Jump to content

Joni Wiljami

Members
  • Posts

    6,459
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

Posts posted by Joni Wiljami

  1. Someone said in this thread that Sibelius is a mediocre figure

    among the great composers.I disagree.

    For me he is a great composer,especially great symphonist,best in the 20.century.

    ...and about Finlandia:it is a great piece but I can't enjoy listening it anymore,because

    played 300+ times(btw two times in Your beautiful Musikverein,Mr Schedenig).

    Playing it is always fun...

  2. Knowing my style?

    I'm not making a judgement about Murphy's personality.

    It's his work on certain scores that I put into question.

    TPM makes me think Murphy is the best in the bussiness.

    A.I. and Minority Report makes me think he's Williams worst enemy.

    I am sorry Stefancos. Totally misunderstanding.

    Limited skills in english language and too much red wine: Bad combination!

    ...and as Justin wrote in the other thread(too many people here who can't

    type or can't english) I'm out of here...back to the lurking business...

    Ps. about my Mr.Murphy comment:it wast ment to be more like joke.

    Sometimes I find him too "nice" praising his friends...

  3. Maybe you got the point. I might be "blinded" by the new sound quality

    and the great playing of LSO.

    well it has to be said that the soundquality on the TPM EU is nothing short of amazing.

    Is this the same Shawn Murphy who recorded A.I.?

    You have something against him.Nice guy according to the interwiews

    But knowing your style A.I. must badly recorded.Great music thou

  4. TPM is great. Possibly even better than RotJ IMO, and better than RotS too. We just haven't heard it in its full uncut glory yet.

    I don't understand what is wrong in TPM Ultimate Edition.(wrong order of the music,some cuts or

    does it miss something from the movie?)For me it is a great comeback to the glorious

    world of Star Wars music...

  5. The opening notes of the violin concerto briefly appear in ESB. ;) Also, Herrmann must have been a Sibelius fan... not only did he record some Sibelius works, the swamp music from Psycho is very reminiscent of a Sibelius work (I think it was Pelleas and Melisande?).

    Finlandia will always remain among my favourite pieces of music, but there's so much more (and let's not forget he stopped composing after about two thirds of his life). Scenes historiques No. 1 is wonderful (both this and Finlandia originate in something called Press Celebrations Music), also Karelia (both the suite and the full thing), the symphonies, King Christian II (one of my favourites), the stunning Kullervo  (based on the same Kalevala poem that inspired much of Tolkien's Turin story), Oceanides, Pohjola's Daughter,.. I'm also fond of Oma maa and Tulen synty.

    This is absolutely essential for everyone remotely interested in Sibelius (and should be available much cheaper... I think mine was about 25 or 30 euros, a few years ago)- unless perhaps if you already have everything on it.

    Any important works I left out? Anything I should discover? Any more choral stuff?

    Marian - Sibelius fan. :mrgreen:

    Yes, City in the Clouds from ESB reminds the beginning of the concerto.

    And 7 Years in Tibet,first track quite similar violin passage than in First symphony.

    What I didn't see in your list is: tonepoem Satu(in English maybe Saga?),Valse triste and

    Swan of Tuonela(this migth include in some serie,scenes historiques perhaps)

    Great english horn solo!

    How come you are Sibelius fan,while you come from Austria? It's not very strong

    area of Sibelius fans(thoug he studied in Wien...)? I mean the whole middle- Europe.

    Trough the history in England and in the Us (later also Japan) the reception of his music has been

    better...

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.