Jump to content

aj_vader

Members
  • Posts

    1,226
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Posts posted by aj_vader

  1. 1 hour ago, ciarlese said:

     

    I watched ROTJ at the Bridgewater Hall and the music was covered by voice and sound effects for pretty much the whole concert. I send then an email to complain about it (after all I had paid nearly £100 for a "live music concert"...)  and they replied they are not responsible for the mixing as it's something set in advance and they have no control on.

    Went to watch it at the RAH later on and it was much better, similar to all the previous live movie concerts I had attended there.

    I know why the E.T. one was so much better, because the Halle Orchestra put the event on and Disney Concerts weren't producing it. Disney Concerts are the producers of every Star Wars Live To Picture unfortunately. 

  2. 51 minutes ago, Tom Guernsey said:

    All the ones I've seen at the Royal Albert Hall have had subtitles. I do rather wish they would dial down the dialogue and sound effects a bit more, or maybe remove them completely, and not bother showing the film. Oh and removing any post-production edits to the music. ;-)

    I agree, it's far too loud (dialogue, sound effects). The best mix was when I saw A New Hope by the LSO in 2018 (Royal Albert Hall) [Saturday Evening showing], however it was still too loud for my liking. 

     

    The worst one was Empire Strikes Back in the Albert Hall (Dirk Brossè and London Philharmonia). I was sat in the stalls right behind the engineers/producers and someone went down and collared one of them, essentially asking them to turn the sound and dialogue down as the music in places was barely audible. I couldn't hear everything said as it was the interval, but it seemed to be a little heated. The engineer ultimately said something along the lines of, "it's standardised and we can't change it". The London Philharmonia are obviously a great orchestra, but they don't have the same 'clout' as the London Symphony Orchestra, so the Empire concert was easily the weakest of the original trilogy presentations there at The Royal Albert Hall. 

     

    I saw E.T. at The Bridgewater Hall in Manchester and thats a much better venue for this (I think), the balance was excellent throughout. 

  3. 5 hours ago, Corellian2019 said:

    Long overdue, but here are snapshots of the Empire Strikes Back LTP concert from May 19

     

    One thing that I didn't expect, and somewhat irritated me, was the decision to include subtitles for the film. @Matt S., was there subtitles for the ROTJ concert?

    IMG_2514.jpg

    IMG_2519.jpg

    IMG_2517.jpg

    IMG_2518.jpg

    Yes, they all include subtitles. E.T did as well. I would assume they all do. 

  4. These Dolby Atmos releases show the state that the Jedi tapes must be in. These are all mono centre channel rips which highlight the 'data' missing from Jedi's transfers compared with A New Hope. 

     

    Main Titles - A New Hope

     

    Tie Fighter Attack - A New Hope 

     

     

    Finale - Empire Strikes Back

     

     

    Return of the Jedi

     

     

    It sounds like they've maybe put reverb over the tape transfers to try and mask the issues. It sounds like aggressive mp3 compression as well. 

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.