Jump to content

Don Davis' THE MATRIX (1999) - 2021 Complete Edition by Varese Sarabande (2xCD / 2xSACD / 3xLP)


Jay
 Share

Recommended Posts

41 minutes ago, Marian Schedenig said:

 

No SACD content can be played on a regular CD player.

If the SACD includes CDDA content, that can be played on a regular CD player.

 

No DVD-A content can be player on a regular DVD player.

If the DVD-A includes DVD-V content, that can be played on a regular DVD player.

 

Yes!

 

Quote

 

Granted, the difference may be hardware vs software, because DVD-A and DVD-V use the same file system, but in case of a DVD-A it contains files that cannot be played by a regular player, whereas as far as I know an SACD will have the SACD and CDDA portions on different physical layers and only SACD specific hardware may have the right layer to even get the digital data off the disc in the first place.

 

Absolutely correct

 

Quote

The end result is the same, except for the important difference that any computer DVD drive can rip the full DVD-A content, but I don't think you can rip the SACD layer without special hardware.

 

Also correct, except you have to break the law to rip the data on a commercial DVD (crack the encryption). 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, Jay said:

Also correct, except you have to break the law to rip the data on a commercial DVD (crack the encryption). 

 

The laws obviously differ from country to country, but I'm pretty sure the latest situation has been (for years - I believe both in the EU and the US?) that the CSS encryption mechanism employed by DVDs has been deemed to weak to count as effective encryption, hence cracking it is legal. Blu-rays are a different matter, because the encryption is stronger and the (absurd) law holds.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, Marian Schedenig said:

I believe both in the EU and the US?) that the CSS encryption mechanism employed by DVDs has been deemed to weak to count as effective encryption, hence cracking it is legal. 

 

I didn't know that - that's pretty interesting!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Jay said:

I didn't know that - that's pretty interesting!

 

It originally was illegal in the US (as part of the Patriot Act I believe?), as was exporting it (encryption technology = military stuff), so people started printing sections of the cracking code on T-Shirts to smuggle it out of the country. As far as I remember, the ease and short time in which it was cracked ultimately lead to it being judged too simple to be worthy of legal protection.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, Jay said:

 

That isn't true.  DVD-A and DVD-V are different and incompatible formats that happen to get pressed to the same medium.

 

The only way a standard DVD player could play content on a DVD-A disc is if the makers of that disc chose to add a DVD-V layer that has the same (musical) content as the DVD-A layer, but it'd be in a lower bitrate.  For example, the DVD-A discs that came in the first pressings of the LOTR CRs did this.  IIRC, there might have been a part of the standard that required them to include a DVD-V layer on every DVD-A disc, I cannot recall for sure right now, but that DVD-V layer could technically have different music or a different mix of the same music on top of being a different bitrate.

 

This is correct. DVD-As typically also included a DVD-V layer (in lower sound quality -- maybe even lossy?) just like SACDs typically include(d) a regular Redbook CD layer in addition to a stereo SACD layer and sometimes/often also a surround SACD layer. When putting a hybrid SACD into a regular CD player, only the CD layer is being read. And when putting a DVD-A disc into a regular DVD player, only the DVD-V layer is being read. One needs special players to do the higher quality audio on either format, though they are backwards compatible as I've explained.


This is one thing that was thankfully simplified with Blu-ray Audio, which plays normally in maximum audio quality on ANY Blu-ray player.

 

EDIT:

6 hours ago, Marian Schedenig said:

No SACD content can be played on a regular CD player.

If the SACD includes CDDA content, that can be played on a regular CD player.

No DVD-A content can be player on a regular DVD player.

If the DVD-A includes DVD-V content, that can be played on a regular DVD player.

 

Granted, the difference may be hardware vs software, because DVD-A and DVD-V use the same file system, but in case of a DVD-A it contains files that cannot be played by a regular player, whereas as far as I know an SACD will have the SACD and CDDA portions on different physical layers and only SACD specific hardware may have the right layer to even get the digital data off the disc in the first place.

 

The end result is the same, except for the important difference that any computer DVD drive can rip the full DVD-A content, but I don't think you can rip the SACD layer without special hardware.

 

Or maybe I didn't need to write my own explanation, LOL.

 

Yavar

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My copy arrived in the mail yesterday!


Haven't opened it yet, or really had a chance to look at it; It was left on my front stoop, and in between when it was left there and when I got home from work it utterly DOWNPOURED rain completely soaking the package.  I had to wipe everything dry with a towel.  Thank goodness for shrinkwrap!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Happened to my mail a few weeks ago - we had two packages on our porch and the clouds dumped out.  One was a yellow padded envelope and that thing soaked through, but luckily it was just some garment my spouse bought.  The other had an expensive David Bowie box set in jt, but thankfully it was the slightly hardier glossy padded envelope, so most of the water didn’t sink in.  The SHRINK WRAP did the rest.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is the digital download 16/44.1 or is it high res? They really should put this info in the listing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They sure should, yep.

 

I'd wager dollars to donuts any format option is all 16/44.1

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I asked about the 5.1 and they replied that they looked into it, but could not make it work with the delivery system they chose. Pity. I would have payed at least 30 Euro for the multichannel tracks which would be still half of the price of the SACD (due to postage and customs) for me. Heck, I would have payed at least 40, which is double of the regular download.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What? The common standardised formats  provide lossless multichannel sound, and yet there are viable distribution platforms that cannot handle any of these formats?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not that I don't understand or that I don't believe, more that I've seen enough about format politics, locked format ecosystems, and DRM platforms that (by definition) care only about maximising profit from the masses instead of supporting all features and use cases to not be surprised that the logistics for content creators are much more complicated than they should be.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have listened to the samples on Qobuz and ... what the fuck is going on with the volume of this release. It seems very volatile and I'm hesitant to buy it therefore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines.