagnerian opera. Many of these characters had pre-existing themes which were very much at his disposal, yet the lack of grand thematic material takes away much of the interest of the score. It really could've been an epic motif festival, and the exploration of this possibility may have been to much to collect for Silvestri. I'm not sure if another composer could've done it to perfection, but they certainly could've given it a shot.

 

Thank you! Written much better than I could have ever hoped to. 

 

It's so sad that he's the one doing End Game. We're going to see the end of these characters we've been with for over 10 years (Iron Man, Captain America, Thor), and the music will surely just be more background phone-it-in crap. Would have been cool to bring in Henry Jackman, Bryan Tyler, Danny Elfman, Giacchino, and (I guess) Silvestri all to collaborate on End Game - the most epic ensemble film of all time.

[The Illustrious Jerry 2464]

I'm sure Silvestri will still write a good score for End Game. It just won't be what we would hope for given the opportunity.

[Jedi767 5]

3 minutes ago, The Illustrious Jerry said:

I'm sure Silvestri will still write a good score for End Game. It just won't be what we would hope for given the opportunity.

 

Just out of curiosity (maybe I'm being too harsh on Infinity War) - what would you consider a bad score from a recent blockbuster?

[Dixon Hill 4142]

45 minutes ago, The Illustrious Jerry said:

I'm not sure if another composer could've done it to perfection, but they certainly could've given it a shot.

 

40 minutes ago, Jedi767 said:

Would have been cool to bring in Henry Jackman, Bryan Tyler, Danny Elfman, Giacchino, and (I guess) Silvestri all to collaborate on End Game - the most epic ensemble film of all time.

 

Bring in whatever or however many composers you want, you're not going to get what you're after because the Russo's specifically said they didn't think it was the right direction to have a score crowded with all the characters' themes.

[JohnnyD 370]

I think you are being too harsh on Alan Silvestri’s work for Infinity War. To be fair, he did reprise a few motifs and passages from his score to The Avengers and Captain Smerica: The First Avenger (Tesseract motif, Captain America motif (subtle references, but it is present), and of course The Avengers theme). He also reprises Ludwig Göransson’s Black Panther theme (partially tracked, though). Though, I do agree that there should have been musical motifs associated with all of the characters, not just Thanos. Still, I liked the score and actually thought it blew Silvestri’s score to The Avengers out of the water. 

 

That is probably the only thing I don’t like about Marvel Studios: The musical scores lack a sense of musical continuity. Though, recently that has somewhat changed.

 

The scores I enjoyed were Iron Man 2, Thor (mainly the themes), Captain America: The First Avenger, The Avengers, Doctor Stange, Spider-Man: Homecoming, Thor: Ragnarok (mainly the orchestral tracks; the Sakaar material was appropriate, though), Black Panther and Avengers: Infinity War. I liked Ant-Man and Ant-Man and the Wasp. I liked Brian Tyler’s Iron Man theme (it’s catchy).

 

I honestly think Henry Jackman did an abysmal job with Captain America: The Winter Soldier. Half of that score is generic synthesized action rhythm, and he hardly ever referenced Alan Silvestri’s Captain America material, save the opening scene. The only thing that made his score to Captain America: Civil Wat a major improvement over that was that it was mostly orchestral.

 

The only memorable thing I can recall from Brian Tyler and Danny Elfman’s scores to Avengers: Age of Ultron were Danny Elfman’s extended arrangement of Alan Silvestri’s Avengers theme and Brian Tyler’s reprisals of his Iron Man theme.

 

Five memorable tracks from Infinity War: Even for You, Charge, Get That Arm / I Feel You, Porch, Infinity War...

 

On 2/10/2019 at 5:24 PM, Knox Harrington said:

Russo's specifically said they didn't think it was the right direction to have a score crowded with all the characters' themes.

 

You beat me to mentioning that.

