My Complete Episode II and III Edits

[GoodMusician 56]

I'm running everything through a 5.1 mixer. It widens the sound, makes it much more crisp, but can add some hiss becuase it's duplicating sound to an extent. Not really reverb though.

The problem with the ATOC album is there is SOOO much hiss! I can't believe it...

If you'd like a comparison file, let me know.

----------------

LET IT ALSO BE KNOWN!!!::

If anyone messages me for the link to this set before I announce it's done, I'm just gonna stop updating on this site.

I am sooooo tired of the people who DO NOT READ THE THREAD...

They simply see "Edit? PM HIM!"

I've started simply answering messages with

"No." or "Read the thread. No."

So yea... not that the people who message me would SEE this... but I do ask that people stop asking me for the edit... there is no link.

When I announce its done, THEN you can.

---

As for the comparison files, if you'd like to hear one, message me saying "comparison file" otherwise you'll get a "No" reply

[Giftheck 916]

Having heard both your previous prequel edits, I think this will be quite good.

Would you be doing the tracked TPM stuff in there (Jedi vs Droid/The Battle of Geonosis)

[GoodMusician 56]

I have yet to fully decide on that.

I think I may try my hand at it but I'm not sure. I'm mostly focusing on what's important which is the real music.. if I do that stuff, it will probably be last...

[aj_vader 534]

I'm running everything through a 5.1 mixer. It widens the sound, makes it much more crisp, but can add some hiss becuase it's duplicating sound to an extent. Not really reverb though.

The problem with the ATOC album is there is SOOO much hiss! I can't believe it...

If you'd like a comparison file, let me know.

----------------

LET IT ALSO BE KNOWN!!!::

If anyone messages me for the link to this set before I announce it's done, I'm just gonna stop updating on this site.

I am sooooo tired of the people who DO NOT READ THE THREAD...

They simply see "Edit? PM HIM!"

I've started simply answering messages with

"No." or "Read the thread. No."

So yea... not that the people who message me would SEE this... but I do ask that people stop asking me for the edit... there is no link.

When I announce its done, THEN you can.

---

As for the comparison files, if you'd like to hear one, message me saying "comparison file" otherwise you'll get a "No" reply

cool thanks... what peice of software is that then? (5.1 Mixer?)

[Giftheck 916]

I made the tracked music for my AotC Edit. The edits are very jarring, and it was a difficult task to find the percussion for the track transitions.

[GoodMusician 56]

I may just steal someone elses edit for those... spruce them up abit here and there... but I don't see any point in truly taking my time to make them just right...

I'm gonna focus on the important parts which I am right now.

I've taken the day off because it was a taxing day and I'm still trying not to get sick here... have a surgery coming up and they wont' do it if I'm sick hehe...

Will keep you all updated

[Giftheck 916]

You can happily steal my edit It took no more that 20 minutes after finding the right percussion (Some I substituted - like timpani hits were subsituted sometimes by material from TPM Bubble World)

[GoodMusician 56]

as far as the 5.1 mixer question went, I didn't see it ...sorry heh

I used Vegas movie studio platinum.

It works out really nicely.

I've taken a few days off as well becuase I'm trying to keep from getting sick. I have a surgery coming up and if I'm sick they won't take out my tonsils. But if I dont' get them out, I'll keep getting sick lol...so I'm trying my damndest to sleep and such...

[Trent Hoyt 13]

I'm looking forward to the finished product.

[GoodMusician 56]

Hey all, just wanted to give an update.

I'm working on the finishing touches right now.

But I've decided to move all talk about this to here:

OT.com Complete Scores

[Pieter Boelen 740]

Hmm; I don't really want to register on yet another forum. I take it you WILL post all main news here anyway, right? Like when it's done.

[GoodMusician 56]

yea... It just is easier for me to post updated at one forum. I will post when its done (which it nearly is)

And here's the moment you've all been waiting for.

