The Rise of Skywalker Star Wars IX The Rise Of Skywalker TEASER MUSIC discussion

[Disco Stu 8878]

On 4/15/2019 at 4:33 AM, TownerFan said:

I am a bit baffled by the amount of over-analysis about this new trailer music piece I read online. I mean, it's always great to see fans getting excited about new Star Wars music and trying to tie up things in musical terms (especially @Falstaft always insightful analysis). But in all honesty, I don't think this simple piece of music for an advertising item is worth such a torrent of words and thoughts, especially because this isn't composed by JW himself. I can certainly agree that it's a well-executed piece of music that succeeds in doing what a trailer should always do--getting people excited for the film itself. I honestly don't know if anything we're hearing in this piece is foreshadowing JW's actual music score we'll hear in TROS, nor any kind of plot reveal (all the talk about the link to the Dies Irae is fun, but imho a tad too stretched for this purpose).

 

Please allow me to direct you to my Youtube vlog where I expound in a painstaking 30 minute video how those four notes reveal the entire plot, beat for beat, of The Rise of Skywalker

[JoeinAR 1190]

On 4/12/2019 at 12:19 PM, lemoncurd said:

just the Dies Irae motif that is used in Burning Homestead from STAR WAR (the cue that has been tracked into TFA when Rey catches the light saber in the forest).

 

[Jay 12118]

Are you trying to say something Joe?

[JoeinAR 1190]

I believe I was most clear.

[Jay 12118]

By quoting a 5 day old post that has nothing to do with what Disco Stu said before you?

How so?

[Jurassic Shark 3755]

Only Joe has the superpower to see that clearly.

[JoeinAR 1190]

1 hour ago, Jay said:

By quoting a 5 day old post that has nothing to do with what Disco Stu said before you?

How so?

 You think in such three-dimensional terms. How small you've become.

[Gruesome Son of a Bitch 4814]

Marty, you're not thinking fourth-dimensionally!

[Quintus 4250]

This is heavy, man.

[MrJosh 132]

Hear me out on this one...the trailer composers are clearly giving us a hint about the film by blatantly quoting the TriStar Pictures logo theme at the end.

 

TriStar...Tri...Star, Three Starkillers. There will be 3 Starkiller bases in this film. 

[Jurassic Shark 3755]

Not one too many!

[JoeinAR 1190]

3 hours ago, Jay said:

By quoting a 5 day old post that has nothing to do with what Disco Stu said before you?

How so?

Some of us do not read or care to read all the posts or all the threads and if I quote something from days ago it is clearly not in response to a current posting but likely the quoted post itself. A prudent man would/should know this or maybe not.

[Jay 12118]

I understand that, but you didn't add any commentary to the quote that you quoted.  Your entire post consists only of the quote with nothing else.

[Stefancos 9622]

Leave the Moderating to me, Jason!

[Jurassic Shark 3755]

[rough cut 571]

It is very unclear, everything.

[Urple 1]

On 4/13/2019 at 8:51 AM, Manakin Skywalker said:

Anyone else notice that the 4 notes we hear during the title reveal are the same last 4 notes of the Columbia Pictures logo? 😂

 

 

 

OH GOSH THANK YOU

 

I created an account just to reply to this because this has been bugging me since the trailer launched. I could hear those notes so clearly and was convinced that it was the ending of a scene from the original trilogy, some transition piece that maybe even hinted at some hidden plot detail. But no, it's just Columbia. Disappointing, but immeasurably relieving. So, thank you!! :)

[rough cut 571]

Must be coincidence, right? Columbia doesn’t have anything to do with Disney.

[Jurassic Shark 3755]

Well, Sony did rerelease the expanded OT scores...

[rough cut 571]

True, but I’ll stand my ground.

[Stefancos 9622]

We got name-dropped on Twitter!

 

 

[Disco Stu 8878]

If she means the discussion is more measured and judicious here, then I agree.  As far as I'm aware, a trailer composer rarely has any insight into or knowledge of the film, so reading much into the music is just letting excitement run away with you.  Which is understandable, it's an exciting trailer.

[rough cut 571]

What did she mean?

[Bilbo 2562]

4 hours ago, Disco Stu said:

If she means the discussion is more measured and judicious here, then I agree.  As far as I'm aware, a trailer composer rarely has any insight into or knowledge of the film, so reading much into the music is just letting excitement run away with you.  Which is understandable, it's an exciting trailer.