[The Illustrious Jerry 2464]

3 hours ago, Knox Harrington said:

Bring in whatever or however many composers you want, you're not going to get what you're after because the Russo's specifically said they didn't think it was the right direction to have a score crowded with all the characters' themes.

Not crowded per se, but at least some decent thematic material inclusion beyond what was achieved with the final product.

[Þekþiþm 5414]

Bitter much?

 

It's just a film score.

[Kasey Kockroach 1959]

Yes, you are alone. Because no one will ever love you.

[Gruesome Son of a Bitch 4820]

I sometimes think I'm alone in my enjoyment of Corey Feldman's Ascension Millennium.

[Alexcremers 1789]

I thought  ET&Elliot was Ghostbusters II?!

[Þekþiþm 5414]

He's me.

[Alexcremers 1789]

Ultimately, yes.

[Obi 236]

The Best Scores of the MCU are :

 

Captain America - The First Avenger, Avengers, Avengers - Infinity War, Ant-Man and Black Panther.

I really love every minutes of all this scores. After, they are them who are great themes or pieces but the score are not entierely good like Doctor Strange, Homecoming or Iron Man 3.

[Kasey Kockroach 1959]

The best Marvel score is Batman Returns.

[Obi 236]

I prefer Superman.

[bollemanneke 1145]

Uh, no, you're definitely not alone. Silvestri's Marvel music is generally bad, minus the marches.

[MedigoScan 120]

I thought it was okay, with a few standout moments. But I agree that most of it blended together into some uniform mess.

[mstrox 3082]

The MCU started with Djawadi's "Iron Man," and from there, things could only possibly be better.

[Þekþiþm 5414]

I didn't mind his score.

[A. A. Ron 310]

I don't think any of Silvestri's Marvel scores are the worst. I don't think any of them are great though.

[Þekþiþm 5414]

I love the Helicarrier music.

[Fargo 150]

17 hours ago, Jedi767 said:

 

It's weird because Winter Soldier is one of the best MCU OST's

 

oh lawd have mercy

 

Now I want to rank 'em. Split into phases:

 

Phase 1

Good: Thor 1, Captain America 1

Average: The Incredible Hulk, Avengers 1

Bad: Iron Man 1

Never seen/heard: Iron Man 2

 

Phase 2

Good: Iron Man 3, Thor 2, Avengers 2

Average: Guardians 1, Ant-Man 1

Bad: Captain America 2

 

Phase 3

Good: Doctor Strange, Spider-Man 1, Thor 3

Average: Guardians 2, Black Panther, Avengers 3

Bad:

Never seen/heard: Captain America 3, Ant-Man 2

 

Best of the best: idk, none are great

Worst of the worst: Captain America 2. Absolute trash, Brock.

 

[Demondm810 251]

I disagree generally, as i think the score is wonderful.  I also think it may have been purposely understated, with hopes Endgame brings what everyone was expecting re: big themes, etc.  

[Alexcremers 1789]

54 minutes ago, Fargo said:

 

Average: The Incredible Hulk

 

Worst of the worst: Captain America 2. Absolute trash, Brock.

 

 

I rest my case!

[Fargo 150]

5 minutes ago, Alexcremers said:

 

I rest my case!

 

Grating electronic sound intensifies

 

Repeated strings for days!

[Obi 236]

 

 

[Jedi767 5]

Nothing in Infinity War comes close to this track alone: 

 

[Bayesian 290]

16 minutes ago, Jedi767 said:

Nothing in Infinity War comes close to this track alone: 

 

 

Well, sure. It's Danny Elfman, and it's never fair to compare Silvestri to him.

[Þekþiþm 5414]

Modern Silvestri > Modern Elfman.

[Bayesian 290]

1 minute ago, dougie said:

Modern Silvestri > Modern Elfman.

 

So very not true.

[Þekþiþm 5414]

Elfman got boring and generic, while Silvestri still does his big manly man music.

[A. A. Ron 310]

Silvestri has always been boring and generic. Elfman has always been brilliant, ok, or boring, but never generic.

[Fargo 150]

3 minutes ago, A. A. Ron said:

Silvestri has always been boring and generic. Elfman has always been brilliant, ok, or boring, but never generic.

 

[Þekþiþm 5414]

Elfman's been boring and generic since the mid-2000s. I just can't get excited about anything the guy does these days.

 

Silvestri's at least maintained his signature harmonic characteristics and has successfully adapted them to meet the demands of modern action/adventure cinema. It might not always necessarily make for great listening on CD - he needs better album production to get the most from his scores.

[Gruesome Son of a Bitch 4820]

I liked the Ready Player 1 main theme.

[TheUlyssesian 1010]

23 hours ago, The Illustrious Jerry said:

Personally, I think Infinity War was a good score. My disappointment comes from what it could've been and simply wasn't. 

 

Silvestri had had the chance to, with this grand culmination of sixty plus superheroes coming together in one film, create a grand Wagnerian opera. Many of these characters had pre-existing themes which were very much at his disposal, yet the lack of grand thematic material takes away much of the interest of the score. It really could've been an epic motif festival, and the exploration of this possibility may have been to much to collect for Silvestri. I'm not sure if another composer could've done it to perfection, but they certainly could've given it a shot.

 

Marvel wouldn't allow it.

 

I think Silvestri delivered the score that the producers/directors asked for.

 

I think the score was kinda unimportant in this movie in a weird way. I remember only one thing - and that is the memorable explosion of the main theme when Thor joins the battle but that's it.

[Jedi767 5]

16 minutes ago, TheUlyssesian said:

I think the score was kinda unimportant in this movie in a weird way. I remember only one thing - and that is the memorable explosion of the main theme when Thor joins the battle but that's it.

 

Exactly. The rest (besides a moment when Thor is taking the heat of the sun) is just useless background that could have been created by any random amateur.

 

Sad to see Silvestri go from something like Back To The Future to Infinity War. I do feel he has lost his touch. Sure the directors might have had something to do with the awful OST, but being the veteran he is he could have stepped up and said 'no, here is what you want & why'. 

 

What's frustrating is this was just Part 1 of an awful soundtrack. We're 2 months away from getting Part 2, which will likely be just as awful even though the film is even more epic.

[Demondm810 251]

oh lord. 

[Fargo 150]

16 hours ago, Jedi767 said:

 

being the veteran he is he could have stepped up and said 'no, here is what you want & why'. 

 

That's not how it works, almost ever. He is getting paid to do a job - if his employers want him to do a non-intrusive score, then that's what he's gonna do. It's literally what his job is.

[Þekþiþm 5414]

Can't we get a computer to do this?

[John 2016]

 

Let me put it this way, Mr. Drax. The Silvestri series is the most reliable film scoring computer ever made. No Silvestri computer has ever made a mistake or distorted a musical note. We are all, by any practical definition of the words, foolproof and incapable of error.

[Chen G. 1439]

16 hours ago, TheUlyssesian said:

I remember only one thing - and that is the memorable explosion of the main theme when Thor joins the battle but that's it.

 

That, and the ominous brass textures surrounding Thanos. That's all that's there to be gleaned from this score.

 

Although by the standards of Marvel scores (Silvestri's previous effort notwithstanding) that's not too bad.

[Obi 236]

23 hours ago, A. A. Ron said:

Silvestri has always been boring and generic. Elfman has always been brilliant, ok, or boring, but never generic.

 

Predator 2 is better than anything in the world, not including John Williams.

 

 

[Gruesome Son of a Bitch 4820]

Danny Elfman's Justice League score (AKA unlistenable garbage) was more disappointing than everything.

[Þekþiþm 5414]

19 hours ago, Ghostbusters II said:

Danny Elfman's Justice League score (AKA unlistenable garbage) was more disappointing than everything.

 

It was worse than almost everything.

[Fargo 150]

7 minutes ago, dougie said:

 

It was worse than almost everything.

 

Everything except The Winter Soldier