I'm Finished with the score edit. Now I'm working on all the goodies. Disc 3 will be finished by tonight, and the sets will be packed and ready to be uploaded... here's a look at the new set

STAR WARS: Episode II (Complete Edit) [2:34:07 +]

Disc 1 - (1:05:55)

01) Fox Fanfare (ESB Recording) - [0:22]

02) Main Title (TPM Recording) - [1:32]

03) Arrival at Coruscant - [0:19]

04) Ambush on the Landing Platform - [2:16]

05) The Security Council - [2:41]

06) Old Friends - Annie- [1:37]

07) The Nightshift Begins - [0:54]

08) Setting the Trap - [2:51]

09) Chase Through Coruscant - [11:49]

10) Executive Orders and Obi Wans Concern - [1:38]

11) Going into Hiding - [2:46]

12) Departing Coruscant - [1:42]

13) Jedi Archives - [1:21]

14) Yoda and the Younglings - [4:00]

15) Audience on Naboo - [2:26]

16) Arrival at Kamino (Film Alternate) - [1:44]

17) The Army of the Republic (Film Ending) - [0:51]

18) Glass Sculptures - Forbidden Kiss - [2:18]

19) Inspecting the Army - [1:52]

20) The Meadow Picnic - [2:32]

21) Interview with Jango - [2:50]

22) Anakin and Padme - [3:59]

23) Making Contact - Dreams (Film)- [2:45]

24) Tatooine Resolution (Tracked) - [1:36]

25) Jango's Escape - Arrival at Tatooine - [3:46]

26) Meeting Watto - [0:54]

27) Bounty Hunter Pursuit - Arrival at Geonosis - [2:21]

Disc 2 - (1:08:38)

01) The Lars Homestead - Searching for Shmi - Spying on the Separatists - [6:54]

02) Tuskan Camp - Return to the Homestead (Film)- [5:52]

03) Anakin's Confession - [2:38]

04) Shmi's Funeral - To Geonosis - [3:46]

05) A Crisis - [0:58]

06) Dooku's Offer (Tracked) - [1:24]

07) Emergency Powers - [1:52]

08) Arrival at Geonosis (Tracked) - [1:38]

09) The Droids Confer - [0:36]

10) On the Conveyor Belt - [3:05]

11) Captured - [0:39]

12) Love Pledge - [2:39]

13) The Arena - [4:28]

14) Battle for Geonosis I (Tracked) - [2:17]

15) Battle for Geonosis II (Tracked) - [3:32]

16) Battle for Geonosis III (Tracked) - [1:38]

17) Battle for Geonosis IV (Tracked) - [1:55]

18) The Ultimate Weapon (Tracked) - [0:51]

19) Dooku's Escape (Tracked) - [1:28]

20) Going After Dooku (Film Alternate) - [2:20]

21) Confronting Dooku (Original) - [2:14]

22) Yoda Vs Dooku (Original) - [2:28]

23) The Clone Wars - Finale - [5:16]

24) End Credits (Album Intro) - [0:53]

25) Across the Stars (Album) - [5:32]

26) End Credits (Extended Album Alternate) - [1:34

Disc 3 - ~ (+30:00)

# Across the Stars (Music Video)

# Dex's Diner (Source)

# Arrival at Kamino (Album Alternate)

# Tusken Camp - Return to the Homestead (Alternate Orchestrations)

# Making Contact (Alternate Orchestrations)

# Arena Source

# Going After Dooku (Album Alternate)

# Confronting Dooku (Film Edit)

# The Jedi Fall (Film Edit)

# Yoda Vs Dooku - Finale (Film Edit)

# Film End Credits Suite

If anyone has any suggestions of additions, let me know.

[Henry B 50]

What's the deal with the end credits? The film version is a tracking job; just use the album version for the whole thing.

[GoodMusician 56]

Well, you have the end credits INtro, then you have the Across the Stars, then you have the End Credits ending which is different.

Then you have the film version which has a slightly different intro and I usually like to end the set with an end credits suite... so I thought I'd put the film end credits there...

If you don't like it, it's not that hard to delete it

[GoodMusician 56]

STAR WARS: Episode II (Complete Edit) [3:11:34]

Disc 1 - (1:05:55)

01) Fox Fanfare (ESB Recording) - [0:22]

02) Main Title (TPM Recording) - [1:32]

03) Arrival at Coruscant - [0:19]

04) Ambush on the Landing Platform - [2:16]

05) The Security Council - [2:41]

06) Old Friends - Annie- [1:37]

07) The Nightshift Begins - [0:54]

08) Setting the Trap - [2:51]

09) Chase Through Coruscant - [11:49]

10) Executive Orders and Obi Wans Concern - [1:38]

11) Going into Hiding - [2:46]

12) Departing Coruscant - [1:42]

13) Jedi Archives - [1:21]

14) Yoda and the Younglings - [4:00]

15) Audience on Naboo - [2:26]

16) Arrival at Kamino (Film Alternate) - [1:44]

17) The Army of the Republic (Film Ending) - [0:51]

