Datameister 2,044 Posted April 4, 2010 Share Posted April 4, 2010 Oy, that's so...old school, though! Boards are supposed to have built-in functionality for this... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Wojo 2,453 Posted April 5, 2010 Share Posted April 5, 2010 Power to the people. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jay 37,373 Posted April 5, 2010 Share Posted April 5, 2010 Oy, that's so...old school, though! Boards are supposed to have built-in functionality for this...The old board had an archive function, but this one doesn't. I've been going through and copy/pasting my old PMs into a draft email in gmail then deleting them to free up space. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Datameister 2,044 Posted April 5, 2010 Share Posted April 5, 2010 Guess I'm gonna have to sit down and just do it one of these days...(The old board's archiving function didn't even work for me anyway...) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 7, 2010 Share Posted April 7, 2010 Quick curious question - has anybody tried wave neutralization with The Phantom Menace? It'd be nice to have the film without the music to see how the Battle of Naboo matches up without having to rebuild the SFX field from scratch. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Datameister 2,044 Posted April 7, 2010 Share Posted April 7, 2010 I doubt it'd work...if we're thinking of the same thing, it only works if the waveforms of the signals you want gone are perfectly identical. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 7, 2010 Share Posted April 7, 2010 Should be since the UE came from the film stem, although I believe it may have been the theatrical film stem... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jay 37,373 Posted April 7, 2010 Share Posted April 7, 2010 But even if the timing was exactly the same, they still did volume adjustments and EQing to the music. I don't think it'd work Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Datameister 2,044 Posted April 7, 2010 Share Posted April 7, 2010 Yeah - I mean, even if the two signals are so much as compressed slightly differently, it'll leave auditory residue. I've even had cases where the same cue is on a CD twice, once with a clean ending and once mixed with something else, and they didn't quite cancel each other out as well as they should have. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 7, 2010 Share Posted April 7, 2010 Ah, well, worth a shot. And as I said, I think the UE is the theatrical mix (although I can't really prove it) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Datameister 2,044 Posted April 7, 2010 Share Posted April 7, 2010 Maybe I'll give it a shot one of these days, but I highly doubt it would work. You'd have to get the mix between the channels just right, and even then, that might not do it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MattyO 62 Posted April 9, 2010 Share Posted April 9, 2010 Has anyone with good editing skills made their own version of the ROTS End Credits?I had a crack, but I'm still trying to figure out Wavepad.I wanted something along the lines of this:A New Hope (Original Finale from ROTS)Star Wars Theme (As is)Princess Leia's Theme (As is)Battle of the Heroes (As is)Luke and LeiaAnakin's ThemeImperial March (with Emperor's Theme interlude)Duel of the FatesLuke's Theme (Original Ending of ROTS Credits)Is something like this even do-able, or should I just call John Williams to compose my ideal ROTS End Credits suite?At any rate, this is how I wish the ROTS Credits had been scored instead of the meaningless (albeit nice) reprisal of the Throne Room music. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
John Takis 206 Posted April 10, 2010 Share Posted April 10, 2010 Has anyone with good editing skills made their own version of the ROTS End Credits?Yeah, I did this. My criteria were that the the edit had to (a) make MUSICAL sense, and (b) be faithful to the tone of the film. First, I replaced the latter part of the main Star Wars theme with the one from TPM's end credits, because it ends on a note that let me segue smoothly into "Lament" (as opposed to "Duel of the Fates"). Then, at 1:07, "Lament" merges into "Anakin's Dark Deeds" (beginning at 0:34). It's the same note, and the chorus is continuous, so it sounds very smooth -- almost as if it was recorded that way. I honestly love this transition. At 2:13, I skip ahead to 3:53 for the final note. THAT note, in turn, is the same note that opens the concert version of "Battle of the Heroes," which is what comes next. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MattyO 62 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 Oh wow, John that sounds brilliant and much less nostalgia-based than mine. Any chance I could have a listen? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
