Jump to content

Should the "Temporary Tintin and War Horse subforum" be merged back into General Discussion?  

37 members have voted

  1. 1. When should the "Temporary Tintin and War Horse subforum" be merged back into General Discussion?

    • Merge it now, the film has opened in most countries
    • Merge on March 1st, after it has opened in every country
    • I don't care either way, but wanted to vote in a poll anyway


Recommended Posts

Posted

What do you guys think?

DISCUSS!

  • Replies 39
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Yes, merge please. And while you're at it: is it too early to create a Lincoln subforum...? ;)

Posted

I don't know if we'll even need a Lincoln subforum. We'll see.

Posted

I voted for merge. Going back and forth between the main and subforum has been a bit arduous (one extra click on the mouse). ;)

Posted

I don't know if we'll even need a Lincoln subforum. We'll see.

I guess a thread will do. ;)

Posted

I want it merged to. And that's because I tend to forget there is a sub-forum.

Karol

Posted

Don't merge. I don't give a fuck about Tintin or War Horse. Having a subforum helps keeping that crap away from the General Discussion board.

Merge them, and it will be chaos. The plague will spread. Rivers of blood will flood the lands. Women will give birth to demons with wings and tentacles. And Cosman will become a Moderator.

Don't merge.

To think I was beggining to like you.....

Posted

The sad truth is that Tintin and War Horse didn't generate NEARLY the amount of posts and threads that Indy IV did. This place was a MAD HOUSE then!

I don't know what the difference is - both were the first Williams score in 3 years, both were action/adventure scores. I guess one was the 4th entry in a beloved franchise and a huge summer blockbuster, the other was 2 winter films that were first entries, even though one was an adaptation of a beloved franchise. I dunno.

Maybe it's that some of the big posters from back then don't post as much any more? I dunno.

Posted
Maybe it's that some of the big posters from back then don't post as much any more? I dunno.

The movie releases were all over the place this time. I know I'm still avoiding War Horse film, as well as most score, threads because the film isn't out yet here.

Posted

The sad truth is that Tintin and War Horse didn't generate NEARLY the amount of posts and threads that Indy IV did.

That is quite funny when thinking how much better films both Tintin and War Horse are. Also music wise.

Answer to the topic: merge.

Even I have seen War Horse, here in the far side of the world.

Posted

The sad truth is that Tintin and War Horse didn't generate NEARLY the amount of posts and threads that Indy IV did. This place was a MAD HOUSE then!

I don't know what the difference is - both were the first Williams score in 3 years, both were action/adventure scores. I guess one was the 4th entry in a beloved franchise and a huge summer blockbuster, the other was 2 winter films that were first entries, even though one was an adaptation of a beloved franchise. I dunno.

Maybe it's that some of the big posters from back then don't post as much any more? I dunno.

I think it's also because WH and Tintin were both released at separate times in the US and Europe, the source of most of our posters. With KotCS I believe it all hit at once, and one person's enthusiasm nourished another's. It's less fun to discuss a movie/score when half the people are avoiding spoiler-filled threads like the plague, and by the time the other half sees the movie the first half isn't as excited to discuss it.

Posted

Yup, well said!

Posted

And it's generally more fun to discuss bad movies than good ones.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

The masses have spoken. It is done.

Posted

ah ok that is why it just dissapeared

but i don't see any Tintin and War Horse threads here.Did they get sucked into a black hole?

Posted

They are all here

Posted

I only see 1 tintin thread in the first forum page

. i guess it's because nobody posted in most of them in a while

Posted

I only see 1 tintin thread in the first forum page

. i guess it's because nobody posted in most of them in a while

I dunno what to tell you man. Every single thread that was in that forum is now in this one.

Posted

no spoilers for war horse yet, MIND YOU!

it opens this friday here.

The horse dies from rabies given in the trences because its bitten by an anatomically incorrect dog.

I knew it! Snowy looked sick.

Posted

Palpatine.jpg

"DO IT!"

Even though it's, y'know, been done already.

John- pleasantly surprised that his Photobucket account was still there after a year of neglect

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.