18) Glass Sculptures - Forbidden Kiss - [2:18]

19) Inspecting the Army - [1:52]

20) The Meadow Picnic - [2:32]

21) Interview with Jango - [2:50]

22) Anakin and Padme - [3:59]

23) Making Contact - Dreams (Film)- [2:45]

24) Tatooine Resolution (Tracked) - [1:36]

25) Jango's Escape - Arrival at Tatooine - [3:46]

26) Meeting Watto - [0:54]

27) Bounty Hunter Pursuit - Arrival at Geonosis - [2:21]

Disc 2

(1:08:38)

01) The Lars Homestead - Searching for Shmi - Spying on the Separatists - [6:54]

02) Tuskan Camp - Return to the Homestead (Film)- [5:52]

03) Anakin's Confession - [2:38]

04) Shmi's Funeral - To Geonosis - [3:46]

05) A Crisis - [0:58]

06) Dooku's Offer (Tracked) - [1:24]

07) Emergency Powers - [1:52]

08) Arrival at Geonosis (Tracked) - [1:38]

09) The Droids Confer - [0:36]

10) On the Conveyor Belt - [3:05]

11) Captured - [0:39]

12) Love Pledge - [2:39]

13) The Arena - [4:28]

14) Battle for Geonosis I (Tracked) - [2:17]

15) Battle for Geonosis II (Tracked) - [3:32]

16) Battle for Geonosis III (Tracked) - [1:38]

17) Battle for Geonosis IV (Tracked) - [1:55]

18) The Ultimate Weapon (Tracked) - [0:51]

19) Dooku's Escape (Tracked) - [1:28]

20) Going After Dooku (Film Alternate) - [2:20]

21) Confronting Dooku (Original) - [2:14]

22) Yoda Vs Dooku (Original) - [2:28]

23) The Clone Wars - Finale - [5:16]

24) End Credits (Album Intro) - [0:53]

25) Across the Stars (Album) - [5:32]

26) End Credits (Extended Album Alternate) - [1:34

Disc 3 - (57:00)

01) Fox Fanfare (1999 Recording) - [0:21]

02) Attack of the Clones- Music Video - [4:34]

03) Across the Stars (Intro) - [0:38]

04) Across the Stars (Musical Journey) - [5:27]

05) Dex's Diner (Available Source) - [1:50]

06) Dex's Diner (Film Version Source) - [1:16]

07) Arrival at Kamino (Album Alternate) - [1:33]

08) Making Contact - Dreams (Album Orchestration) - [2:45]

09) Tusken Camp - Return to the Homestead (Album Orchestration) - [5:52]

10) Arena Source (Ben Burtt) - [2:39]

11) Going After Dooku (Album Alternate) - [2:16]

12) Confronting Dooku (Film Edit) - [1:17]

13) The Jedi Fall (Film Edit) - [1:10]

14) Yoda Vs. Dooku - Finale (Film Edit) - [3:42]

15) The Story of Attack of the Clones - [15:13]

16) Film End Credits Suite - [6:20]

Last call on suggestions...

Anyone Anyone?

I kinda want to put a complete suite of the End Credits as heard on the album but I didn't want to have two end credits... and I do kinda want to show the film version as mentioned above...

I suppose I could move the film up to be track 15, move The Story of Attack of the Clones down... and then add it on as last...

Maybe?

[Admiral Holdo 16]

I have to say, this looks pretty amazing - it's expansive, yet not a mess of 8000 20-second cues, even keeping in the tracked music - I look forward to this.

[Giftheck 916]

This is... wow. I think nobody can top this at all. This looks really good.

[GoodMusician 56]

I have to say, this looks pretty amazing - it's expansive, yet not a mess of 8000 20-second cues, even keeping in the tracked music - I look forward to this.

::grumble grumble:: between this and your pm ...

::grumble grumble:: lol

I'm actually waiting right now to upload it.

I just listened to ALL of the set... found that for some odd reason I'd left off the first few seconds of "Across the Stars" ::shrugs::

lol...

Past that I think the set is very listenable.

Once you get over the idea that some of the tracks have sfx, or vocal echo, and really focus on the music... it's fine...

I also managed to make the music much more present... so that the vocal echo and the sfx are more the oddman out... than the norm. THe music becomes the norm, it just happends to have some sfx and vocal echo in it at times.

But as I said, I'm waiting to upload it (can you believe I deleted the email with the new password to the FTP! lol)

So the next post by me should be announcing it's up and you can begin pming me for the link.