John Takis 206 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 Oh wow, John that sounds brilliant and much less nostalgia-based than mine. Any chance I could have a listen?Hi MattyO,I try not to spread custom edits around, even of released material. I prefer to post "do-it-yourself" guides so that folks can legally make their own. (Also, PM is really the more appropriate venue for such questions.) I do appreciate your interest. My goal was, indeed, to avoid anything "nostalgia based," as I felt Williams' own recording unquestionably was.-- John Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MattyO 62 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 Sorry John, after I posted I thought I should have sent you an IM instead. I like your edit, I'm still going to have a go at assembling my own though. Thanks.I have some noob questions regarding the prequel scores. When we say we want the intended versions of the prequels released, does that mean the recording sessions? If so, does anyone have the list of recorded cues for Episode I and II - I've just looked at the one for III. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Trent B 337 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 I have some noob questions regarding the prequel scores. When we say we want the intended versions of the prequels released, does that mean the recording sessions? If so, does anyone have the list of recorded cues for Episode I and II - I've just looked at the one for III.To answer your first question yes when we saw we want the intended versions, we want the original recording sessions (final version) on how the music was recorded. Well before it was chopped up in the editing room.There's a partial list for The Phantom Menace, but nothing Attack Of The Clones and we have all the cues for Revenge Of The Sith.Here's the list for Revenge Of The Sith20th Century Fox FanfareStar Wars Main TitleBoys Into BattleThey're Coming AroundGet 'Em, R2!General Grievous / The Elevator SceneCount Dooku's EntranceThe Death Of DookuGrievous and The DroidsAnother Happy LandingRevisiting PadméGrievous Travels To PalpatineScenes and DreamsBe Careful Of Your FriendCouncil MeetingHold MePalpatine's TV SetPalpatine's Big PitchGoodbye, Old FriendGoing To UtapauObi-Wan Fights DroidsDrawing SwordsGood Guys ArrivePalpatine's SeductionRolling With GrievousFighting With GrievousDialogue With MacePadmé's RuminationsI Am The SenatePalpatine Instructs AnakinLamentBail's EscapeSwimming, Droids, Yoda FarewellNews Of The AttackMoving Things AlongAnakin's Dark DeedsIt Can't BeA Moody TripPadmé's VisitHeroes CollideDuel Of Yoda and SidiousYoda FallsThe Boys ContinueYoda To ExileRevenge Of The SithThe Immolation SceneAnakin CrawlingBirth Of The TwinsDeath Of PadméPlans For The TwinsPadmé's FuneralA Home For The TwinsEnd CreditsA Hero Falls (Concert Suite)Edit: For The Phantom Menace list I did my best to fill in the missing gaps that were there.20th Century Fox FanfareStar Wars Main TitleThe ArrivalGas LeakDroid FightQueen AmidalaThe Droid InvasionIntroducing Jar JarBubble WorldGone Fishin'Darth SidiousTentaclesTheed Palace ArivalYou're Under ArrestEscape From NabooIntro Darth MaulArrival At TatooinePadmé Meets AnakinRun-In With SebulbaIntroducing ThreepioRunning Out Of TimeTalk Of PodracingWatto's DealKids At PlayMidi-Chlorian CountThe Sith SpacecraftRoll Of The DieThe Flag ParadeJabba IntroductionThe Race BeginsLap Three(speculation)Anakin Defeats SebulbaAnakin's Great VictoryAnakin Is FreeDarth and Qui-GonCoruscant ArrivalThe Queen and PalpatineHigh Council MeetingThe SenateAnakin's TestHe Is The Chosen OneConferring With SidiousMoving ForwardThe GungansWar PlansThe Armies Face OffCourtyard CrossfireLaser Fight MarchGet To Your ShipsThe Big ArmyAnakin Takes Off (I'm sure that was a separate cue)The Droid BattleUp The WireThe Great DuelThe Invisible Wall (possibly recorded as a separate cue)Crash LandingQui-Gon's Noble EndBattleship DestroyedThe Death Of Darth MaulA Jedi He Will BeQui-Gon's FuneralAugie's Great Municipal BandEnd Credits (containing unused parts)Duel Of The FatesAnakin's ThemeUnknown Tremolo SwellStreet Band Of Mos Espa (Source)Desert Winds (Source)Mos Espa Arena Band (Source)The Street Singer (Source) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MattyO 62 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 It seems so condensed compared to the mess of the scores in the films. It would be so easy for Lucasfilm to release this music. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 Courtyard CrossfireLaser Fight MarchI always thought of those two cues as actually being one. It could be that there's never been a released clean ending for it though (I know there's one in Obi-Wan but that's just reverb - I could do the same with my sound card)End Credits (containing unused parts)I always thought that there were two different end credits recordings. But beyond that, there's two different versions of the one that was actually used - the one used in the Album/Ultimate Edition is slightly different in its orchestration to the one used in the film. In fact, the one in the film, save for the end few notes, is exactly the same as the AOTC End Credits, so it wouldn't surprise me if they recorded some overlays for that take. The unused recording (allegedly "7m? End Title Part II (unused)") is just taken straight from the Throne Room/End Credits suite. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Luke Skywalker 1,796 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 not straight, that princess leias theme variation is refreshing. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 It's the same as the End Credits portion of the Throne Room suite. That 'variation' is always used in the Throne Room suite, and in the Main Titles suite too.EDIT: Just noticed we have the clean ending to "Shmi's Funeral - Crisis on Geonosis". It's in Elite Squadron but there's two problems with the file. 1 - the channels are flipped. 2 - you'll need to re-save the entire file as it's cut short a bit but the entirety of the final chord is buried in there despite the apparent fade-out (you might try to ay it's reverb caused my my new mastering technique but there's never been any reverb on any of the other cues - just this one has the final chord 'hidden'). I'd suggest opening it in a program such as Adobe Soundbooth and re-saving it there. Otherwise it picks up exactly where the TFU part leaves off. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Luke Skywalker 1,796 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 i had never heard that prince's leia variation.All versions i have heard are the typical concert suite. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 This is what you replied to mine. not straight, that princess leias theme variation is refreshing.The Unused End Credits, found in Republic Commando, Renegade and Elite Squadron, and a couple of other games, come straight from that concert suite. You're probably thinking of the Episode III End Credits. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Luke Skywalker 1,796 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 But princess leia's theme is reorchestrated in a way i had never heard before or after! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 11, 2010 Share Posted April 11, 2010 The only difference I can notice is the way the flutes play in the lead up to the crescendo. Then again, I'm sure I've heard that done in a concert suite for the Main Titles somewhere...It seems I was right about the AotC credits being the TPM End Credits with an overlayed ending. To get rid of the end of the TPM cue they just removed it and added a looped measure from before, then added an overlay.Speaking of the TPM End Credits, I'm wondering if there's more to the End Credits recording that was used.Trent speculates that there's a "Lap Three" cue. I don't think so. I think it goes with "The Race Begins" as shown in the video game Racer Revenge.It seems a more natural fit that way and I layered it against the film. The orchestrations mostly fit from where Anakin manages to get his engines to start, up to the part where Sebulba rams that three-eyed guy off the the track. But they could have changed that scene afterwards because the next part doesn't fit very well.As I said above, but probably it went unnoticed because it was an edit to my post, I now have almost all of the ending to "Shmi's Funeral - Crisis on Geonosis". There's material in Elite Squadron that segues directly into the bit we have from TFU. I'll send the corrected file along if anybody wants it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Henry B 50 Posted April 12, 2010 Author Share Posted April 12, 2010 But princess leia's theme is reorchestrated in a way i had never heard before or after!Manuel, listen to "Throne Room/End Title." It's the original end credits from Star Wars, simple as that. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
steb74 53 Posted April 12, 2010 Share Posted April 12, 2010 Trent speculates that there's a "Lap Three" cue. I don't think so. I think it goes with "The Race Begins" as shown in the video game Racer Revenge.It seems a more natural fit that way and I layered it against the film. The orchestrations mostly fit from where Anakin manages to get his engines to start, up to the part where Sebulba rams that three-eyed guy off the the track. But they could have changed that scene afterwards because the next part doesn't fit very well.I think Trent is probably right and there's a good chance it's cue 4M1.Below are the written cues I've looked over and the 'Lap 3' music is not part of 'The Race Begins' like I previously mentioned ...unless of course it was written later as an insert.3M10 ??(Jabba Introduction/Start Your Engine)3M11 The Race Begins4M2 Anakin Defeats Sebulba Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Trent B 337 Posted April 12, 2010 Share Posted April 12, 2010 It plays after "The Race Begins" I think it's meant to be a separate piece. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 12, 2010 Share Posted April 12, 2010 I heard "Jabba Introduction" and "Start Your Engine" were two different cues.So if that is the case, what we have as "The Race Begins" could be "Start Your Engine" and what some people have as "Lap Three" (me personally I added it to the end of The Reace Begins) might be "The Race Begins".But this is based on an older cue list that doesn't have the complete slate numbers. It also claims "The Armies Face Off" is separate from "Forest Mist" (the oiginal "Gungans' March" bit replaced by the Drums Insert) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aj_vader 534 Posted April 13, 2010 Share Posted April 13, 2010 Is it true that the Opening Star Wars Theme for Revenge Of The Sith, is a recording from Attack of the Clones or Phantom Menace? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Charlie Brigden 7 Posted April 13, 2010 Share Posted April 13, 2010 Is it true that the Opening Star Wars Theme for Revenge Of The Sith, is a recording from Attack of the Clones or Phantom Menace?As far as I'm aware, the main title that was recorded for TPM was just re-used for AOTC and ROTS instead of recording new ones. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
John Crichton 4 Posted April 13, 2010 Share Posted April 13, 2010 Correct. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
