Which score do you prefer?
I prefer Star Trek V, First Contact has too much suspenseful (and most times forgettable) underscore for me.
The Mountain Vs. First Contact Main Title
https://www.youtube....h?v=DsRwg0Mul7A
vs.
https://www.youtube....h?v=mhoa7oWPPhk
Lets Get Out of Here vs. Resistance is Futile!
https://www.youtube....h?v=bd0S5cvZKAU
Vs.
https://www.youtube....h?v=-TMxCxPIyBA (at 11:15)
Raid on Paradise Vs. Fully Functional
https://www.youtube....h?v=7RdaWm-w_9U
vs.
https://www.youtube....el_video_titles
Open the Gates Vs. The Dish
https://www.youtube....h?v=LHBuE3QriZ0
Vs.
https://www.youtube....h?v=OWxOCuk6rMs
Not Alone Vs. Welcome Aboard
https://www.youtube....h?v=hpIvw6io3Yg
Vs.
https://www.youtube....h?v=TAX9M8vSqqQ
Star Trek V Vs. First Contact
Started by Faleel, Feb 06 2012 07:10 PM
19 replies to this topic
#1
Faleel
-
- Members
-
- 4522 posts
Frequent Poster
- Gender:Not Telling
Posted 06 February 2012 - 07:10 PM
Among all the things I have done in my short and pitiful life, becoming an inside joke on JWFAN is the one I'm the least proud of.
#2
Stefancos
-
- Members
-
- 53778 posts
The Road Goes Ever On And On
- Gender:Male
- Location:Hoorn, The Netherlands, Europe, Planet Earth
Posted 06 February 2012 - 07:18 PM
I like FC but Trek V is better. Its a real classic.
It's true. You're my role model, Stefan Cosman.
#3
Trent Bennett
-
- Members
-
- 12163 posts
Trekkie For Life
- Gender:Male
- Location:Utah
Posted 06 February 2012 - 07:24 PM
I like FC but Trek V is better. Its a real classic.
Agreed.
First Contact is a bit better listening experience for the album compared to Star Trek V. However, in complete form Star Trek V gets my vote.
"Let's make sure history never forgets the name......Enterprise." - Captain Picard
#4
tharpdevenport
-
- Members
-
- 1685 posts
Frequent Poster
- Gender:Male
- Location:The Village...
Posted 06 February 2012 - 07:26 PM
I could not vote.
I could only do the first question, since with the second, I consider both scores to be on equal playing fields (though different efforts).
The poll would not let me cast a vote unless I did both questions.
For the OST one, I was going to go with First Contact, simply because The Final Frontier has that aweful Moon song and reminds me of that terrible, terrible, horrible, unforgivable scene in the film. While "Magic Carpet Ride" is an excellent song, and the other okay.
I could only do the first question, since with the second, I consider both scores to be on equal playing fields (though different efforts).
The poll would not let me cast a vote unless I did both questions.
For the OST one, I was going to go with First Contact, simply because The Final Frontier has that aweful Moon song and reminds me of that terrible, terrible, horrible, unforgivable scene in the film. While "Magic Carpet Ride" is an excellent song, and the other okay.
REJECTED FILM SCORES SITE
Number 2: "Are you going to run?"
Number 6: "Like blazes! First chance i get."
-The Prisoner-
PLEASE NOTE: I don't sell CD-Rs, or trade MP3s -- do NOT contact me asking for those; I also don't do downloading/uploading. Just trade, CD-Rs.
Number 2: "Are you going to run?"
Number 6: "Like blazes! First chance i get."
-The Prisoner-
PLEASE NOTE: I don't sell CD-Rs, or trade MP3s -- do NOT contact me asking for those; I also don't do downloading/uploading. Just trade, CD-Rs.
#5
Faleel
-
- Members
-
- 4522 posts
Frequent Poster
- Gender:Not Telling
Posted 06 February 2012 - 07:30 PM
I could not vote.
The poll would not let me cast a vote unless I did both questions.
I added an option for you.
Among all the things I have done in my short and pitiful life, becoming an inside joke on JWFAN is the one I'm the least proud of.
#6
OneBuckFilms
-
- Members
-
- 1002 posts
Frequent Poster
- Gender:Male
Posted 06 February 2012 - 07:36 PM
I enjoy Star Trek V slightly better. But this is very close for me.
Of all the things I've lost, I miss my mind the most.
#7
Miles Prower
-
- Members
-
- 1222 posts
Deserved the Best Picture win
- Gender:Male
- Location:The Genesis Planet
Posted 06 February 2012 - 07:40 PM
Yeah, First Contact's OST is a better listen than the complete score (with a few exceptions, Joel Goldsmith's climax cue primarily).
Final Frontier is the better score though, and the LLL expansion makes it shine.
Final Frontier is the better score though, and the LLL expansion makes it shine.
#8
tharpdevenport
-
- Members
-
- 1685 posts
Frequent Poster
- Gender:Male
- Location:The Village...
Posted 06 February 2012 - 07:46 PM
Thank you, voted!
The most perfect Trek OST would probably have to be (minus the special editions, I'm talking the originals) TWoK (even though it sounds like a tin can at times).
The most perfect Trek OST would probably have to be (minus the special editions, I'm talking the originals) TWoK (even though it sounds like a tin can at times).
REJECTED FILM SCORES SITE
Number 2: "Are you going to run?"
Number 6: "Like blazes! First chance i get."
-The Prisoner-
PLEASE NOTE: I don't sell CD-Rs, or trade MP3s -- do NOT contact me asking for those; I also don't do downloading/uploading. Just trade, CD-Rs.
Number 2: "Are you going to run?"
Number 6: "Like blazes! First chance i get."
-The Prisoner-
PLEASE NOTE: I don't sell CD-Rs, or trade MP3s -- do NOT contact me asking for those; I also don't do downloading/uploading. Just trade, CD-Rs.
#9
John Crichton
-
- Members
-
- 16472 posts
The Doctor in America
- Gender:Male
- Location:West Texas
Posted 06 February 2012 - 08:15 PM
I go back and forth between these two all the time on which I like better. They're so close, it's totally mood dependent. No vote from me.
The First Question. The Oldest Question in the Universe, hidden in plain sight...
#10
Wojo
-
- Members
-
- 17845 posts
Let's eat
- Gender:Male
Posted 06 February 2012 - 08:18 PM
For the OST one, I was going to go with First Contact, simply because The Final Frontier has that aweful Moon song and reminds me of that terrible, terrible, horrible, unforgivable scene in the film. While "Magic Carpet Ride" is an excellent song, and the other okay.
The Hiroshima song is far more tolerable on album than in the film because it's at least a real song by a real band that I've seen in the discount bin. Nichelle Nichols' singing.....not so much. As far as 80s pop songs go, I've heard far, far worse than TMAWTH.
I love the action-mode Enterprise theme in the FC complete score when the Phoenix flies past the Enterprise. That and The Dish make the album for me.
I go back and forth between these two all the time on which I like better. They're so close, it's totally mood dependent. No vote from me.
They really are great companion scores to each other. Adapting the four-note friendship theme to be Picard's theme helped, I guess.
I suggest a full frontal assault with automated laser monkeys, scalpel mines, and acid.
#11
Charlie Brigden
-
- Members
-
- 7322 posts
Huge Member
- Gender:Male
- Location:Wales
Posted 06 February 2012 - 09:11 PM
Not to mention making the Klingon theme heroic for Worf.
I prefer V. FC needs a happy medium between OST and complete. 'A Quest For Vengeance' is amazing though.
I prefer V. FC needs a happy medium between OST and complete. 'A Quest For Vengeance' is amazing though.
Repeat the JWFan pledge after me: 'I hereby recognise John Towner Williams' place in the world as the great composer there has ever been, and I therefore renounce the works of Rozsa, Korngold, Herrmann, Horner, Kamen, Giacchino (unless the prophecy is fulfilled and he becomes the heir to JTW) and Goldsmith, especially Goldsmith. I understand that if I ever refer to Jurassic Park as anything less than "a masterpiece sixty-five million years in the making" I will be resigned to living out my days at the Zimmershrine.'