[DarkRuss3ll 0]

Hey, GoodMusician,

Just want to say, that I appreciate all the hard work that you are putting into this, and keep it up! I really enjoyed the Episode III edit, so I'm pretty optimistic and excited about this one. Keep up the good work.

[GoodMusician 56]

Thank you, I couldn't help but read that like:

"I just wanted to wish you good luck: We're all counting on you." lol

Anyways!!!

___________________________________________________________________

STAR WARS EPISODE II: The Complete Score Edit

[3:22:22]

Disc 1 - (1:05:55)

01) Fox Fanfare (ESB Recording) - [0:22]

02) Main Title (TPM Recording) - [1:32]

03) Arrival at Coruscant - [0:19]

04) Ambush on the Landing Platform - [2:16]

05) The Security Council - [2:41]

06) Old Friends - Annie- [1:37]

07) The Nightshift Begins - [0:54]

08) Setting the Trap - [2:51]

09) Chase Through Coruscant - [11:49]

10) Executive Orders and Obi Wans Concern - [1:38]

11) Going into Hiding - [2:46]

12) Departing Coruscant - [1:42]

13) Jedi Archives - [1:21]

14) Yoda and the Younglings - [4:00]

15) Audience on Naboo - [2:26]

16) Arrival at Kamino (Film Alternate) - [1:44]

17) The Army of the Republic (Film Ending) - [0:51]

18) Glass Sculptures - Forbidden Kiss - [2:18]

19) Inspecting the Army - [1:52]

20) The Meadow Picnic - [2:32]

21) Interview with Jango - [2:50]

22) Anakin and Padme - [3:59]

23) Making Contact - Dreams (Film)- [2:45]

24) Tatooine Resolution (Tracked) - [1:36]

25) Jango's Escape - Arrival at Tatooine - [3:46]

26) Meeting Watto - [0:54]

27) Bounty Hunter Pursuit - Arrival at Geonosis - [2:21]

Disc 2 - (1:08:38)

01) The Lars Homestead - Searching for Shmi - Spying on the Separatists - [6:54]

02) Tuskan Camp - Return to the Homestead (Film)- [5:52]

03) Anakin's Confession - [2:38]

04) Shmi's Funeral - To Geonosis - [3:46]

05) A Crisis - [0:58]

06) Dooku's Offer (Tracked) - [1:24]

07) Emergency Powers - [1:52]

08) Arrival at Geonosis (Tracked) - [1:38]

09) The Droids Confer - [0:36]

10) On the Conveyor Belt - [3:05]

11) Captured - [0:39]

12) Love Pledge - [2:39]

13) The Arena - [4:28]

14) Battle for Geonosis I (Tracked) - [2:17]

15) Battle for Geonosis II (Tracked) - [3:32]

16) Battle for Geonosis III (Tracked) - [1:38]

17) Battle for Geonosis IV (Tracked) - [1:55]

18) The Ultimate Weapon (Tracked) - [0:51]

19) Dooku's Escape (Tracked) - [1:28]

20) Going After Dooku (Film Alternate) - [2:20]

21) Confronting Dooku (Original) - [2:14]

22) Yoda Vs Dooku (Original) - [2:28]

23) The Clone Wars - Finale - [5:16]

24) End Credits (Album Intro) - [0:53]

25) Across the Stars (Album) - [5:32]

26) End Credits (Extended Album Alternate) - [1:34

Disc 3 - (1:08:13)

01) Fox Fanfare (1999 Recording) - [0:21]

02) Attack of the Clones- Music Video - [4:34]

03) Across the Stars (Intro) - [0:38]

04) Across the Stars (Musical Journey) - [5:27]

05) Dex's Diner (Available Source) - [1:50]

06) Dex's Diner (Film Version Source) - [1:16]

07) Arrival at Kamino (Album Alternate) - [1:33]

08) Making Contact - Dreams (Album Orchestration) - [2:45]

09) Tusken Camp - Return to the Homestead (Album Orchestration) - [5:52]

10) Arena Source (Ben Burtt) - [2:39]

11) Going After Dooku (Album Alternate) - [2:16]

12) Confronting Dooku (Film Edit) - [1:17]

13) The Jedi Fall (Film Edit) - [1:10]

14) Yoda Vs. Dooku - Finale (Film Edit) - [3:42]

15) The Clone Wars -Finale - End Credits (Suite) - [11:13]

15) The Story of Attack of the Clones - [15:13]

16) Film End Credits Suite - [6:20]

Currently Only Episode II is available. Disc 1 and Disc 2 are up. Disc 3 is nearly finished. I will start uploading all my other edits again in case anyone missed them. PM me for the new link.