 

I feel icky when I see regular Star Wars fans talking about film music. It’s ewwww.

[Disco Stu 8878]

21 minutes ago, Bilbo said:

 

I feel icky when I see regular Star Wars fans talking about film music. It’s ewwww.

 

Not only do most of them not realize that Williams didn't write the trailer music, I'm pretty sure most would not even understand there's really a difference.

[Manakin Skywalker 1082]

1 hour ago, Bilbo said:

I feel icky when I see regular Star Wars fans talking about film music. It’s ewwww.

 

That's actually a great way to describe it.

 

6 hours ago, Stefancos said:

We got name-dropped on Twitter!

 

We're famous!

[Bilbo 2562]

1 hour ago, Disco Stu said:

 

Not only do most of them not realize that Williams didn't write the trailer music, I'm pretty sure most would not even understand there's really a difference.

 

Dude, I love the song from the trailer! I hope it’s in the film! 

[Disco Stu 8878]

Just now, Bilbo said:

 

Dude, I love the song from the trailer! I hope it’s in the film! 

 

I appreciate their excitement, I really do.  It's great the films have scores that average fans even notice.  But yeah, I can't help cringing a little at times.  Maybe that makes me a snob!  I can't help it!

[Bilbo 2562]

Just now, Disco Stu said:

 

I appreciate their excitement, I really do.  It's great the films have scores that average fans even notice.  But yeah, I can't help cringing a little at times.  Maybe that makes me a snob!  I can't help it!

 

 

If it’s wrong I don’t want to be right!

[Manakin Skywalker 1082]

I saw some YouTube video about a year ago where someone was complaining about the music when Leia is sucked out of the Raddus' bridge. He went so far as to make a shitty mockup of what he thought would work better; basically sounded like generic trailer music. Yuck.

[kelliwisethebrave 38]

11 hours ago, Disco Stu said:

If she means the discussion is more measured and judicious here, then I agree.  As far as I'm aware, a trailer composer rarely has any insight into or knowledge of the film, so reading much into the music is just letting excitement run away with you.  Which is understandable, it's an exciting trailer.

 

Hi!, I'm in the she in question. You're more or less correct. Basically, the discussion of all SW music on twitter vs here is very different (for example, Rogue One's music is almost universally adored on SW twitter, but I get the impression that it is not well-loved here), but I've noticed it especially with trailers, where some on twitter often assume the trailer music is either written or chosen based on what is going to happen with the film's plot and themes. There's always a possibility that there's some direction or input from directors, etc but even if that were the case, it's probably not as significant as it's interpreted to be. A lot of people there are looking for any hint or clue to those things in marketing, which is understandable, but has some interesting results at this stage.

[Disco Stu 8878]

5 minutes ago, kelliwisethebrave said:

 

Hi!, I'm in the she in question. You're more or less correct. Basically, the discussion of all SW music on twitter vs here is very different (for example, Rogue One's music is almost universally adored on SW twitter, but I get the impression that it is not well-loved here), but I've noticed it especially with trailers, where some on twitter often assume the trailer music is either written or chosen based on what is going to happen with the film's plot and themes. There's always a possibility that there's some direction or input from directors, etc but even if that were the case, it's probably not as significant as it's interpreted to be. A lot of people there are looking for any hint or clue to those things in marketing, which is understandable, but has some interesting results at this stage.

 

It can be pretty fun to follow the discussions too!  Even if it’s all a bit silly!

 

Some people do get just a little bit too carried away though.

[Manakin Skywalker 1082]

1 hour ago, kelliwisethebrave said:

There's always a possibility that there's some direction or input from directors, etc but even if that were the case, it's probably not as significant as it's interpreted to be.

 

I believe JJ said a few years back that he was not at all involved in any of the trailers besides the first teaser. Apparently the editors were asked to send in several random clips to a trailer house, and they'd literally take care of the rest. A lot of people on social media seem to not realize that. I think I remember Rian mentioning that on Twitter as well. If there's one thing you're absolutely correct about, it's that there is a pretty noticeable contrast between the more "casual" fans (and some of the more hardcore fans as well) and people like us, who dissect everything.

