Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About thestat

  • Rank
    Occasional Poster

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. So sad to see Balfe get another job, the Ang Lee Gemini Man project - I thought most sensible folk understood that he is only a Zimmer copycat with no original sensibility. I mean, Fallout had some good moments, but that whole 200-piece orchestra stuff is like Monty Python sketches on film composition.... The man is a simplistic tunesmith, though not very good at that either, to be entirely honest, ready to score the next McD commercial, he is not ready to take on anything requiring a real attention span. Beltrami, the original composer, is not exactly man of the compositional moment either.....but at least he is not Barfe. This was obviously the moment where Ang Lee lost control of the project and Der Bruckheimer took over, so nothing interesting. Everything has to sound like a reality TV show competition.....
  2. Yeah, Zimmer might do it, but he's going to get hammered with Dune. I mean, he has to do actual work for a production of that size. So, not expecting anything great. Just as long as it's not Balfe, the most banal, ad-man, jingle-happy nobody from HZ's works.
  3. I can guarantee you with 99% certainty it will be Holkenborg and Pope. And I will be immensely pleased. Yes, if JNH took it, totally awesome, Powell is too dynamic (ie. bitty, mickeymousey) for Cameron and Zimmer is too up his own arse too see the light nowadays. His scores sound like an absolute gas explosion from a Dunkirk vessel - and FINALLY, he's had a bomb that will destroy his superhero career! Goransson is too cool, happy to incorporate styles and not/or too strong enough for a steely Jim, yet he is a pop superstar so will this be enough to be flexible enough to bend the knee to Cameron? Tom, with massive help from Pope will natch it. Unless, my best man David Stone Hamilton gets it.....as if......
  4. Even though I agree with the previous poster - would love to hear what Hans came up originally - but sadly a lot of this sounds like copying Interstellar (when it's good) and Dunkirk (when it's totally useless). Hans is not a man to innovate from score to score, so if all sounds like previous work? But hey don't discount Lockington, he's not bad.
  5. I mean, yeah, okay, er.... this is bad. I would like to support Hans when he apparently goes solo and does a score.....but yeah. this is a flunkie junkie score that probably netted Zimmer millions. Wow. Anyone, and I do mean ANYONE, in the scoring business could have done this.
  6. What is going on in this score? Yes, HZ had to recalibrate as Kinberg tried to piece up the madness of the production. But this sounds either like one of those early Media Ventures trailer CDs from the late 1990s or a total mess of Dunkirk and other nonsense that he has been fumbling about with. This is so bad. Is this the worst score of Hans' career - it sounds like cheap trailer music done in every film industry in the world. I think the world finally caught up with Zimmer. He cheapened the standards and now the poor standard sound better than him! Ironic and he better get back on his game. A Widows score consisting of nonsensical rythmic stuff is not going to make him relevant. Time to harvest the good times. Hans - your time is up. Innovation is over. Stopped with Interstellar.
  7. Yeah.....this actually really makes sense. Desplat was composing for future audiences.....his score still stands as intellectual but also totally genre........ But at the end of the day, Desplat would not have been able to compose a love-fest like Rodan, a massive 5 minute piece premised on Alien3's Ignition scene, combined with Horner's marine martiality. Yes, it's fan service, but you guys are the fans. Why the fuck are you not happy! What do the fans want then? Something different (you didn't like Desplat), or something similar (you don't like McCreary), wow.......... Something exactly like your silly little self, whoever you are.
  8. Yavar, yes, used to love that theme. It's sad that FreeClyde seems to have disappeared. But I think Thaxton, a nemesis to many, now a friend after years, is working hard on Joel's stuff. The episodic stuff on Stargate need to be released.
  9. Man, isn't it clear that the mandate from both McCreary and studio was - Elliot Goldenthal. The orchestrations, melodies, weirdness, and crazy choral stuff is totally exhibing Goldenthal strains. Rodan - the best track - is such an awesome homage to the Alien franchise - the theme is from Alien 3, the military percussion is total Aliens. Amazing score but with all those all important Bear inflections.
  10. I was mystified by the presence of a Graeme Revell 'Duty' score I heard back in the early 2000s that was fantastic and massively orchestral (hence done by Tim Simonec). Then I got his Big Red One (the score, not anything else you might think of). Call of Duty 2 (don't play videogames) is out on youtube!. I mean, if you like Giacchino's work in the series, this is quite close to that awesomeness, probably not as dynamic as Giacchino, but close and so similar in orchestration.....wtf. Is there for any of you can identify a version of Revell's scores that uses massive chorus and Goldsmithian orchestrations or was i too stoned in the early 2000s? No, it wasn't Joel's piece or 13th Warrior. Sorry guys; it was probably this. Back in the early 2000s, ostinatos were creative. No chorus, I'm afraid: Sorry guys, it was probably this: Back then ostinatos were creative orchestral devices and I simply remembered wrong as now they are the A to B of anything. Still a solid piece of music, some solid orchesration and JNH style action. The horn and flute action in all these pieces is fantastic. Have a gander at all of the tracks, seriously. You won't regret it.
  11. It's a shame that Joel never truly broke out from his esteemed father's shadow (but who on earth could have!). But he's been such an astonishing composer over the years. I especially like Moon 44 (I do love Arnold but if Emmerich had stuck with Joel, who knows): Yes, the off meter rhythms are very Goldsmith Sr. but there's so much here that one hears in later Joel scores that is idiosyncratically him. But another son to father homage first:
  12. The key thing with anything Holkenborg or Junk/o is that Conrad Pope is now his go-to guy for conducting orchestras. This must have been a development from that Boss Baby cue that Hans asked Pope to do. Anyways, Pope, the man that does shit for JW is doing Junkie stuff can tell you about the change in quality from a Deadpool to Mortal Engines. Different worlds and massively awesome scores. Battle Angel is fantastic in some of its weird allusions to, of all frigging things, Trevor Jones' seminal Dark City, and I argue to even Huppertz's score for Metropolis (Junk boy is an avid fan of film music). There's a moment in Battle Angel track 5, at 0:59 t0 1:15 that is either a Huppertz reference, or even geekier for you guys, a Harry Sukman, Salem's Lot, ding don. To my mind, the 10 or so seconds in this Junkie score rival a Jones on fire:, 1:55 - 2:30. And even a Williams......If you like your Dark City.....
  13. Balfe has never composed a single piece of music that identifies him as the composer. Junk+boyo is very easy to distinguish as his style is so obvious.
  14. Balfe is a copycat, Junk XL has his own style.
  • Create New...