[Pieter Boelen 740]

Cool. Looks like I'll be needing to redo my own personal very-quickly-put-together Episode II extended version then. Like I didn't have enough to do already.

[Henry B 50]

Thank you, I couldn't help but read that like:

"I just wanted to wish you good luck: We're all counting on you." lol

...

[GoodMusician 56]

Thank you, I couldn't help but read that like:

"I just wanted to wish you good luck: We're all counting on you." lol

...

WHAT! lol

It kinda sounds like it...

Hey, GoodMusician,

Just want to say, that I appreciate all the hard work that you are putting into this, and keep it up! I really enjoyed the Episode III edit, so I'm pretty optimistic and excited about this one. Keep up the good work.

[TRIFORCE89 0]

No one replied?

I've listened to it GM. Going to give it another listen today before I say much of anything. But, there weren't as many SFX as I thought there were going to be. Good job!

Can't wait to see what you do next.

[Giftheck 916]

I've listened to it. I couldn't believe he got the tracked music 100% absolutely correct! There's one tracked piece missing but that's actually irrelevant (about 10 seconds long from "Search for Shmi" but to be honest the track sounds a lot better without the tracked bit in it)

I'd strongly recommend this edit to anyone and everyone who's a fan of Williams. It's the best AotC score I've heard in a long time.

Once again, a brilliant effort, GoodMusician.

[Henry B 50]

I couldn't believe he got the tracked music 100% absolutely correct!

That's a good thing?

[GoodMusician 56]

I tried my best on the Battle for Geonosis to get everything right. Track the correct material from the correct source (just had to listen enough and know the music enough to recognize where things came from) and then also to correctly alter things...

Many people never pitch shifted certain segments, but you have to to get the flow right...

And yes, seeing as I did it as part of the set, it's a good thing

But do NOT be mislead. I did NOT track music into cues that were written for the film... like Secret Landing on Geonosis had the ending of the track brought in about the middle, but I did NOT do tracks like that. I only did sourced cues when that was the "cue" and there is no official... like "Tatooine Resolution," or the Battle for Geonosis ones...

No tracked music or looped segments within released cues from Episode II were done as that's simply not what this set was for.

Like I made "Tatooine Resolution" becuase it was all tracked music and no one knows what went there... but In the music for the dark side taking root or "Tusken Camp" as Yoda speaks to Mace... that music is looped twice in the film... but Ididn't do that in my edit.

However, cues that I was unsure of... or couldn't adequately create the endings to, might have the tracked music as heard in the film.

The Council Confers for instance... no one is exactly sure what was suppose to go there and what was tracked from other sources such as The Jedi Archives or even Emergency Powers... but it's hard to say... and if I removed a segment, the audio echo would be strange as you'd hear one thing, and then mid sentence someone else... so I left the entire rip in that case.

In the case of the ending to "The Army for the Republic," which then transitions into the lake retreat and "Glass Sculptures - Forbidden Kiss," I believe these two cues are meant to be one, but because of the amount of editing done to adequate bring in that trakced music for the finale of "The Army of the Republic," I couldn't bring in the beginning fanfare for "Glass Sculptures," so I simply let Army of the Republic end with its tracked music...and Glass Sculptures start with the correct music.

[Henry B 50]

Many people never pitch shifted certain segments, but you have to to get the flow right...

I wasn't aware that there was any flow to that music.

[GoodMusician 56]

cute... say what you will, but I did my best to replicate what was done.

[Wojo 2,453]

yet not a mess of 8000 20-second cues, even keeping in the tracked music - I look forward to this.

::grumble grumble:: between this and your pm ...

::grumble grumble:: lol

Not to dig up old wounds, but I just wanted to toss my two cents into the ring with regard to lots of tiny tracks versus long epic tracks.

My CDs get ripped to MP3, then never touched again. My 3-disc stereo on my dresser usually scratches my CDs, I'm too cheap to buy a new one, and listening to CDs on a computer is redundant once I've made the MP3.