#12
Stefancos
-
- Members
-
- 53778 posts
The Road Goes Ever On And On
- Gender:Male
- Location:Hoorn, The Netherlands, Europe, Planet Earth
Posted 06 February 2012 - 09:13 PM
They really are great companion scores to each other. Adapting the four-note friendship theme to be Picard's theme helped, I guess.
It's the Quest theme Wojo, not a friendship theme.
It's true. You're my role model, Stefan Cosman.
#13
Faleel
-
- Members
-
- 4522 posts
Frequent Poster
- Gender:Not Telling
Posted 06 February 2012 - 09:15 PM
They really are great companion scores to each other. Adapting the four-note friendship theme to be Picard's theme helped, I guess.
It's the Quest theme Wojo, not a friendship theme.
It is in nemesis pretty much.
Among all the things I have done in my short and pitiful life, becoming an inside joke on JWFAN is the one I'm the least proud of.
#14
Stefancos
-
- Members
-
- 53778 posts
The Road Goes Ever On And On
- Gender:Male
- Location:Hoorn, The Netherlands, Europe, Planet Earth
Posted 06 February 2012 - 09:18 PM
In First Contact it has no specific character or situation associated with it. Since Goldsmith was under time pressure I assume he just lifted this fairly non specific theme from trek 5 as a time saver.
Officially it's not in Insurrection, though one might argue that the action motif of that film (the US Marshalls theme) is an adaptation of it.
Officially it's not in Insurrection, though one might argue that the action motif of that film (the US Marshalls theme) is an adaptation of it.
It's true. You're my role model, Stefan Cosman.
#15
KK.
-
- Members
-
- 4599 posts
Rich in Fish!
- Gender:Male
- Location:Canada
Posted 06 February 2012 - 09:31 PM
I really like First Contact, but Star Trek V really wins this one for me, on both regards.
Music Muse Reviews: "Escape From Tomorrow by Abel Korzeniowski
#16
John Crichton
-
- Members
-
- 16472 posts
The Doctor in America
- Gender:Male
- Location:West Texas
Posted 06 February 2012 - 10:00 PM
The liners on V did wonders for helping me sort those themes out.
They really are great companion scores to each other. Adapting the four-note friendship theme to be Picard's theme helped, I guess.
It's the Quest theme Wojo, not a friendship theme.
The First Question. The Oldest Question in the Universe, hidden in plain sight...
#17
Wojo
-
- Members
-
- 17845 posts
Let's eat
- Gender:Male
Posted 06 February 2012 - 11:28 PM
I have yet to read those liners. I couldn't even tell you where the jewel case and discs are more specifically than "my bedroom back home."
I suggest a full frontal assault with automated laser monkeys, scalpel mines, and acid.
#18
Kendal_Ozzel
-
- Members
-
- 2474 posts
Admiral
- Gender:Male
- Location:Otisburg
Posted 07 February 2012 - 01:30 AM
It's been too long since listened to First Contact in OST form. But I'd probably have to say The Final Frontier on both counts.
And those liner notes are great. I hadn't previously realized how much the quest theme and Sybok's theme were woven into the score (even on just the OST selections).
And those liner notes are great. I hadn't previously realized how much the quest theme and Sybok's theme were woven into the score (even on just the OST selections).
#19
Richard
-
- Members
-
- 3892 posts
Frequent Poster
Posted 08 February 2012 - 05:04 PM
"Star TreK: V", versus "Star Trek"???!!!
Are you lot having a giraffe???!!!
Are you lot having a giraffe???!!!
#20
Stefancos
-
- Members
-
- 53778 posts
The Road Goes Ever On And On
- Gender:Male
- Location:Hoorn, The Netherlands, Europe, Planet Earth
Posted 08 February 2012 - 05:34 PM
And those liner notes are great. I hadn't previously realized how much the quest theme and Sybok's theme were woven into the score (even on just the OST selections).
The OST heavily favours music from the latter half of the film, meaning the Quest theme is featured a lot. i think I'm right in saying that Sybok's theme can only be heard in Open The Gates and a small cameo in An Angry God.
I love the way that in the complete score The Quest Theme takes over from Sybok's theme.
It's true. You're my role model, Stefan Cosman.
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users
