POLL: How do the large scale music works for the Star Wars Saga (John Williams) and Middle Earth Saga (Howard Shore) compare?
POLL: How do the large scale music works for the Star Wars Saga (John Williams) and Middle Earth Saga (Howard Shore) compare?
22 members have voted
-
1. Which large scale work has the better themes and leitmotifs?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
-
2. Which large scale work has more complexity?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
-
3. Which large scale work has better evolution, development and manipulation of the themes and leitmotifs?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
-
4. Which large scale work better enhances scenes and supports storytelling within the films?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
-
5. Which large scale work better rewards stand alone listening experiences away from the film?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
-
6. Which large scale work is overall more original?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
-
7. Which large scale work is overall more ambitious?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
-
8. Which large scale work is more coherent or tied together or has more unity within it?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
-
9. Which large scale work is a greater work of film-scoring?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
-
10. Which large scale work is a greater work of music composition?
-
Middle-Earth Saga (6 films)
-
Star Wars Saga (9 films)
-
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now