Star Wars: Tales from Galaxy's Edge - Scores by Bear McCreary, Danny Piccione, Joseph Trapanese

[Jay 18395]

 

[Jurassic Shark 6317]

Song previews?

[Jay 18395]

Marketing people don't know the difference between a score cue and song

[Jurassic Shark 6317]

Bummer, I was hoping for a SW musical.

[Marian Schedenig 3107]

22 minutes ago, Jurassic Shark said:

Bummer, I was hoping for a SW musical.

 

If anybody could do something like that, it would probably be McCreary.

[Edmilson 1739]

A McCreary Star Wars score could be interesting. Less sure about Trapanese, though, his scores tend to be very electronic and "RCP-like".

 

Don't know who is Danny Piccione.

[karelm 1880]

3 hours ago, Jay said:

 

 

That's great!  Joe is very talented and a very nice guy and huge JW fan.  Bear is great too.  Looks like a solid line up.

[DrTenma 83]

11 hours ago, Edmilson said:

A McCreary Star Wars score could be interesting. Less sure about Trapanese, though, his scores tend to be very electronic and "RCP-like".

 

Don't know who is Danny Piccione.

Agree, McCreary could be very interesting and Trapanese depends... 

 

I hope Disney release an album with the music from Galaxy Edge and that someone uses Williams themes. For me is a pity how disconnected everything might be.

[Arpy 3707]

Excited to hear Trapanese's involvement. 

[karelm 1880]

18 hours ago, Edmilson said:

A McCreary Star Wars score could be interesting. Less sure about Trapanese, though, his scores tend to be very electronic and "RCP-like".

 

Don't know who is Danny Piccione.

 

Joe is very talented.  Before he was famous I hung out in his studio where we talked about JW and shared some of our orchestral demos with each other and I was blown away by the quality of what he produced, it was very much in the JW and swashbuckling cinematic vein which is not the famous scores he is known for which are adaptations of electronic music. 

[SilverTrumpet 154]

Bear's probably been at the top of my list for Star Wars after the composers we've already heard from.

[CGCJ 145]

 

[CGCJ 145]

 

[Jay 18395]

Hmm that one's kinda weird.

 

Just noticed Bear McCreary's was posted too. That one isn't very exciting either

 

 

[Thor 3761]

Just to be clear -- these are compositions for various rides inside the Galaxy's Edge attraction in Disneyland?

[Falco 2352]

1 minute ago, Thor said:

Just to be clear -- these are compositions for various rides inside the Galaxy's Edge attraction in Disneyland?

No, these are compositions for a VR "game"

https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Star_Wars:_Tales_from_the_Galaxy's_Edge

[Thor 3761]

6 minutes ago, Spider-Fal said:

No, these are compositions for a VR "game"

https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Star_Wars:_Tales_from_the_Galaxy's_Edge

 

I see, thanks. Intriguing. I have a friend who works in VR. I'll ask him about this game the next time I meet him.

[DarthDementous 254]

Very underwhelming. None of these sound like they belong in the Star Wars universe (except for the Cantina music), and what's worse is that they don't really bring their own unique soundscape to compensate so it just comes off as sounding generic.

Seeing footage of Yoda instructing you in a Jedi temple and hearing this is going to be an extremely jarring Star Wars experience:

 

[Falco 2352]

LOL, save that for Tron 3 Joseph!

[Arpy 3707]

7 hours ago, DarthDementous said:

Very underwhelming. None of these sound like they belong in the Star Wars universe (except for the Cantina music), and what's worse is that they don't really bring their own unique soundscape to compensate so it just comes off as sounding generic.

Seeing footage of Yoda instructing you in a Jedi temple and hearing this is going to be an extremely jarring Star Wars experience:

 

Exactly, these pieces sound like generic scores from other games and films, and in the context of Star Wars feel like imposters. 

I was always reticent to think Star Wars music had to sound one way - the Williams' way - but when you wedge modern scoring sensibilities into an already established soundscape, you run the risk of interfering with that familiar sound. I was disappointed by McCreary's and Trapanese's pieces because there we have two competent composers who've written for the orchestra, just chuck that sound and style out the window.

[SilverTrumpet 154]

McCreary is way better than that track he put out. What a disappointment. 

[crumbs 8398]

Very disappointing. They just sound like generic atmospheric tracks from Mass Effect or something.

 

Not even vaguely Star Wars-ian.