steb74 53 Posted April 13, 2010 Share Posted April 13, 2010 I heard "Jabba Introduction" and "Start Your Engine" were two different cues.It's not man, it's one cue - 3M10So if that is the case, what we have as "The Race Begins" could be "Start Your Engine" and what some people have as "Lap Three" (me personally I added it to the end of The Reace Begins) might be "The Race Begins".The Race Begins is just 3M11 The Race Begins and like I keep saying, the Lap 3 music is not part of that particular written cue, it may of been added later as an insert or something but it was not part of the original cue.I believe it's how Trent has it and there's a good chance it's 4M1. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jim Ware 526 Posted April 13, 2010 Share Posted April 13, 2010 I heard "Jabba Introduction" and "Start Your Engine" were two different cues.It's not man, it's one cue - 3M10How does 3M10 end? How does 3M11 begin?There are three distinct pieces in this sequence:The Jabba intro (OST T9 0:00-1:39).The string tremelo/low brass pulses (OST T9 1:39-1:58)The fast-paced string/high woodwind dominated action cue (OST T9 1:58-2:27)Can you give any indication of how these fit in the written score?So if that is the case, what we have as "The Race Begins" could be "Start Your Engine" and what some people have as "Lap Three" (me personally I added it to the end of The Reace Begins) might be "The Race Begins".The Race Begins is just 3M11 The Race Begins and like I keep saying, the Lap 3 music is not part of that particular written cue, it may of been added later as an insert or something but it was not part of the original cue.I believe it's how Trent has it and there's a good chance it's 4M1.I've always suspected that the supposed 'Lap Three' piece is an alternate 'Race Begins'.Also, we have distinct confusion being caused by the introduction of fan-created cue titles! I know that 'Jabba Introduction', 'Start Your Engine', 'Race Begins', 'Anakin Defeats Sebulba' and 'Anakin's Great Victory' are all genuine, but things like 'Courtyard Crossfire' are not. Can we perhaps assemble a definitive list (with the aid of the printed scores if available)? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
steb74 53 Posted April 13, 2010 Share Posted April 13, 2010 How does 3M10 end?Hi Jim, in the OST version (Track 9: 0:00 - 1:38), the cue obviously segues into the next cue but the UE version has the proper clean ending for it which is basically just the drum roll that plays out (2 side drums + field drum).How does 3M11 begin?Almost the same as on the OST (Track 9: 1:38 - 2:27) but the cue is missing the first bar, the brass chords and strings trills that you hear at the start this cue on the OST are from bar 2, the first bar may be there but is just mixed way down, so I consider it to be missing.The UE version does have this missing bar but it's heavily edited. It was mentioned on here though by ggctuk that by using the AOTC dvd you can get a rip of the missing bar, I think he said from the Arena scene.There are three distinct pieces in this sequence:The Jabba intro (OST T9 0:00-1:39).The string tremelo/low brass pulses (OST T9 1:39-1:58)The fast-paced string/high woodwind dominated action cue (OST T9 1:58-2:27)Can you give any indication of how these fit in the written score?With regards to the written score, the OST is split up as follows:3M10 ?? (Jabba Introduction/Start Your Engine)0:00 - 1:383M11 The Race Begins1:38 - 2:27 (1:38 - 1:58, maybe it's meant to be split from the remaining music up until 2:27 but it's still part of 3M11)4M2 Anakin Defeats Sebulba2:27 - end (the cymbal you hear at the start of this cue is not in the written score, it was possibly added on the scoring stage or later artificially, I think there are one or two more cymbal hits added that are also not on the written score)I've always suspected that the supposed 'Lap Three' piece is an alternate 'Race Begins'.Interesting man, I hadn't even considered that option, I do like the idea though that this could be 4M1.(Timings may differ by a second or so due to the method of playback I suppose)Can we perhaps assemble a definitive list (with the aid of the printed scores if available)?The only ones I have looked at are:1M7 Introducing Jar jar3M6 The Sith Spacecraft (I haven't looked at this one but a friend of mine gave me the slate number)3M10 ?? (Jabba Introduction/Start Your Engine)3M11 The Race Begins4M2 Anakin Defeats Sebulba5M4+5 The Chosen One Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gruesome Son of a Bitch 6,488 Posted April 13, 2010 Share Posted April 13, 2010 I just want to say that while I don't participate in editing the PT music, I love reading through this thread. I usually learn something new and there's something just sort of comforting about just how obsessive you guys are with this stuff, and I mean no disrespect. I'm just very entertained with the thread is all I'm really saying. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 14, 2010 Share Posted April 14, 2010 I heard "Jabba Introduction" and "Start Your Engine" were two different cues.It's not man, it's one cue - 3M10So if that is the case, what we have as "The Race Begins" could be "Start Your Engine" and what some people have as "Lap Three" (me personally I added it to the end of The Reace Begins) might be "The Race Begins".The Race Begins is just 3M11 The Race Begins and like I keep saying, the Lap 3 music is not part of that particular written cue, it may of been added later as an insert or something but it was not part of the original cue.I believe it's how Trent has it and there's a good chance it's 4M1.You've misinterpreted what I'm saying. No, what I mean is this:The material in the Album, Track 09, from start to 1:36 is "Jabba Introduction". From there, it's "Start Your Engine" to 2:27. The Race Begins is that partially unreleased piece, the end bit which is in the Ultimate Edition Disc 1, Track 33, from 1:43 to the end.If Anakin Defeats Sebulba is 4M2, what's 4M1, I wonder? If it IS that piece, I still believe it goes where I put it. I cannot find a single place elsewhere to put it. I doubt it starts Lap Three. Then again, it could also have been used to score a scene that got canned in the re-edit Lucas made. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
