-
Posts
2,127 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
4
Smeltington last won the day on August 21 2023
Smeltington had the most liked content!
Profile
-
Title (custom text underneath your username)
a bigger JWFan than you
Recent Profile Visitors
10,473 profile views
-
bored reacted to a post in a topic: On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
-
bored reacted to a post in a topic: On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
-
Yavar Moradi reacted to a post in a topic: On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
-
Yavar Moradi reacted to a post in a topic: On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
-
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: Temple of Doom is celebrating 40 years in 2024
-
On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
Smeltington replied to JoeinAR's topic in General Discussion
I wish he thought of that! -
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: Temple of Doom is celebrating 40 years in 2024
-
On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
Smeltington replied to JoeinAR's topic in General Discussion
Lol, yeah it was really poorly thought through. Just to create a manufactured obstacle for the love story, he had to decide that ALL Jedi were celibate. Given that being strong in the force is passed down from parent to child, and given that the training has to start at such a young age, they really should just breed their own younglings instead of going out in the world and taking random children back to Coruscant. -
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
-
Chen G. reacted to a post in a topic: On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
-
Yavar Moradi reacted to a post in a topic: On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
-
On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
Smeltington replied to JoeinAR's topic in General Discussion
Ok, but in the actual movie, Luke's father is a Jedi. And that wouldn't be possible if his father was celibate. -
Edmilson reacted to a post in a topic: On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
-
On a scale of 1 to 10(best) rate Attack of the Clones
Smeltington replied to JoeinAR's topic in General Discussion
The idea that Jedi can't have romantic relationships was obviously invented specifically for this movie to allow a FORBIDDEN LOVE story just to make everything spicy. A la Titanic, or Romeo and Juliet. And I guess it also conveniently puts Anakin more at odds with the Jedi order. The only thing that keeps the concept from being even more ridiculous is that the Jedi order is already monk-like. But this idea is certainly not there to tell us anything about relationships and attachment, it's just for dramatic purposes. And the movie isn't asking us to agree with the rules of the Jedi order, it's asking us to delight in the fact that the love story happened against the odds. -
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: Best single in-film statement of every major Star Wars theme?
-
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: Temple of Doom is celebrating 40 years in 2024
-
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: Temple of Doom is celebrating 40 years in 2024
-
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: Temple of Doom is celebrating 40 years in 2024
-
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: James Bond is better than everything
-
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: John Williams' Film Night at Tanglewood, Aug 2 and 3, 2024
-
ThePenitentMan1 reacted to a post in a topic: new discovery - original Cantina Band cue title
-
new discovery - original Cantina Band cue title
Smeltington replied to enderdrag64's topic in JOHN WILLIAMS
I would think a Williams scoring session for a jazz-style piece would be different from a typical jazz recording session, in that all the solos would be written by Williams, rather than improvised by the soloists, and therefore there shouldn't be too much variation in the length of different takes. Maybe some small variation due to the cantina pieces possibly being recorded "wild" without having to sync to the picture. But Williams probably had a tempo in mind that would keep most takes to roughly the same length. Someone with more specific knowledge of the cantina band sheet music and recording process could probably address these speculations better, and hopefully will! -
Smeltington reacted to a post in a topic: John Williams returning to Vienna for two concerts, December 7 and 8, 2024
-
Andy reacted to a post in a topic: The ALIEN FRANCHISE Appreciation thread.
-
Who says the petition failed?? Although, Disney probably have a policy by now of ignoring all fan petitions related to Star Wars Mike def knows we want Star Wars, and Indy. There's no way he wouldn't pursue any possible avenues that could lead to expansions. I don't think we need to worry about him at all.
-
Not sure if this is an insult to Williams, or a compliment?
-
Two performances of The Force Awakens this September at Symphony Hall in Boston! https://www.bso.org/events/star-wars-the-force-awakens?performance=2024-09-05-19:30
-
Harry Potter - Live to Projection Concerts
Smeltington replied to bollemanneke's topic in JOHN WILLIAMS
Not exactly LTP, but the Boston Pops have a Harry Potter concert coming up this year that looks very exciting! "A Grand Suite from Harry Potter" on Sept 7 and 8. No program listed yet, but it mentions it's John Williams' music, so hopefully that means the concert suites from all three of the films he scored, and maybe some extra material from the score like they included in Boston Pops' Star Wars concert last year. https://www.bso.org/events/a-grand-suite-from-harry-potter?performance=2024-09-07-19:30