Since I'm also to cheap to buy an iPod/Zune/Nomad/MP3-ready-cell-phone, I burn my music to an MP3 CD for either Winamp listening, or my four year old AIWA MP3-CD/FM/AM player in the car with a cassette adapter. Winamp is really good at blending track transitions, so it could be one 80-minute track, or a bunch of tiny ones. But that MP3 CD player leaves about a split-second gap between tracks. 8000 20-second tracks with such a gap between every track gets painful to listen to. Shorter tracks means you can't play them on random without breaking musical ideas; I don't listen to soundtracks on random anyways, but still. To each their own.

Examples of this are on the 4-disc Return of the King, with "Dwimorberg: The Haunted Mountain" and "Master Meriadoc, Swordthain" being one coherent musical statement, unnaturally separated into two separate tracks for length; ditto for "Allegiance to Denethor" and "The Sacrifice of Faramir." When I stop being lazy, I'll rerip each pair of tracks to be one track. The same thing is for such lengthy sequences as the water battle from Ben-Hur, where I opted for a 9 minute super-track instead of a bunch of little ones, just so my MP3 player wouldn't bug me.

I'm a hypocrite, though, when it comes to The Wizard of Oz...for some reason, I prefer to keep the whole Munchkinland sequence separated, so each song is its own track, instead of one supertrack. Dunno.

I digress. You did a marvelous job with this set, as with the other two prequel flicks, and look forward to listening to it sin interruptum.

***

"I just wanted to wish you good luck: We're all counting on you."

[]

[GoodMusician 56]

Ok...so I goofed... I knew that "The Droids Confer" was a tracked cue... but I simply COULD NOT find it...

and I just did... kick me...hit me...whatever lol...

I'm going to upload the single track in a bit to replace the one that is in the edit.

I've also decided under the suggestion of others to post the discs broken up by 100 mb for easier downloads. Incase you have had problems as well...

[Henry B 50]

cute... say what you will, but I did my best to replicate what was done.

Then you must be admitting that you find some merit in this music. That's something I can't understand. The editing is an insult to Williams, and certainly a contributing factor to his disinterest in Revenge of the Sith. It's something that should never be heard.

[GoodMusician 56]

I'm not going to get into some argument with you in my thread.

I'm simply saying that I included the score as complete as I could. The tracked battle music, seeing as Williams didn't write ANYTHING for those scenes, I included upon the request of those out there. I had not intended to, but I realized it would have made the set significantly shorter, no one had adequately replicated what was heard in the film, and it does improve the overall narrative to include it.

If you want to speak further on the issue, go ahead and pm me....

[Henry B 50]

Fair enough.

[Miguel Andrade 1,263]

Covers are already in the works.

CD labels should be up very soon

[GoodMusician 56]

OOoOO!

I knew I'd asked but I didn't think you'd be this quick ;-) thank you ehehe

Be sure you check that one track...

"The Droids Confer (Tracked)" should be the full title... ;-)

[Miguel Andrade 1,263]

Well, the day has 24 hours... of those 24 hours I work around 10 at school... sometimes 12.

Of the remaining, I sleep about 5 hours a night... which still leaves me some time to work on this projects.

[Giftheck 916]

GoodMusician, the MP3 link for the new "Droids Confer" track does not work.

[GoodMusician 56]

I can't believe it...

the link I wrote said .mp3... and the file ended in .MP3 lol and thus it didn't work...

[Giftheck 916]

heh... the internet is real picky like that.

Out of curiosity, when are you putting Episode III back up? I had to get rid due to limited Hard Drive space (and it was the one I told you about so it's likely out of date anyway)

[Desplat13 1]

So I have a question: Is this, um, legal?

Just curious.

Colin Thomson

[Red 75]

Considering it's not for sale, yes it is.

[GoodMusician 56]

The way It works is the site claims no offiliation to it. Anything given out cannot be done so publically like putting a link in a thread.

But legally speaking, as long as you have the album and the DVD, this could fall under making a copy for yourself... and as no money is exchanging hands... yes...

[Desplat13 1]

I see....And if you have the album, but not the DVD?

Colin Thomson

[GoodMusician 56]

You could lie and said you did and I'd be none the wiser technically...

There's some grey area...

[Henry B 50]

Nope, no gray area. It's illegal; end of story.

[Desplat13 1]

I may have just found a reason to buy the movies

Have AOTC, but none of the others.

Colin Thomson

[John Crichton 4]

I will make it legal.

[GoodMusician 56]

Thanks Henry... I was so confused until you made it so clear.

[Henry B 50]

Well, really. You're distributing files that contain music from a CD album, a DVD, numerous games, and more. There may be "gray area" in the case of the game music (though I suspect not), but any distribution of music from or edited from the CD is clearly illegal.