[Disco Stu 8878]

I find it hard to believe that JJ’s not involved in the trailer.  But I guess he’s got plenty on his plate getting the movie finished in time.  I think he said in an interview there’s three months less post-production with TROS than with TFA

[Fal J. M. Skywalker 1784]

Sometimes the trailer music does almost seem to eerily predict aspects of the final score, for example The TLJ trailer music sounds a bit like "The Spark"

[crumbs 5975]

2 hours ago, kelliwisethebrave said:

A lot of people there are looking for any hint or clue to those things in marketing, which is understandable, but has some interesting results at this stage.

 

I thought the TLJ trailer music was interesting. 3 TFA themes were used prominently in the teaser, then the theatrical trailer actually used the ostinato from The Spark months before the score was released (but months after that cue was recorded). 

 

I speculated at the time, given the score's completion, and Disney's insistence on using Star Wars music in their marketing, that this ostinato might be a fragment of TLJ's score and that proved correct. 

 

The main difference with TROS is that Williams hasn't started writing the score, let alone recorded it, so there's little musical insight to be found in this particular teaser. The music itself appears to be an unused marketing track from TFA anyway.

[Manakin Skywalker 1082]

2 hours ago, crumbs said:

The main difference with TROS is that Williams hasn't started writing the score, let alone recorded it, so there's little musical insight to be found in this particular teaser. The music itself appears to be an unused marketing track from TFA anyway.

 

I guarantee he's written at least some of the score. They just haven't recorded it yet.

[crumbs 5975]

17 minutes ago, Manakin Skywalker said:

 

I guarantee he's written most of the score. They just haven't recorded it yet.

 

What makes you say that? Even Matessino said Williams probably wouldn't start working on it until the summer. 

 

It's a shame there's no concerts going on at the moment because we might get an update from Williams on the status of his score. I liked that anecdote about scoring TLJ he kept telling. 

[Manakin Skywalker 1082]

7 minutes ago, crumbs said:

 

What makes you say that? Even Matessino said Williams probably wouldn't start working on it until the summer.  

 

It's a shame there's no concerts going on at the moment because we might get an update from Williams on the status of his score. I liked that anecdote about scoring TLJ he kept telling. 

 

With recording sessions likely happening in the summer, I'm sure he's written something by now. I assume MM was referring to the sessions, not the writing itself.

[crumbs 5975]

11 minutes ago, Manakin Skywalker said:

 

With recording sessions likely happening in the summer, I'm sure he's written something by now. I assume MM was referring to the sessions, not the writing itself.

 

Would definitely be nice to have clarification,  there's a hell of a difference between writing and recording. 

 

I still think May/June is manageable for a writing start date. JW might prefer to record the whole score in one batch for JJ this time, after what happened with TFA.

[Manakin Skywalker 1082]

I would hope that's what they plan to do. The score would certainly be more cohesive.

[crumbs 5975]

JW: What's that, JJ Baby? You need thirty-seven cues revised from last week's sessions? What a shame the film's out next week and we left ourselves no time for revisions... 

JJ: But I changed the edit!

 

*car tires screeching out front, fresh skid marks trailing away from JW's parking spot*

[King Mark 1936]

why is anyone analyzing this trailer music. It's not even JW

 

i can't believe this is getting more attention than Galaxy's Edge

[crumbs 5975]

I can't believe it's not butter, but such is life. 

[Bilbo 2562]

There’s a proper recording of Galaxy’s Edge? 

 

 

Anyway, I’m not surprised that SW Twitter loves the Rogue One score. The vast vast vast majority probably don’t recognize the blown out cliches and poor writing because they don’t listen to enough film music to properly judge it. 

 

Nobody is saying they can’t like it though. 

[Balahkay 584]

I'd be very surprised if Williams hasn't been shown a rough cut by now and started writing.  Maybe he's not doing concerts right now because he intended to spend most of his time during these months writing TROS? 

 

If MM's "summer" remark is to be taken literally, the summer season officially starts June 21 and I doubt they will wait that long to start talking about the music.  

[Remco 251]

I have a very strong feeling he’s starting to write now, considered he finished the project with ASM and that he’s not conducting or attending in Boston next month.

[crumbs 5975]

It would be very cool if he spent the next few months just writing the new themes and end credits suite, before starting the score proper. It makes sense to wait until a more finalised edit of the film is ready.

[King Mark 1936]

I'm sure he's started

[Remco 251]

8 hours ago, crumbs said:

It would be very cool if he spent the next few months just writing the new themes and end credits suite, before starting the score proper. It makes sense to wait until a more finalised edit of the film is ready.

 

That probably takes him about a week!😁