Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Difficult question.

Maybe I would say Dear Basketball (2017).

If not, then I would probably fall back on Lincoln too.

(I haven't listened to the The Rise of Skywalker enough to pick a certain track from there, and I didn't really connect to some more recent obvious choices like Helena's theme or Mother and Son from The Fabelmans)

Posted
2 hours ago, Miguel Andrade said:

Le Concerto pour piano !

Similar

 

JB

Posted

Hmmm. I would say memoirs of a geisha. And if it didnt have a few cues basically being re-recordings of previous material, kingdom of the crystal skull. I dont know maybe tintin or war horse…

Posted
Just now, Luke Skywalker said:

Hmmm. I would say memoirs of a geisha

Oh, you went even further earlier! :o

Posted

Ah i didnt read correctly and i thought we were talking about complete works.

 

as a single piece masterpiece…

 

i supose something more recent could be rey’s theme. 
 

i had forgot the whole concept album across  the stars too.

Posted

Of Grit and Glory is a personal favorite.  The piano concerto is quite impressive.  In the vein of his other concertos but also having many unique moments.  

Posted

If we’re talking film scores, I’d say either Lincoln or The Force Awakens. Not to say anything since hasn’t been masterful, it’s just those two scores have the most lasting cultural impact.

 

Works in general? The Piano Concerto! What a tour de force that one is!

Posted

I'd say Memoirs of a Geisha was the last masterpiece of a full score, which isn't to discount some incredible scores which followed (War Horse and Lincoln being at the top of that list).

Posted
15 hours ago, HunterTech said:

I will forever love Helena's theme, but it's incredibly difficult to beat this

 

 

And I thought I was the only one who thought The Jedi Steps is an incredibly powerful theme and wished it was used and developed further than became the case. 

Posted

I agree with the comments about Helena's theme and Jedi Steps being his most recent best themes. I can't recall it right now, but I think his Obi Wan one was also solid.

Posted

War Horse

 

So rich in long-lined themes, English influence and overall quality. It's the most recent project where I think we got a perfect storm of a good canvas and a composer absolutely in their element. The problem with the Fabelmans for me is that the film just didn't need a prominent score on the same level, and as soon as you dilute the soundscape with pre-existing pieces, the score becomes connective material, rather than the most prominent aspect.

 

If we're talking about the last theme he wrote that reached undeniable widespread public recognition, it has to be Hedwig's theme.

Posted

If it's recent then I'm thinking in the last few years, and to my ears that has to be Helena's Theme from Dial of Destiny. I love how it feels almost inevitable in its melody, as only JW can do, it becomes an earworm that makes you want to absorb every little instance of it in the score. 

Posted

Dear basketball is amazing. Interestingly I think it’s one of the last JW score post -2015 that sounds like it could belong to a JW 2000s era.

 

The writing, the sound of the strings / brass.

something in the orchestration of JW changed in the 2010s era, sounded less “lush”, still amazing though 

Posted
On 14/02/2026 at 8:10 AM, Luke Skywalker said:

i supose something more recent could be rey’s theme. 

 

This was my vote.

Posted
On 15/2/2026 at 9:06 AM, Darth Mulder said:

Hedwig's Theme :D

 

Yeah, I'd probably have to go back to this to name a piece that elicited a pronouncement of "Holy shit!" from me at the end.

 

Yes, the highest praise. lol

Posted

Rey’s Theme.  It really was in my memory as the first time in some years up until then the score took over and drove the film, mixed so forward as we see the character sledding down that hill.  For a few moments, it was magical, and the “old” John Williams was back for what had felt like years.  
 

Harder to pick a Masterpiece Score, where every bit counts.  If I’m being honest, probably Temple of Doom. If I’m being generous, maaaaybe Hook, but it’s flawed. 

Posted
4 minutes ago, Andy said:

Harder to pick a Masterpiece Score, where every bit counts.  If I’m being honest, probably Temple of Doom. If I’m being generous, maaaaybe Hook, but it’s flawed. 

:o

Really?

That far behind?

Posted
13 minutes ago, filmmusic said:

:o

Really?

That far behind?

Perhaps he has a healthy fear of the Holocaust, dinosaurs, wizards, and being left home alone.  

Posted
12 minutes ago, Andy said:

Harder to pick a Masterpiece Score, where every bit counts.  If I’m being honest, probably Temple of Doom. If I’m being generous, maaaaybe Hook, but it’s flawed. 

 

I see what you mean. I would probably go with at least Last Crusade. (Or Always!) There are not as many "I love every single note in this score and if you play something for me I can tell you exactly what it is" scores as I think there are. 

 

The highs of Jurassic Park are SO high. But I don't love the whole thing.

 

What if I just love everything that was originally on the album? (Definitely Last Crusade.)

 

But again, if I don't have to take all of The Force Awakens with it, it's Rey's Theme.

Posted
2 hours ago, Andy said:

Rey’s Theme.  It really was in my memory as the first time in some years up until then the score took over and drove the film, mixed so forward as we see the character sledding down that hill.  For a few moments, it was magical, and the “old” John Williams was back for what had felt like years.  

THAT.

 

And then the film and sequels truly were so much afar from the old EU that it all went downhill for me.

Posted
8 hours ago, Tallguy said:

 

I see what you mean. I would probably go with at least Last Crusade.


:lol: Freudian slip?

 

Least Crusade is a competitor.  It was good. It was very, very good. 
 

I ain’t sayin’ it got Forestalled in the spike chamber, but it doesn’t take the golden idol. 

Posted
15 minutes ago, Jurassic Shark said:

Helena's Theme.

 

Too close to Anakin's theme and I have no idea what it's supposed to be saying about a young woman in 1969. It sounds as grounded in the '30's at Marion's theme. I'm listening to DoD at the behest of several people here's recommendations. I'm not hating it but it's not really grabbing me. (Much like the film.)

 

30 minutes ago, Andy said:

:lol: Freudian slip?

 

No. I'm saying he made at least one more perfect Indy score.

Posted
3 hours ago, Mr. Hooper said:

The Adventures of Mutt.

 

John loves it, and you should too.

Irina's Theme (the concert version, not the "many cues stitched together" from the OST) > Adventures of Mutt.

 

9 hours ago, filmmusic said:

:o

Really?

That far behind?

He likes less than half of JW's career :(

Posted
4 minutes ago, Edmilson said:

Irina's Theme (the concert version, not the "many cues stitched together" from the OST) > Adventures of Mutt.


image.jpeg

Posted
3 hours ago, Jurassic Shark said:

 

I listen to it and judge it as pure music.

Very wise.  I would add Adventures of Mutt as another that is easier to appreciate along those lines.

Posted

If by "masterpiece" we mean something that stands above the average of his own works (while being way above the average of other film scores), I think I would go for Memoirs of a Geisha. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.