steb74 53 Posted April 14, 2010 Share Posted April 14, 2010 You've misinterpreted what I'm saying. No, what I mean is this:The material in the Album, Track 09, from start to 1:36 is "Jabba Introduction". From there, it's "Start Your Engine" to 2:27. The Race Begins is that partially unreleased piece, the end bit which is in the Ultimate Edition Disc 1, Track 33, from 1:43 to the end.Although Jabba Introduction and Start Your Engine are in a sense two different things, they are both part of 3M10, both of them.Unfortunately, the title was cropped off the score I looked at but it still says 3M10.The Race Begins is not that partially unreleased piece, it is not on the written score.I'm not saying it couldn't of been added later as an insert or something ....but it is not part of the written cue 3M11 The Race Begins, it just isn't.If Anakin Defeats Sebulba is 4M2, what's 4M1, I wonder? If it IS that piece, I still believe it goes where I put it. I cannot find a single place elsewhere to put it. I doubt it starts Lap Three. Then again, it could also have been used to score a scene that got canned in the re-edit Lucas made.Exactly, with the amount of tinkering that went on with the film, I imagine there'll be some parts that will be almost impossible for us to truly figure out.For now, I'm going with Lap 3 as 4M1 unless like Jim W says, it could possibly be an alternate 'Race Begins'. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Trent B 337 Posted April 18, 2010 Share Posted April 18, 2010 Okay fellas I finally went through the PC rips for TFU and made a list of just the important stuff. There was some stuff from The Phantom Menace U.E. that I really didn't include. I also deleted the PS2 rips that the guy did when he made the PC rips, simply because there was no need for duplicates. Then I just numbered the PC rips accordingly.008 - PC_mxGUI_jwStatsAct1_lp_01ROTS - Moving Things Along (Film Version)011 - PC_mxGUI_jwStatsAct1Evil_lpTPM - Bubble WorldTFU - ?014 - PC_mxGUI_jwStatsAct2Evil_lpTFU - ?018 - PC_mxEMP_jwJunoRescue_lp_02AOTC - Confrontation With Count Dooku (with TPM Tromolo Swell)TFU 019 - PC_mxDEA_mgRebelBattle_lpTFU020 - PC_mxFE1_jw3RancorBattle_lpROTS - They're Coming Around (Film Version)023 - PC_mxFE1_jwShaakTiBattle_lpTFUROTS - I Am The SenateROTS - It Can't BeROTS - I Am The Senate024 - PC_mxFEL_mgRancorBattle_lpTFU025 - PC_mxFEL_mgImperialBattle_lpTFU026 - PC_mxFEL_mgSithBattle_lpTFU028 - PC_mxKAS_jwMarchBattle_lpAOTC - The Arena031 - PC_mxFE1_jwAmbient01_lpESBAOTC - This Is A CrisisROTS - Count Dooku's EntranceROTS - Goodbye, Old FriendROTS - I Am The Senate032 - PC_mxFE1_jwAmbient02_lpTFU - ?033 - PC_mxFE1_jwAmbient02_lp_01TFU - ?034 - PC_mxFE1_jwAmbient02_lp_02AOTC - Zam The AssassinTFU - ?ROTS - I Am The SenateTFUAOTC - Zam The AssassinTFUROTS - I Am The SenateTFU035 - PC_mxFE1_jwAmbient02_lp_03ROTS - Palpatine's Big PitchROTS - News Of The AttackROTS - Be Careful Of Your FriendROTS - News Of The AttackROTS - Palpatine's Big Pitch036 - PC_mxFE1_jwAmbient02_lp_04ROTS - Goodbye, Old FriendROTS - Scenes and Dreams (Unedited OST section)TFU - ?AOTC - Zam The AssassinTFU - ?037 - PC_mxFE1_jwAmbient02_lp_05AOTC - The HomesteadAOTC - Spying On The Separatists (Film Version)AOTC - The Tusken Camp038 - PC_mxGEN_jwEvilCredits_lpROTJTFUROTS - Anakin CrawlingROTS - Birth Of The TwinsESBROTS - Moving Things Along (Film Version)039 - PC_mxJT2_jwGreatHall02_lp_01ROTS - Palpatine's SeductionROTS - Anakin's Dark DeedsROTS - Scenes and DreamsROTS - Palpatine's Seduction040 - PC_mxJT2_jwGreatHall02_lp_02AOTC - Zam The Assassin042 - PC_mxJT3_jwTempleRuins02_lpROTS - Be Careful Of Your FriendAOTC - FinaleTPM - The SenateTPMROTS - Be Careful Of Your Friend043 - PC_mxRX1_jwLandingPad01_lpPalpatine's TV Set (looped a few times)044 - PC_mxDEA_jwVaderBattle01_lpESBTPM - Death Of Darth MaulTPM - Qui-Gon's Noble EndESB048 - PC_mxDEA_jwEmperorBattle_lpROTS - I Am The Senate054 - PC_music_vnDML0ROTS - Anakin's Dark Deeds (Alternate / Film Version Mixes)055 - PC_music_vnDML020ROTS - Grievous Travels To PalpatineROTS - Heroes CollideESBROTS - Grievous Travels To Palpatine (looped)056 - PC_mxKAS_mgRebelBattle_lpTFU060 - PC_mxPRO_jwLandingPad01_lpROTS - Moving Things Along (Film Version)061 - PC_mxTIE_jwLowCombat01_lpROTS - Swimming, Droids, Yoda Farewell 062 - PC_mxTIE_jwPanelFabHall_lpROTS - General Grievous / The Elevator SceneROTS - Get 'Em, R2!063 - PC_mxTIE_mgApprenBattle_lpTFU066 - PC_music_vnKAS920AOTC - Yoda Vs. Dooku067 - PC_music_vnCCY01TFU069 - PC_mxTAT_jwIntroVignette_nlAOTC - Return To Tatooine070 - PC_mxTIE_jwAmbient01_lpTPM071 - PC_mxRX2_jwPROXYEnding_lpAOTC - Return To Tatooine (Film Version)TPM - Duel Of The Fates (Instrumental)072 - PC_mxRX1_jwBehemothFight01_lpROTS - Rolling With Grievous073 - PC_mxRX1_jwDrexlBattle01_lpROTS - Riding The Lizard (Film Version Mix)074 - PC_mxRX1_jwGolemFight01_lpAOTC - Going After DookuAOTC - The Tusken Camp075 - PC_mxRX1_jwKazdanBattle01_lpTPM - Anakin Defeats Sebulba (Early Mix)076 - PC_mxRX1_jwKazdanBattle02_lpTPM - TentaclesAOTC - Bounty Hunter's PursuitTPM - Tentacles078 - PC_mxRX1_jwSusState02_lpAOTC - Yoda Vs. DookuTPM - The Sith SpacecraftROTS - Count Dooku's EntranceAOTC - The Chase Through Coruscant080 - PC_mxRX2_jwGeneratorRoom01_lpTFUESB082 - PC_mxGEN_jwGoodCredits_lpTFU 083 - PC_music_vnDML030TPM - Crash Landing (mixed with TFU)ESB084 - PC_music_vnFEL250TFU - ?085 - PC_music_vnTAT080_SkiffExitROTS - I Am The Senate (unused section)086 - PC_mxFE1_jwTransition01_nlTFU088 - PC_mxFE1_jwTransition03_nlTFU -?089 - PC_mxFE1_jwTransition04_nlAOTC - Inspecting The Army090 - PC_mxFE1_jwTransition05_nlUnknown DrumsROTS - I Am The SenateUnknown Ending092 - PC_mxRX1_mgSusState01_lpROTS - Dialogue With Mace (clean opening)094 - PC_mxFE2_jwTransition01_nlROTS - Fighting With Grievous097 - PC_mxFE2_jwTransition04_nlESBTFU - ?099 - PC_mxHOT_jwHothBattleReveal_nlAOTC - Confrontation With Count DookuTPM - Tremolo SwellTFU101 - PC_mxHOT_wrSuspense01_lpESBTFU - ?114 - PC_mxRX2_jwTransition02_nlTPM - High Council Meeting (unused opening?)115 - PC_mxRX2_mgOverlay01TFU118 - PC_mxTAT_jwRancorGate_nlROTS - General Grievous / The Elevator Scene (Possible Film Mix)119 - PC_mxTAT_jwTortureRoom_lpROTS - Birth Of The Twins122 - PC_mxTIE_jwTransition02_nlTPM - Running Out Of Time123 - PC_mxTIE_jwTransition03_nlTPM - Courtyard Crossfire125 - PC_vnDS010_RoyalGuardIntroAOTC - Chase Through Coruscant (Film Version)127 - PC_vnTEM010_PlayerIntroROTS - Obi-Wan Fights Droids135 - PC_music_vnTFCF010ROTS - They're Coming Around136 - PC_music_vnVDR010TFU - ?137 - PC_mxDEA_jwVaderBattle_lpTPM - Crash Landing (UE) mixed with TFU140 - PC_mxFE1_jwOverlay03_nlROTS - Drawing Swords144 - PC_mxFE1_mgOverlay01_nlROTS - The Elevator Scene145 - PC_mxFE1_mgOverlay02_nlTFU - ?146 - PC_mxFE1_mgOverlay03_nlROTS - Grievous and The Droids147 - PC_mxFE1_mgOverlay04_nlAOTC - Bounty Hunter's Pursuit148 - PC_mxFE1_mgOverlay05_nlTFU - ?149 - PC_mxFE1_mgOverlay06_nlROTS - Death Of Dooku150 - PC_mxFE1_mgOverlay07_nlTFU - ? TPM - Piccolo overlays151 - PC_mxFE2_jwOverlay01TFU - ?154 - PC_mxFE2_jwOverlay04TFU - ?158 - PC_mxFE2_jwOverlay09TFU - ?159 - PC_mxFE2_jwOverlay10ROTS - Going To Utapau161 - PC_mxFE2_jwOverlay12AOTC - Ambush On Coruscant162 - PC_mxFE2_jwOverlay13TFU - ?164 - PC_mxFE2_jwOverlay15ROTS - Swimming165 - PC_mxFE2_jwOverlay16TFU - ?166 - PC_mxFE2_jwSusState01_lpAOTC - Bounty Hunter's Pursuit168 - PC_mxFE2_mgOverlay01TPM - Tremolo Swell TFU - Overlays169 - PC_mxFE2_mgOverlay02ROTS - Palpatine's Big Pitch171 - PC_mxFE2_mgOverlay04AOTC - Zam The Assassin (overlayed with TFU)175 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay01_nlTFU - ?177 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay03_nlTFU - ?178 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay04_nlTFU - ?179 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay05_nlROTS - Be Careful Of Your Friend180 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay06_nlTFU - ?181 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay07_nlTFU - ?182 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay08_nlROTS - Goodbye, Old Friend (TFU Overlay)183 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay09_nlROTS - Anakin Crawling184 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay10_nlROTS (Riding The Lizard) mixed with TFU186 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay12_nlTFU - ?187 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay13_nlROTS - Heroes Collide (unreleased beginning portion)188 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay14_nlROTS - I Am The Senate189 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay15_nlTFU - ?190 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay16_nlAOTC - Zam The Assassin191 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay17_nlROTS - Swimming (clean opening)192 - PC_mxRX1_jwOverlay18_nlTFU - ?193 - PC_mxRX1_jwTransition02_nlTFU - Same as above194 - PC_mxRX1_jwTransition03_nlTFU - ?196 - PC_mxRX1_jwTransition05_nlROTS - Rolling With GrievousESB197 - PC_mxRX1_jwTransition06_nlROTS - Good Guys Arrive (Ending)198 - PC_mxRX1_jwTransition07_nlROTS - Fight With Grievous (Film Version)DOTF 199 - PC_mxRX1_jwTransition08_nlROTS - Bail's Escape (Ending)200 - PC_mxRX1_jwTransition09_nlROTS - Fighting With Grievous201 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay01_nlROTS - Drawing SwordsAOTC - Ambush On Coruscant / Council's Confer202 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay02_nlAOTC - Zam The Assassin203 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay03_nlTFU - ?204 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay04_nlROTS - Heroes Collide (same 187 but more)205 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay05_nlTFU - ?206 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay06_nlROTS - Count Dooku's Entrance207 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay07_nlROTS - Grievous Travels To Palpatine208 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay08_nlROTS - Fighting With Grievous (Ending)209 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay09_nlROTS - Palpatine's Big Pitch211 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay11_nlAOTC - Yoda Vs. Dooku212 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay12_nlROTS - I Am The Senate213 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay13_nlROTS - Palpatine's SeductionROTS - Palpatine's Big Pitch214 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay14_nlTFU - ?215 - PC_mxRX1_mgOverlay15_nlTFU - ?216 - PC_mxRX2_jwBattleZoneVictoryAOTC - Bounty Hunter's Pursuit218 - PC_mxRX2_jwOverlay02TFU - ?ROTS - Drawing Swords224 - PC_mxRX2_jwOverlay08ROTS - Death Of Dooku (drum roll)ESB227 - PC_mxRX2_jwOverlay11ROTS - Bail's EscapeAOTC - Confrontation With Count Dooku228 - PC_mxRX2_jwOverlay12TFU - ?231 - PC_mxRX2_jwOverlay15ROTS - Drawing SwordsROTS - Fight With Grievous (Ending)233 - PC_mxRX2_jwOverlay17ROTS - It Can't Be234 - PC_mxRX2_jwOverlay18ROTS - Drawing Swords235 - PC_mxRX2_jwOverlay19ROTS - Moving Things Along236 - Mov_FMV-AttractModeANHTFU - ? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 18, 2010 Share Posted April 18, 2010 Some of that is recycled BF2 and Revenge of the Sith game mixes, but there is an abundance of newer material that we've identified in the PC rip. Great work, Trent.I wasn't aware of any differences, aside from looping, between the film and album mixes of "Riding the Lizard".It's funny you mention "Anakin Defeats Sebulba" is an 'early mix' (it's one of three mixes for that cue that we have). I would assume that the mixes used in the video games, especially for TPM, were done by Ken Wannberg for LucasArts specifically, although some of those mixes appear in Attack of the Clones as well as the Final mixes by Williams himself. Oddly enough some of the 'early mixes' are identical, or near enough identical, to the 'final mixes' so in some cases I'm assuming Williams was satisfied with one take on some cues.Oddly enough, Wannberg seems to have created two mixes of the cue "Take to your Ships" for use in the games. The first mix (the one closest to the Album version) has not been heard since Jedi Starfighter. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Luke Skywalker 1,796 Posted April 18, 2010 Share Posted April 18, 2010 ken wannberg creating mixxes specifically for the games? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 18, 2010 Share Posted April 18, 2010 Well, he was the supervising music editor. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Trent B 337 Posted April 18, 2010 Share Posted April 18, 2010 I'm sure those early versions were actually recorded as is for the film but were revised to not include the added percussion. Much like the re-recorded pieces for the OST of ROTS for certain cues.Edit: By the way I remember something from the U.E. of TPM the Sith Chant overlays that are present towards the end of "Qui-Gon's Noble End", the way how they were looped and sped up was exactly how they appeared during the part when Obi-Wan was stuck behind that force field while watching Qui-Gon and Maul fight before Maul beat Qui-Gon. In the U.E. they don't reflect that, it's just the album version with those piccolos overlayed and the horn deal. So another cue that's clearly not the film version (IE: Augie's Great Municipal Band). Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Giftheck 917 Posted April 18, 2010 Share Posted April 18, 2010 I don't recall any added percussion to most of the cues in TPM, just Anakin Defeats Sebulba and Duel of the Fates.I'd love to know why there currently exists three different mixes for three cues - "Anakin Defeats Sebulba", "Take to your Ships" and "End Credits". Each mix sounds different in comparable bits. Of course, we don't actually have all of the third version of "Take to your Ships". Yet. I hope we do get more in a future game.EDIT: I shall explain that there are indeed three different versions of End Credits. Two are obvious - the Album take and the one based on the Throne Room concert suite. The third is the film version, which can also be heard in Attack of the Clones. The orchestration of the middle parts is different to the TPM album version. Slightly different but with a careful ear you can hear the differences.I thought the ROTS Album contained the exact same takes used in the film, just without overlayed percussion? I think there's a single fanfare missing from the film version of "Boys into Battle" but it's quiet enough to have been dropped out in the sound booth. The mixing of the snare drums is also louder in the film version too.I also find it curious that the album version of They're Coming Around has odd mixing for the taiko drums - first the drums are mixed in loud, then they get quieter and queiter.So we have the following cues not the same as the TPM film:Disc 1- "04 - Death Warrant for Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan" -Final synth chord is shorter although that could be due to editing if the album to lessen the gap between the tracks.- "31 - The Flag Parade" - not the same as the theatrical version, nor the DVD version.- "32 - Sebulba's Dirty Hand - Qui-Gon's Pep Talk" - they added the actual closing moments of the cue in the UE, they are absent in the film.Disc 2- "15 - The Queen and Her Group Sneak Back Into the Palace" and 16 - The Battle Begins"" - in the UE it goes straight to "Moving Forward/Courtyard Crossfire/Whatever it's called", but in the film, there's a good few seconds between the end of this piece and the start of "Moving Forward". Had that been replicated in the UE, we would have had a clean ending for "The Armies Face Off" far sooner than BF2.- "17 - The Republic Pilots Take Off Into Space" - the film cuts the last timpani hit in favour of reverb.- "27 - The Death of Qui-Gon and the Surrender of the Gunguns" See Trent's post above- "29 - The Queen Confronts Nute and Rune" and "30 - The Funeral of Qui-Gon" are the Album version, but I'm certain in the film the first track was edited down. I haven't seen the film in some time though so I could be mistaken.- "31 - The Parade" and "32 - End Credits" are the Album version. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lordskylark 1 Posted April 21, 2010 Share Posted April 21, 2010 This is the Episode III cue sheet (there has never been an episode II cue sheet released anywhere that I am aware of). This Episode III cue sheet leaves gaps for placement of tracked music. As it was pre-planned for this music to be tracked, I personally consider it a part of the final version of the score (unlike tracking that is done late into the production) * 1M1 Fox Fanfare (The Empire Strikes Back Recording) * 1M2 Star Wars Main Theme (The Phantom Menace Recording) * 1M3 Boys Into Battle February 12, 2005 * 1M4 They're Coming Around February 14, 2005 * 1M4a "Get 'Em, R-2!" February 7, 2005 * 1M5 The Elevator Scene February 17, 2005 * 1M6 Count Dooku's Entrance February 14, 2005 * 1M7 The Death Of Dooku February 2, 2005 * 2M1 Grievous And The Droids February 9, 2005 * 2M3 Another Happy Landing February 3, 2005 * 2M4 Revisiting Padmé February 3, 2005 * 2M5 Grievous Travels To Palpatine February 3, 2005 * 2M6 Scenes And Dreams February 12, 2005 * 2M7 Be Careful Of Your Friend February 13, 2005 * 3M1 Council Meeting February 14, 2005 * 3M2 Hold Me February 13, 2005 * 3M2a Palpatine's TV Set February 7, 2005 * 3M3 Palpatine's Big Pitch February 9, 2005 * 3M5 Goodbye Old Friend February 3, 2005 * 3M6 Going To Utapau February 13, 2005 * 3M7 Riding The Lizard February 12, 2005 * 3M8 Obi-Wan Fares [sic] Droids February 12, 2005 * 4M1x Drawing Swords February 3, 2005 * 4M1a Good Guys Arrive February 8, 2005 * 4M3 Palpatine's Seduction February 2, 2005 * 4M4 Rolling With Grievous February 13, 2005 * 4M4a Fighting With Grievous February 8, 2005 * 4M5 Dialogue With Mace February 17, 2005 * 4M5a Padmé's Ruminations February 8, 2005 * 4M6 I Am The Senate February 14, 2005 * 5M1 Palpatine Instructs Anakin February 3, 2005 * 5M3 Lament February 7, 2005 * 5M3a Bail's Escape February 14, 2005 * 5M4 "Swimming, Droids and Yoda Farewell" February 9, 2005 * 5M5 News Of The Attack February 12, 2005 * 5M6 Moving Things Along February 9, 2005 * 5M7 Anakin's Dark Deeds February 3, 2005 * 6M1 It Can't Be February 17, 2005 * 6M2 A Moody Trip February 12, 2005 * 6M3 Padmé's Visit February 2, 2005 * 6M4 Heroes Collide February 2, 2005 * 6M5 Duel Of Yoda And Sidious **Choir Only** Not Assigned * 6M6 Yoda Falls February 3, 2005 * 6M7 The Boys Continue February 8, 2005 * 6M8 Rev. Yoda To Exile February 12, 2005 * 6M9 Revenge Of The Sith February 3, 2005 * 7M1 The Immolation Scene February 8, 2005 * 7M2 Anakin Crawling February 8, 2005 * 7M3 The Birth Of The Twins February 7, 2005 * 7M4 The Death Of Padmé February 7, 2005 * 7M5 Plans For The Twins February 8, 2005 * 7M6 Padmé's Funeral February 7, 2005 * 7M7 A Home For The Twins February 7, 2005 * 7M8 End Credits February 17, 2005This is an assumed cue list by trying to arrange the official cue titles which appeared in one of the games (not all tracks appeared in the game, and thus there were more cues). This is someone's presumed list of cue division and not meant to be official. The title names appearing on the list are official. The cue number of "6M7 The Great Duel" is the only one that can be confirmed as matching with a proper number as this appeared in one of the Episode I bonus videos.1m? Star Wars (Main Title)1m? The Arrival1m? Gas Leak1m? Droid Fight1m? Queen Amidala1m? The Droid Invasion1m? Introducing Jar Jar1m? Bubble World1m? Gone Fishin'2m? Darth Sidious2m? Tentacles2m? Theed Palace Arrival2m? You're Under Arrest2m? Escape from Naboo2m? Intro Darth Maul2m? Arrival at Tatooine2m? [Title Unknown]2m? [Title Unknown]3m? Running Out of Time3m? [Title Unknown]3m? Talk of Podracing3m? Watto's Deal3m? Kids at Play3m? [Title Unknown]3m? The Sith Spacecraft3m? [Title Unknown]3m? Flag Parade3m? Jabba Introduction3m? Start Your Engine (unused)3m? The Race Begins 4m? Anakin Defeats Sebulba 4m? Anakin's Great Victory4m? Anakin Is Free4m? Darth and Qui-Gon4m? Coruscant Arrival4m? Queen and Palpatine5m? High Council Meeting5m? The Senate5m? Anakin's Test5m? He Is the Chosen One5m? [Title Unknown]5m? Naboo Temple5m? The Gungans5m? War Plans6m? Forest Mist 6m? The Armies Face Off6m? Moving Forward 6m? Take To Your Ships6m? Laser Fight March6m? Anakin Takes Off6m? The Big Army6m? The Droid Battle6m? Up the Wire6m7 The Great Duel 6m? Crash Landing6m? Qui-Gon's Noble End6m? Battleship Destroyed6m? The End of Darth Maul7m? [Title Unknown]7m? Qui-Gon's Funeral7m? Augie's Great Municipal Band7m? End Title7m? End Title Part II Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
steb74 53 Posted April 21, 2010 Share Posted April 21, 2010 I wrote this in an earlier post, perhaps you missed it.I've looked at the written scores to the following cues -1M7 Introducing Jar jar3M6 The Sith Spacecraft (I haven't looked at this one but a friend of mine gave me the slate number from his copy)3M10 ?? (Jabba Introduction/Start Your Engine, all one cue)3M11 The Race Begins4M2 Anakin Defeats Sebulba5M4+5 The Chosen One Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Datameister 2,044 Posted April 21, 2010 Share Posted April 21, 2010 And let's not forget that an insert or alternate beginning was recorded for ROTS's 7M7, "A Home for the Twins." The album version doesn't contain any microedits - the film version is expanded. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
steb74 53 Posted April 21, 2010 Share Posted April 21, 2010 I agree and it makes you wonder how many more inserts, etc, might have been recorded and not listed on the official cue list. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Datameister 2,044 Posted April 21, 2010 Share Posted April 21, 2010 True. Hopefully not too many, though. As far as I'm aware, all the other material we have is accounted for, but I could be mistaken.Side note, but I must say, I really wonder what the score for "Palpatine's TV Set" looked like. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
King Mark 3,631 Posted April 21, 2010 Share Posted April 21, 2010 And let's not forget that an insert or alternate beginning was recorded for ROTS's 7M7, "A Home for the Twins." The album version doesn't contain any microedits - the film version is expanded.i still don't buy that Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts